ポスト #5001 · 2017-08-10 05:22:58pmにポスト 6.7年前
PureBlue | |
---|---|
Member | |
2,925 ポスト | |
Reg. 2009-04-08 | |
"I'm your thorn." |
Holy shit the Miku song is even less of a 16 than Emera is
ポスト #5002 · 2017-08-10 06:24:25pmにポスト 6.7年前
Quote: Zowayix
^ So how did we suddenly get from 0 to 2 brand new lineouts of the full song? That would mean two more passes, both of them lineouts, and neither of them coming up as separate videos.
Koji passed it twice, probably grinding it quickly to make the video. Remember that it is just a 13, it's not too hard. The only real reason there were so few passes on it before was because of the ENDYMION ESP requirement and because of the awful sync on it. Since the requirement has been lowered and the timing fixed, there's been a lot more passes and a lot better scores on AFA.
ポスト #5003 · 2017-08-10 10:01:26pmにポスト 6.7年前
dominatorstrangeman8 | |
---|---|
Member+ | |
2,165 ポスト | |
Reg. 2011-01-13 | |
"Pls" |
Quote: PureBlue
Holy shit the Miku song is even less of a 16 than Emera is
Yeah no shit, I just compared it to nephilim Delta And honestly, they look somewhat similar in difficulty...
Just, the Miku song is longer....
ポスト #5004 · 2017-08-10 10:14:48pmにポスト 6.7年前
wrsw | |
---|---|
Member | |
342 ポスト | |
Reg. 2016-01-01 | |
"Sleep cancelled due to COVID-19." |
Last updated: 2017-08-10 10:18pm
Miku's runs at 240 (compared to Nephilim Delta's 220), and is about 20-odd seconds shorter.
If we say the song is a harder version of Nephilim Delta, which is a 15, then we can make the argument that this should be a 16.
EDIT: Wait a minute Nephilim Delta's a 14 nevermind argument doesn't work at all
EDIT #2: Yeah the best argument is that it's a 20 BPM slower version of Illegal Function Call, but has higher step density than IFC does (699 vs. 729 steps, both songs being about the same length) That's the only working argument for this being a 16. Otherwise, it's a 15, really.
If we say the song is a harder version of Nephilim Delta, which is a 15, then we can make the argument that this should be a 16.
EDIT: Wait a minute Nephilim Delta's a 14 nevermind argument doesn't work at all
EDIT #2: Yeah the best argument is that it's a 20 BPM slower version of Illegal Function Call, but has higher step density than IFC does (699 vs. 729 steps, both songs being about the same length) That's the only working argument for this being a 16. Otherwise, it's a 15, really.
ポスト #5005 · 2017-08-10 10:35:46pmにポスト 6.7年前
Nevermind
Anywhat, IFC 699 steps crammed into a 1:59 song whereas Miku's song is well over 2 minutes long with not much in the means if heavy crossovers, streams, or jumps...
It honestly looks more like an extremely lengthy 14
There's really not much bumping it up from that, tbh
Anywhat, IFC 699 steps crammed into a 1:59 song whereas Miku's song is well over 2 minutes long with not much in the means if heavy crossovers, streams, or jumps...
It honestly looks more like an extremely lengthy 14
There's really not much bumping it up from that, tbh
ポスト #5006 · 2017-08-11 12:23:40amにポスト 6.7年前
RGTM | |
---|---|
Moderator+ | |
7,206 ポスト | |
Reg. 2007-07-19 | |
"BBCode Not Allowed" |
Singles tier lists updated to include the Vocaloid licenses.
http://ddrcommunity.com/ddr-difficulty-tier-list/ (Remember, based on timing/scoring difficulty)
Doubles position for Disappearance of Miku to come later.
http://ddrcommunity.com/ddr-difficulty-tier-list/ (Remember, based on timing/scoring difficulty)
Doubles position for Disappearance of Miku to come later.
ポスト #5007 · 2017-08-11 01:06:53amにポスト 6.7年前
I hate to be that guy but uhh...
You're lacking one extra less than symbol...
That chart is a 14...
Doesn't matter that it has over 700+ notes and goes 240 bpm those patterns are way too simple and way too broken enough to not even warrant being labeled a 15...
Imean, that's just the way I see it, idunno...
You're lacking one extra less than symbol...
That chart is a 14...
Doesn't matter that it has over 700+ notes and goes 240 bpm those patterns are way too simple and way too broken enough to not even warrant being labeled a 15...
Imean, that's just the way I see it, idunno...
ポスト #5008 · 2017-08-11 01:43:02amにポスト 6.7年前
wrsw | |
---|---|
Member | |
342 ポスト | |
Reg. 2016-01-01 | |
"Sleep cancelled due to COVID-19." |
Last updated: 2017-08-11 01:51am
Yeah, it's the second-most flagrant mis-rate on the history of the X-scale (the first-most being FLOWER, which was originally somehow a 17 (now a 15)), though it's I still think it's almost always better to rate higher than rate lower, as lower mis-rates actually end rounds.
(And I specify most flagrant mis-rate on the X-scale, because on the classic scale, SuperNOVA 2 was a complete mess)
(EDIT: And even before then, how the hell were Bag or Sakura 10-footers on classic scale?!)
(And I specify most flagrant mis-rate on the X-scale, because on the classic scale, SuperNOVA 2 was a complete mess)
(EDIT: And even before then, how the hell were Bag or Sakura 10-footers on classic scale?!)
ポスト #5009 · 2017-08-11 02:20:54amにポスト 6.7年前
SomethingRandom | |
---|---|
Member | |
2,798 ポスト | |
Reg. 2015-02-21 | |
"bootylicious " |
they were rated 10 because of their speed (despite mods being a thing at the time, maybe Konami thought players still used x1)
ポスト #5010 · 2017-08-11 03:30:19pmにポスト 6.7年前
PaperSak | |
---|---|
Member | |
1,248 ポスト | |
Reg. 2010-09-16 | |
"Take your hater shades off." |
The silver lining of Disappearance of Hatsune Miku is we now have a song where people can't gripe about the background being distracting... but the chart is to bland that distractions don't matter.
I have more negative comments than it deserves, but this addition is still so weird... and it's still not the kors k Miku song.
I have more negative comments than it deserves, but this addition is still so weird... and it's still not the kors k Miku song.
ポスト #5011 · 2017-08-11 06:43:54pmにポスト 6.7年前
maxpowr90 | |
---|---|
Member | |
498 ポスト | |
Reg. 2007-09-28 | |
Quote: SomethingRandom
they were rated 10 because of their speed (despite mods being a thing at the time, maybe Konami thought players still used x1)
The speed changes for Sakura are still not easy, and I still think it's a 14 [I feel there are easier 14s than Sakura and many classics are underrated] but there is already a misrated thread for this debate.
The only reason I'd rate Hatsune Miku a 15 is the time length [a new DDR AC record of 2:21] for stamina but even then, the song is about as difficult as Houkago Stride making it a medium-to-hard 14.
ポスト #5012 · 2017-08-11 08:40:05pmにポスト 6.7年前
Gpop | |
---|---|
Member | |
208 ポスト | |
Not Set | |
Reg. 2010-01-17 | |
Quote: dominatorstrangeman8
I hate to be that guy but uhh...
You're lacking one extra less than symbol...
That chart is a 14...
Doesn't matter that it has over 700+ notes and goes 240 bpm those patterns are way too simple and way too broken enough to not even warrant being labeled a 15...
Imean, that's just the way I see it, idunno...
You're lacking one extra less than symbol...
That chart is a 14...
Doesn't matter that it has over 700+ notes and goes 240 bpm those patterns are way too simple and way too broken enough to not even warrant being labeled a 15...
Imean, that's just the way I see it, idunno...
nah, I would say it's a 15, because I would say it's about the same as a slightly faster Houkago Stride, which is a 14 (but imo Houkago Stride it's borderline 15 because it's actually very tiring to be a 14 with it being very streamy at 225 bpm).
ポスト #5013 · 2017-08-11 09:27:01pmにポスト 6.7年前
Houkago Stride has more lengthy streams and complex crossovers than TDoHM
I guess the only reason I'd give it a 15 rating is maybe because of that silly jump in the middle of the near-ending stream
I guess the only reason I'd give it a 15 rating is maybe because of that silly jump in the middle of the near-ending stream
ポスト #5014 · 2017-08-11 09:33:44pmにポスト 6.7年前
NewbStepper | |
---|---|
Moderator+ | |
2,516 ポスト | |
Reg. 2013-05-23 | |
"Crybabies unite~ ♡" |
That, and the 729-step notecount (previously unseen in anything under a 17). Most high-end 14 challengers will find it to be quite the endurance test and find it a struggle to remain consistent on the song for that long.
ポスト #5015 · 2017-08-12 04:30:06amにポスト 6.7年前
I don't think step count should have that much of a sway over ratings considering a song like NGO on both Heavy and Oni has less steps than an average 13 or 14 and yet still deserve its 16 and 18 ratings, and the Space Prim song has a lot of notes on Heavy while still not deserving anything higher than a 14
ポスト #5016 · 2017-08-12 04:56:20amにポスト 6.7年前
SomethingRandom | |
---|---|
Member | |
2,798 ポスト | |
Reg. 2015-02-21 | |
"bootylicious " |
also illegal function call
ポスト #5017 · 2017-08-12 04:58:20amにポスト 6.7年前
wrsw | |
---|---|
Member | |
342 ポスト | |
Reg. 2016-01-01 | |
"Sleep cancelled due to COVID-19." |
Last updated: 2017-08-12 05:06am
Quote: PureBlue
NGO on both Heavy and Oni has less steps than an average 13 or 14 and yet still deserve its 16 and 18 ratings
Don't want to be that guy but NGO is only a 15 on expert, not a 16 (and honestly it's an easy 15 at that, only one part is any difficult)
EDIT: Also the for that is also incredibly stupid and no one likes it (like Jumpspam? Yeah, I thought so), a better comparison would be Neutrino, which is a 16 and 18, with stepcounts of 499 and 570, and isn't also complete garbage, compared to the arguably easier Come To Life, also 16 and 18, but with 611 and 730 (and is actually quite good, chart wise).
ポスト #5018 · 2017-08-12 07:13:53amにポスト 6.7年前
NewbStepper | |
---|---|
Moderator+ | |
2,516 ポスト | |
Reg. 2013-05-23 | |
"Crybabies unite~ ♡" |
Last updated: 2017-08-12 07:43am
Quote: wrsw
Don't want to be that guy but NGO is only a 15 on expert, not a 16 (and honestly it's an easy 15 at that, only one part is any difficult)
I don't really want to go on a tangent here but I wouldn't say NGO S- is easy for a 15. Yes, it's true that only one part is truly difficult (the ending), but said ending stream is 95 notes in length and requires footwork that is considered complex at level 15. You could start from a full gauge and fail just from the ending run.On top of that, the fact that it has a very low notecount overall (371 steps and 10 freezes in total) makes the 95-step ending account for a quarter of all notes. Add the slowdown section that is difficult to time correctly, and you have a 15 that has a rather high scoring difficulty. It's not a chart I would recommend to someone who is just ready to move up to this level.
Quote: PureBlue
I don't think step count should have that much of a sway over ratings considering a song like NGO on both Heavy and Oni has less steps than an average 13 or 14 and yet still deserve its 16 and 18 ratings, and the Space Prim song has a lot of notes on Heavy while still not deserving anything higher than a 14
I agree in principle. Notecounts typically raise or lower a rating by 1 level at most. That Prim song on actually has easy footwork for a 14, and it's rated that mainly because of its sheer volume of notes.ポスト #5019 · 2017-08-12 04:31:41pmにポスト 6.7年前
Quote: PureBlue
and the Space Prim song has a lot of notes on Heavy while still not deserving anything higher than a 14
It's a 15 on doubles with less notes.But it doesn't matter because ratings should be more of a guideline rather than "this rating must mean this chart has this in it and if it doesn't it is WRONG AND BAD". If it is misrated, it doesn't change the chart at all.
Also Disappearance probably isn't as complicated as many fan charts for it simply because it is a licensed song and making it an 18/19 is probably an awful idea if that means it can be removed at any time when the license runs out.
ポスト #5020 · 2017-08-12 04:48:54pmにポスト 6.7年前
PureBlue | |
---|---|
Member | |
2,925 ポスト | |
Reg. 2009-04-08 | |
"I'm your thorn." |
Quote: wrsw
Quote: PureBlue
NGO on both Heavy and Oni has less steps than an average 13 or 14 and yet still deserve its 16 and 18 ratings
Don't want to be that guy but NGO is only a 15 on expert, not a 16 (and honestly it's an easy 15 at that, only one part is any difficult)
Could have sworn it was a 16 but you're right, my apologies, my point still stands. NewbStepper is completely right in saying that the ending is what justifies its rating. But it's justified regardless.