Post #521 · Posted at 2017-06-12 09:55:50pm 8 years ago
![]() | |
---|---|
![]() |
Member |
1,958 Posts | |
![]() | |
Reg. 2010-02-25 | |
![]() ![]() | |
" ♫~~ I'm wired to the world ~~♫" |
Sorry to everyone who wasted votes on me. I spent too much time studying for the GRE (which I took today) and lost track of voting & submissions. I should've mentioned earlier that I may not have gotten my votes in on time.
Oh well. :/ Thanks for voting for it, I guess.
Oh well. :/ Thanks for voting for it, I guess.
Post #522 · Posted at 2017-06-12 10:34:44pm 8 years ago
Quote: Oni-91
- The artist must be male / identify as male. In the case of a group, all the group's members must all be / identify as male.
What's the rule regarding vocal samples? One of the songs I'm considering samples a female voice but the song's otherwise entirely written and produced by males.
Post #523 · Posted at 2017-06-12 10:37:00pm 8 years ago
![]() | |
---|---|
![]() |
Moderator+ |
13,518 Posts | |
![]() | |
Reg. 2006-10-20 | |
![]() ![]() | |
"Popular bisexual disaster" |
I wouldn't risk it.
Post #524 · Posted at 2017-06-12 10:39:59pm 8 years ago
![]() | |
---|---|
![]() |
Member |
1,958 Posts | |
![]() | |
Reg. 2010-02-25 | |
![]() ![]() | |
" ♫~~ I'm wired to the world ~~♫" |
For this new theme, does a song qualify if it was originally released before Dec 31, 1999 but you step a remix that came out in the 21st century?
Post #525 · Posted at 2017-06-12 10:42:22pm 8 years ago
![]() | |
---|---|
![]() |
Moderator+ |
13,518 Posts | |
![]() | |
Reg. 2006-10-20 | |
![]() ![]() | |
"Popular bisexual disaster" |
The song you're stepping would have been released post-99, so no.
Post #526 · Posted at 2017-06-12 11:30:58pm 8 years ago
![]() | |
---|---|
![]() |
Member |
38 Posts | |
![]() | |
Reg. 2015-11-25 | |
"I like trainskjcbqiefbqoicnoefi" |
Last updated: 2017-06-12 11:32pm
And I didn't place in the top 10. But that's ok because I'm a normal human being with a healthy ego.
*screams internally*
So many HM's though.
*screams internally*
So many HM's though.

Post #527 · Posted at 2017-06-13 12:37:26am 8 years ago
![]() | |
---|---|
![]() |
Member |
500 Posts | |
![]() | |
Reg. 2015-10-19 | |
"Pancakes!" |
So judging from the results, I'm going to assume that a MAX of 3 people either bothered to play something besides Blow Me Away's 10 or actually looked at the chart title and description of it and knew what was up.
Surprising, except not.
Surprising, except not.
Post #528 · Posted at 2017-06-13 02:30:41am 8 years ago
Silly thing for me to ask about but shouldn't this be week 7?
There's, to date:
Short
Zivision
Academy
Rock Out
Mighty #9
and Sentimental previously, and now this round
I would know about 7s, I've come in 7th so many times har har
Also basic if it's any consolation I played
and both of your edits (**during my judging), the ideas were interesting but I wasn't a huge fan of the execution; that being said I respect the risk you took.
There's, to date:
Short
Zivision
Academy
Rock Out
Mighty #9
and Sentimental previously, and now this round
I would know about 7s, I've come in 7th so many times har har
Also basic if it's any consolation I played

Post #529 · Posted at 2017-06-13 03:43:26am 8 years ago
Posting my first reviews for this contest (for [Rock Out] files) I apologize in advance for any typos. Let me know if you need any clarification.
Ranks + Votes
Comments:
Ranks + Votes
9.5/10
Astral Body +4
9.375
Chou Super Dragon Soul +3
noah +3
9.25
Blow Me Away +2
Ghost Hunters +2
Looking Up +1
9.0 (HMs)
I Wish I Was Your Cigarette
What The Hell
8.75 (also HMs)
Blood In the cut
Blue Tattoo
Breaking Up
Song 2
Versa
8.5
LOL
Nijiiro Yuenchi
Shala La
8.375
Never Look Back In Sorrow
8.25
Kyouran Hey Kids!
Nefertiti
8.0
CHASE/THE THRILL
7.875
Gimme Choco
7.75
City Escape
Be Rock U
Misery Business
7.5
GAIA (GITADORA EDITION)
Heart Attack
Good Night Paranoia
5.5
3s and 7s
Astral Body +4
9.375
Chou Super Dragon Soul +3
noah +3
9.25
Blow Me Away +2
Ghost Hunters +2
Looking Up +1
9.0 (HMs)
I Wish I Was Your Cigarette
What The Hell
8.75 (also HMs)
Blood In the cut
Blue Tattoo
Breaking Up
Song 2
Versa
8.5
LOL
Nijiiro Yuenchi
Shala La
8.375
Never Look Back In Sorrow
8.25
Kyouran Hey Kids!
Nefertiti
8.0
CHASE/THE THRILL
7.875
Gimme Choco
7.75
City Escape
Be Rock U
Misery Business
7.5
GAIA (GITADORA EDITION)
Heart Attack
Good Night Paranoia
5.5
3s and 7s
Comments:
3s and 7s
Many things that are horrendously upsetting: (1) I feel like what you currently have as 4th notes shoudl actually be 8th notes and vice versa (i.e. just press "insert" or "delete" once on your keyboard). Currently, it feels like your file has "blue note syndrome" when it doesn't need to. (2) I'm fairly positive the BPM is off/incorrect. It's either constant, when it should require a changing BPM over time, or the BPM itself is just wrong. (3) Certain rhythms make zero sense: The parts where you insert some 12ths(?) is not really accurate at all.
5.5/10
Astral Body
Wow, this is really good. Really interesting song, too (with interesting time signature changes) 9.5/10
Be RockU
It's not bad. I like the general DDR style of the chart (including many of the doublesteps), but I think it could be tweaked to more closely follow certain rhythms (trills going to the female vocals, for example)
7.75/10
Blood in the Cut
Rhythm choices were pretty spot on, patterns were pretty good, too. Only thing I was a little bothered about was the way the jacks were at the opening of the song. I'm pretty sure it musically makes more sense to have the patterns like D-D-L instead of D-L-L for example, to better reflect the pitch change. That was the main issue for me. That being said I really thought the jacks on the drum beat was a great choice. Also minor syncing issues exist (might be drifting)
8.75/10
Blow Me Away
That was great! I have zero problems with this chart!
9.75/10
Wow, the crossovers and turns in this chart are so plentiful! Only problem is that sometimes, they don't connect perfectly (without doublesteps), even if you guess the ambiguous parts correctly. Also I don't think the 32nds were supposed to be 32nds. THey seem more like 24ths to me in the music (also those patterns are REALLY harsh)
8.75/10
Blue Tattoo
Pretty good, for an easy chart. 8,75/10
PRetty good, too. 8.75/10
Breaking Up
Really good for the most part. Only thing was the seemingly confused rhythm choices towards the beginning. It seemed like you were switching back and forth between the guitar and the vocals. 8.75/10
CHASE/THE THRILL
It seems like you either tried to closely to go to too many things or you partially followed something and failed to follow through all the way. Aside from slightly less-than-perfect rhythm choices, IMO, it looks like a fun chart to play.
8/10
City Escape
definitely feels like this should've been double the BPM. I think the rhythms should've followed drums more closely, but this works alright.
7.75/10
GAIA (GITADORA Edition)
Rhythm choices are pretty good overall. Patterning...not so much. I'm not quite sure how familiar you are with playing DDR on a pad. The way some of these pattenrs turn up (particularly in longer 16th streams) would force the player to spin or double-step a 16th note, which is not ideal in the slightest.
7.5/10 (sloppy patterning is the major downfall of this chart)
Ghost Hunters
WHY IS EVERYTHIGN YOU DO SO PERFECT? 9.75/10
Actually this seemed slightly overkill in some parts, but it was still pretty good. 8.75/10
Gimme Choco
Looks like a fun chart to play. However, there are numerous rhythmical inaccuracies. I thought it was strange (and detrimental) that you chose not to accent the strong 8th notes that exist throughout the song. 8/10
Same comments here, for
, to a slightly worse degree 7.75/10
Props to the amazing sync, though!
OYASUMI (Good Night) PARANOIA
I thought rhythms were overall well-selected. However, there were a couple of inaccuracies throughout (the part that should be triplets but is stepped as 4th-16th-8th-16th rhythms and the trill at the end.) Also, the sync needs work and there are really long sections with left-facing syndrome. 7.5/10
I WISH I WAS YOUR CIGARETTE
This is really good. Not really any problems I could come up with. Looks pretty fun too. 9/10
Kyouran Hey Kids!
I don't know if I was the only one with this issue, but the sync was really off.
Otherwise, the chart's pretty good, for the most part. A couple rhythmical issues, IMO. When you follow the guitars at the beginning, i think during the second repetition of the rhythm the rhythms you currently have are off. Also I don't see why you didn't follow the guitars again later in the song.
8.25/10
LOL
Nothing too out of place. Nothing too stand-out-ish either. Technically sound. Rhythms worked relatively well. 8.5/10
Looking Up
I really liked this one. Only minor issue was that the 4-note jacks were always on the left foot. 9.25/10
Misery Business (it's hard not to be biased because I did this song, but with a different cut)
Great job with the stream in the middle of the song, changing the pattern with each pitch change! Good use of a break for the Freeze Arrows in the middle. Can't say I agree with some of the 8th triplets towards the beginning. Nice use of jumps in the chorus (for the guitar parts). I probably should've done that too.
7.75/10
Liked the jacks during that one part. Fit really nicely AND added difficulty. However, I feel like having 8th stream throughout the whole song was not the best way to add to the difficulty (nor were the jumpstreams). I guess I don't really have any other suggestions for you :/
7.75/10
Nefertiti
Well that was quite the difficulty spike. I don't really like the fact that the chart with solely to the guitars for the whole song. There was so much more in this song that could have also been stepped. Nice use of doublesteps, good patterns present.
8.25/10 (loss mostly because personal preference)
Never Look back in Sorrow
Very peculiar song. I like the speed changes. Chart's pretty good, too. Just a couple doublsteps towards the beginning. 8.75/10
I think you might've been pushing the dififculty a little too much with the chart. What's there is decent, despite not being stepped exactly to music. I do think it complements the song to an extent. 8.00/10
Nijiiro yuenchi (again bias)
Pretty good overall. I wondered a little bit why you stopped following the melody for brief periods of time. Also you have one or two instances of 12ths in that one section, but there are more instances of 12ths. I don't quite understand the motivation for that.
8.5/10
noah
Really good job! 9.25/10
Amazing! 9.5/10
Shala La
Really like the song. Chart is pretty decent, if only a little bit generic. Kinda wish it would follow specific elements of the song a little more (maybe vocals). I like what you did with the drum 12th trills. 8.5/10
Song2
Hey I actually know this song! I think you did a prety good job with it! A little confused why you said to C-mod this, it seemed fine to me. 8.75/10
This Heart Attack
Looks alright. I thought it was weird that you only accented very specific lines in the vocals towards the beginning. I think you should have stuck with whatever you were following or doing before. I also didn't really understand what the 16ths towards the end were going to (besides the drum 16ths). 7.5/10
Chou Super Dragon Soul
I really liked this chart 9.25/10
Also really well done. 9.5/10
Versa
I liked a lot of this chart. Most of the rhythm choices were great and patterns were good too! However, it wasn't perfect. I think the stop was scripted too early (it should have been on the 8th guitar, but was on the 4th earlier). Also I didn't like the last 4 16th trills. Otherwise, I like it a lot. 8.75/10
What The Hell
Wow, this was pretty good. Not really anything major I didn't like (just minor rhythm preferences towards the end) 9/10

5.5/10
Astral Body

Be RockU

7.75/10
Blood in the Cut

8.75/10
Blow Me Away

9.75/10

8.75/10
Blue Tattoo


Breaking Up

CHASE/THE THRILL

8/10
City Escape

7.75/10
GAIA (GITADORA Edition)

7.5/10 (sloppy patterning is the major downfall of this chart)
Ghost Hunters


Gimme Choco



Props to the amazing sync, though!
OYASUMI (Good Night) PARANOIA

I WISH I WAS YOUR CIGARETTE

Kyouran Hey Kids!

Otherwise, the chart's pretty good, for the most part. A couple rhythmical issues, IMO. When you follow the guitars at the beginning, i think during the second repetition of the rhythm the rhythms you currently have are off. Also I don't see why you didn't follow the guitars again later in the song.
8.25/10
LOL

Looking Up

Misery Business (it's hard not to be biased because I did this song, but with a different cut)

7.75/10

7.75/10
Nefertiti

8.25/10 (loss mostly because personal preference)
Never Look back in Sorrow


Nijiiro yuenchi (again bias)

8.5/10
noah


Shala La

Song2

This Heart Attack

Chou Super Dragon Soul


Versa

What The Hell

Post #530 · Posted at 2017-06-13 11:56:51am 8 years ago
![]() | |
---|---|
![]() |
Member |
10,356 Posts | |
![]() | |
Reg. 2007-04-06 | |
![]() ![]() |
Quote: hiddennames
Welp.
Is there some way to salvage our submission if we just reupload a slightly shorter cut?
Regardless, I would like some feedback on the chart even if it gets DQed (In the form of ghost points at least, or if you want to, an actual review)
You can update the file with a shorter cut but it won't count since it's past the deadline.Is there some way to salvage our submission if we just reupload a slightly shorter cut?
Regardless, I would like some feedback on the chart even if it gets DQed (In the form of ghost points at least, or if you want to, an actual review)
Post #531 · Posted at 2017-06-13 01:30:05pm 8 years ago
![]() | |
---|---|
![]() |
Member |
500 Posts | |
![]() | |
Reg. 2015-10-19 | |
"Pancakes!" |
Quote: mf32892

8.75/10
But it also wasn't meant to be a serious chart at all.
Post #532 · Posted at 2017-06-13 03:26:15pm 8 years ago
Thank you mf32892 for the awesome feedback. I must say that all of the Expert charts that I made were VERY terrible and I just haven't gotten enough practice to do a awesome job just like the rest of the people who are in the Summer Contest. 
another problem is that I'm in a conflict where I'm editing stepcharts and everytime when I reach a certain amount of times of editing the chart over and over again it kicks me out of the game

another problem is that I'm in a conflict where I'm editing stepcharts and everytime when I reach a certain amount of times of editing the chart over and over again it kicks me out of the game
Post #533 · Posted at 2017-06-13 03:32:47pm 8 years ago
![]() | |
---|---|
![]() |
Member |
38 Posts | |
![]() | |
Reg. 2015-11-25 | |
"I like trainskjcbqiefbqoicnoefi" |
Quote: mf32892
Kyouran Hey Kids!
I don't know if I was the only one with this issue, but the sync was really off.
Otherwise, the chart's pretty good, for the most part. A couple rhythmical issues, IMO. When you follow the guitars at the beginning, i think during the second repetition of the rhythm the rhythms you currently have are off. Also I don't see why you didn't follow the guitars again later in the song.
8.25/10

Otherwise, the chart's pretty good, for the most part. A couple rhythmical issues, IMO. When you follow the guitars at the beginning, i think during the second repetition of the rhythm the rhythms you currently have are off. Also I don't see why you didn't follow the guitars again later in the song.
8.25/10
I had some trouble when fixing the timing on the SM file. I used a different editor that didn't round off BPMs to the nearest 100th's. Hence, when I would correct them in the text file (using notepad) the stops would disappear. This was fixed in a later update I did before the 5pm UTC deadline though, so I don't know if you caught that.
Quote: hooky
Quote: daichiikamuzu
! ! ! UPDATE ! ! !
UPDATED:
SM FILE (Fixed errors with the stops)
VIDEO ADDED
AUDIO (Synced with video)
SM FILE (Fixed errors with the stops)
VIDEO ADDED
AUDIO (Synced with video)
I'm sure you know this (the audio is listed as LQ on the simfile page, after all), but the new audio is much, much quieter than the old audio. When you need the audio and video to sync up, you can use a program like Audacity to line it up right. Just match the wavelengths of the HQ audio and the video's audio and you'll get a perfect audio file!

That said, I had downloaded all the files up to mine so I could go ahead and start reviewing them, and this update was a massive improvement.

People probably didn't notice that I updated it and that's probably why my charts only had HM's and a few votes.
Post #534 · Posted at 2017-06-13 06:54:50pm 8 years ago
![]() | |
---|---|
![]() |
Member |
2,755 Posts | |
![]() | |
Reg. 2015-11-27 | |
![]() | |
"Mostly just lurking." |
Quote: daichiikamuzu
People probably didn't notice that I updated it and that's probably why my charts only had HM's and a few votes.
I played the updated version of your chart; the reason why I gave it an HM is because I had already chosen too many songs I had wanted to vote for and I wouldn't be able to vote for this one since I had used up all my 15 points.
Post #535 · Posted at 2017-06-13 07:27:24pm 8 years ago
![]() | |
---|---|
![]() |
Member |
42 Posts | |
![]() | |
Reg. 2016-10-11 | |
"Where the fuck did monday go" |
So for the latest theme, what's the verdict on if there's female backing vocals on parts, but the main group is otherwise guys?
Post #536 · Posted at 2017-06-13 09:43:32pm 8 years ago
![]() | |
---|---|
![]() |
Member+ |
8,622 Posts | |
![]() | |
Reg. 2008-02-24 | |
"icon by hypnosispkmn@tumblr" |
Quote: stylek226
Do I ever get a fucking point in this contest?
Quote: DigitalBasic
So judging from the results, I'm going to assume that a MAX of 3 people either bothered to play something besides Blow Me Away's 10 or actually looked at the chart title and description of it and knew what was up.
Surprising, except not.
You're not entitled to votes by participating in Summer Contest. If you want votes, get better.Surprising, except not.
Quote: daichiikamuzu
People probably didn't notice that I updated it and that's probably why my charts only had HM's and a few votes.
If they downloaded the pack I uploaded, it had the latest version. I wait until after the deadline to download the files and upload them together.Post #537 · Posted at 2017-06-14 03:50:35am 8 years ago
![]() | |
---|---|
![]() |
Member |
500 Posts | |
![]() | |
Reg. 2015-10-19 | |
"Pancakes!" |
Quote: chewi
You're not entitled to votes by participating in Summer Contest. If you want votes, get better.
There's a difference between "Give me points even though it is garbage" and "The entire simfile was judged unfairly"I didn't complain about Hollow Mind getting so low when I saw the votes, as I wasn't as big on it myself. It did not turn out to be that great to me and I did not care that it placed low as a result. Blow Me Away, on the other hand, I not only put more work into it, I believe it to actually be a good simfile. Not the best, definitely, but most certainly not bottom 5 material...
I know it was due to people only playing Challenge. That chart was not fun at all, and it only takes a look into the chart name and description to see that. Maybe I should have hinted at that being a joke chart more?
I guess that brings up a good question:
The rules do state a one chart minimum but it does not state that voting must occur on one chart only except for ZIv Academy III simply due to the nature of it. Perhaps that should be clarified so I know if I -- and everyone else, for that matter -- should start highlighting the specific charts we want to be scored rather than tossing it out and hoping people play the right thing. My impression of the one chart minimum rule was because of the nature of the contest being a new simfile every week, rather than a simfile in a much larger timeframe, and as such forcing a 3 chart minimum every week could be very taxing to a lot of people, but adding more could affect your votes in a positive way if you choose to add them.
Am I correct on that?
Post #538 · Posted at 2017-06-14 04:09:21am 8 years ago
![]() | |
---|---|
![]() |
Member+ |
8,622 Posts | |
![]() | |
Reg. 2008-02-24 | |
"icon by hypnosispkmn@tumblr" |
Well, I can only speak for myself, but I had no idea that Blow Me Away
was supposed to be a joke chart. But it didn't matter to me because I didn't play it. I guess other people don't use themes that support whatever you put that information in. I only play
for every file (unless it's a week like ZIv Academy or Mighty No. 9). There's no doubt that most people just play the hardest difficulty(s) when judging.
I think the one difficulty minimum rule can be used to avoid situations like this. You could always just submit the 1 difficulty you want judged and nothing else to avoid confusion.
Lastly, people are allowed to vote however they want. Not sure how you would make a rule that forces people to vote a specific way.


I think the one difficulty minimum rule can be used to avoid situations like this. You could always just submit the 1 difficulty you want judged and nothing else to avoid confusion.
Lastly, people are allowed to vote however they want. Not sure how you would make a rule that forces people to vote a specific way.
Post #539 · Posted at 2017-06-14 08:03:29am 8 years ago
![]() | |
---|---|
![]() |
Moderator+ |
13,518 Posts | |
![]() | |
Reg. 2006-10-20 | |
![]() ![]() | |
"Popular bisexual disaster" |
Quote: Wari
So for the latest theme, what's the verdict on if there's female backing vocals on parts, but the main group is otherwise guys?
The "which bit is the actual band and which bit is a session backing singer" thing is a bit of a gray area, so I'm just going to blanket say no on this one.I'm having trouble too, I tried to step Chains of Love until I realised that I didn't know whether the backing vocals at the end were a female or Andy Bell with his testicles in a vice.
Post #540 · Posted at 2017-06-14 08:03:56pm 8 years ago
![]() | |
---|---|
![]() |
Member+ |
8,622 Posts | |
![]() | |
Reg. 2008-02-24 | |
"icon by hypnosispkmn@tumblr" |