ポスト #41 · 2019-09-16 08:12:41amにポスト 4.7年前
Marten | |
---|---|
Moderator+ | |
1,037 ポスト | |
Reg. 2014-08-03 | |
"touch n go ride the flow" |
ポスト #42 · 2019-09-16 09:30:06amにポスト 4.7年前
forcednature | |
---|---|
Member | |
1,020 ポスト | |
Reg. 2012-06-12 | |
""Captain uwu"" |
Graphics made by TonyAkita!
Singles: 2 / 4 / 7 / 9
X-Scale: 3 / 6 / 10 / 13
Doubles: 4 / 7 / 9
X-Scale: 6 / 10 / 13
X-Scale: 3 / 6 / 10 / 13
Doubles: 4 / 7 / 9
X-Scale: 6 / 10 / 13
ポスト #43 · 2019-09-16 01:53:49pmにポスト 4.7年前
ポスト #44 · 2019-09-16 03:37:14pmにポスト 4.7年前
Pandemonium X | |
---|---|
Member | |
10,360 ポスト | |
Reg. 2007-04-06 | |
Everyone should be in. Upload those files now.
ポスト #46 · 2019-09-18 10:53:58amにポスト 4.7年前
ElijahPWG | |
---|---|
Member | |
43 ポスト | |
Reg. 2019-02-18 | |
":3" |
is it too late to sign up?
if not i'm in
if not i'm in
ポスト #47 · 2019-09-18 10:07:05pmにポスト 4.7年前
SomethingRandom | |
---|---|
Member | |
2,819 ポスト | |
Reg. 2015-02-21 | |
"bootylicious " |
Quote: Rules
15. You can still enter the contest up until the deadline for the qualifier round passes.
sorry the qualifier round deadline has already passed so you'll have to sit this contest out
ポスト #48 · 2019-09-19 12:31:42amにポスト 4.7年前
Pandemonium X | |
---|---|
Member | |
10,360 ポスト | |
Reg. 2007-04-06 | |
What SomethingRandom said.
ポスト #49 · 2019-09-22 04:24:12pmにポスト 4.7年前
ElijahPWG | |
---|---|
Member | |
43 ポスト | |
Reg. 2019-02-18 | |
":3" |
alright, that's okay owo
i'll wait for the next competition and for now i'll just practice making better simfiles lol
i'll wait for the next competition and for now i'll just practice making better simfiles lol
ポスト #50 · 2019-09-23 12:38:40amにポスト 4.7年前
I've decided to drop feedback to everyone's files this round, and plan to do so for every other round as well:
https://pastebin.com/yRAyB3KN
No hard grades or numerical ratings because I felt that it would shift or slide around. I judged the top two difficulties if there were multiple difficulties (so Challenge/Expert or Expert/Difficult).
Hope this helps anyone!
In exchange, if anyone could provide feedback to my file as well, that'd be helpful for me
https://pastebin.com/yRAyB3KN
No hard grades or numerical ratings because I felt that it would shift or slide around. I judged the top two difficulties if there were multiple difficulties (so Challenge/Expert or Expert/Difficult).
Hope this helps anyone!
In exchange, if anyone could provide feedback to my file as well, that'd be helpful for me
ポスト #51 · 2019-09-23 03:24:48amにポスト 4.7年前
Quote: talkion's review of Shellfie
Stagnant difficulty curve and feels repetitive due to the second half basically being mirrored from the first. If the patterning were more technical or demanding in the second half it could've helped solve this
You're not wrong about the repetition. That's why I used Shellfie for the qualifier and not the later rounds where things matter a bit more.
That being said, I personally don't like the idea of making a harder/more technical second half for the sake of avoiding repetition if the song doesn't actually feel like it should get harder. If there were more instruments in the second half or if the second half featured a key change, sure I'd change up the patterns. If the song feels more climactic, the steps get more climactic. In this case the song just repeats with no changes at all, so that's how the steps played out. Regardless of which option you pick it ends up being a sort of lose-lose situation IMO.
I'm willing to give feedback as well to anybody that wants it, just PM me! (talkion, I'll send you my feedback on your file later, I don't really have time to do it this instant.)
ポスト #52 · 2019-09-23 04:06:35amにポスト 4.7年前
talkion | |
---|---|
Member | |
195 ポスト | |
Reg. 2018-05-06 | |
Quote
That being said, I personally don't like the idea of making a harder/more technical second half for the sake of avoiding repetition if the song doesn't actually feel like it should get harder. If there were more instruments in the second half or if the second half featured a key change, sure I'd change up the patterns. If the song feels more climactic, the steps get more climactic. In this case the song just repeats with no changes at all, so that's how the steps played out. Regardless of which option you pick it ends up being a sort of lose-lose situation IMO.
So there are a few ways I think you could go about this without interrupting that kind of musical connection as much:
- Rely on patterns that get harder when mirrored. For example, you could have crossovers like LDRDR in the first half, which get harder to execute when flipped. I also find that, as people generally seem to be right foot dominant, shifting from right foot entry patterns to left foot entry patterns provides a minor source of difficulty change as well.
- Use patterns that look similar but require more movement. Between LUDUL and ULDLU, it's more dififcult to execute the latter.
- Or just outright remove the second verse. There's no min time limit, and I'd enjoy the file with one verse all the same
I get your struggle; I have actually tried to chart Splatoon songs before but a lot of them don't really mesh well with the usual length of files, lol
Thanks for offering feedback! Every bit helps
ポスト #53 · 2019-09-24 12:35:45amにポスト 4.7年前
Due to a scheduling conflict, results will be later in the day. Votes are still due at the same time.
Sorry for the inconvenience. We'll get the results as soon as possible.
Here are the results. https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1lXHB7hgNqOD9Fa1EF4c-MNp6fBppka4WcghAdbZHcCQ/edit#gid=669562440 Big thank you to darkanine for the spreadsheet.
The brackets.
1. hypnoticmarten77
16. dancingmaractus
8. hooky
9. Digital Basic
5. Pandemonium X
12. Nezemarth
4. Gameoson
13. vonafroa
--------
3. FoRCeDNaTuRe
14. SomethingRandom
6. talkion
11. ledgam3r1279
7. tamtamino
10. chewi
2. VanEden
15. TonyAkita
Sadly, Braeden47, _|/-\43D, and SupremeX did not make the cut.
When we vote next week, you will just vote on the better simfile in the match up. Good luck, now the fun starts.
Sorry for the inconvenience. We'll get the results as soon as possible.
Here are the results. https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1lXHB7hgNqOD9Fa1EF4c-MNp6fBppka4WcghAdbZHcCQ/edit#gid=669562440 Big thank you to darkanine for the spreadsheet.
The brackets.
1. hypnoticmarten77
16. dancingmaractus
8. hooky
9. Digital Basic
5. Pandemonium X
12. Nezemarth
4. Gameoson
13. vonafroa
--------
3. FoRCeDNaTuRe
14. SomethingRandom
6. talkion
11. ledgam3r1279
7. tamtamino
10. chewi
2. VanEden
15. TonyAkita
Sadly, Braeden47, _|/-\43D, and SupremeX did not make the cut.
When we vote next week, you will just vote on the better simfile in the match up. Good luck, now the fun starts.
ポスト #54 · 2019-09-24 12:49:00amにポスト 4.7年前
talkion | |
---|---|
Member | |
195 ポスト | |
Reg. 2018-05-06 | |
Nice, 6th. Thanks to everyone who voted for my file
Oh God Oh Fuck
Quote
6. talkion
11. ledgam3r1279
11. ledgam3r1279
Oh God Oh Fuck
ポスト #55 · 2019-09-24 01:14:25amにポスト 4.7年前
SupremeX | |
---|---|
Member | |
1,654 ポスト | |
Not Set | |
Reg. 2010-01-25 | |
Quote: Pandemonium X
Sadly, Braeden47, _|/-\43D, and SupremeX did not make the cut.
I don't understand. What kind of cut?
ポスト #56 · 2019-09-24 01:15:24amにポスト 4.7年前
Marten | |
---|---|
Moderator+ | |
1,037 ポスト | |
Reg. 2014-08-03 | |
"touch n go ride the flow" |
Thank you to everyone who voted for my file. It's on, dancingmaractus.
ポスト #57 · 2019-09-24 01:24:51amにポスト 4.7年前
forcednature | |
---|---|
Member | |
1,020 ポスト | |
Reg. 2012-06-12 | |
""Captain uwu"" |
Lower side of the bracket looks really rough. GL HF SomethingRandom!
ポスト #58 · 2019-09-24 01:32:29amにポスト 4.7年前
SomethingRandom | |
---|---|
Member | |
2,819 ポスト | |
Reg. 2015-02-21 | |
"bootylicious " |
Quote: SupremeX
Quote: Pandemonium X
Sadly, Braeden47, _|/-\43D, and SupremeX did not make the cut.
I don't understand. What kind of cut?
it means you did not make it to the next round
ポスト #59 · 2019-09-24 01:35:01amにポスト 4.7年前
SupremeX | |
---|---|
Member | |
1,654 ポスト | |
Not Set | |
Reg. 2010-01-25 | |
Quote: SomethingRandom
Quote: SupremeX
Quote: Pandemonium X
Sadly, Braeden47, _|/-\43D, and SupremeX did not make the cut.
I don't understand. What kind of cut?
it means you did not make it to the next round
Uhhh. Literally i didn't understand what Pandy said. Thanks! for the clarification.
ポスト #60 · 2019-09-24 01:35:13amにポスト 4.7年前
TonyAkita | |
---|---|
Member | |
236 ポスト | |
Reg. 2018-01-21 | |
Quote: Pandemonium X
Here are the results.
2. VanEden
15. TonyAkita
Good luck, now the fun starts.
2. VanEden
15. TonyAkita
Good luck, now the fun starts.
"If it wasn't for bad luck, I wouldn't have any..."