Post #81 · Posté à 2010-12-29 01:09:37pm il y a 13.7 années
Telperion | |
---|---|
Member+ | |
2,003 Messages | |
Reg. 2009-04-25 | |
"btor2osly" |
Votes:
Jingle Bell Rock - 1st (+3)
Deck the Hallcore - 2nd (+2)
Semesta Bertasbih - 3rd (+1)
Honorable mention to JOY TO THE WORLD, MY GIFTS, and Winter. I wanted to vote for more
I'll post comments later / after the contest if anybody's interested.
Winners if I were to vote based on music choice alone:
Winter - 1st
Deck the Hallcore - 2nd
Snow Quartz - 3rd
Jingle Bell Rock - 1st (+3)
Deck the Hallcore - 2nd (+2)
Semesta Bertasbih - 3rd (+1)
Honorable mention to JOY TO THE WORLD, MY GIFTS, and Winter. I wanted to vote for more
I'll post comments later / after the contest if anybody's interested.
Winners if I were to vote based on music choice alone:
Winter - 1st
Deck the Hallcore - 2nd
Snow Quartz - 3rd
Post #82 · Posté à 2010-12-29 01:56:10pm il y a 13.7 années
KcLKcL | |
---|---|
Member | |
388 Messages | |
Reg. 2008-08-12 | |
My votes:
3rd: Semesta Bertasbih
2nd: NIGHT OF FIRE (For Christmas Mix)
1st: I'm Getting Nuttin' For Christmas
3rd: Semesta Bertasbih
2nd: NIGHT OF FIRE (For Christmas Mix)
1st: I'm Getting Nuttin' For Christmas
Post #83 · Posté à 2010-12-30 10:15:55am il y a 13.7 années
Daiz | |
---|---|
Member+ | |
1,465 Messages | |
Reg. 2008-10-29 | |
"TAKING IT TO THE PIE" |
Christmas Accelerator
Song Choice: This reminds me of DeltaMAX for Christmas. Not really pleasent to listen to.
Expert: Adrupt flow and the difficulty didn't really feel like a 10, more like a 9 that tried too hard. Rhythm was predictable
Challenge: Definitely felt like a "Challenge" chart expanding on Expert. Not much more flow and jumps weren't really placed all that well.
Notes: I liked the idea but the song didn't really pull it off very well.
---------------------------
Deck the Hallcore
Song Choice: Nice redention of Deck the Halls. It won't be going on my iPod but I enjoyed playing it.
Expert: It's a simple chart, I felt like a bit more could have done but I enjoyed playing it. Towards the end there was a part where there was a jump that left me in an awkward position.
Notes: Good graphics, good custom song. I played it twice on the ITG2 I was on.
---------------------------
I'm Gettin' Nuttin' for Christmas
Song Choice: Very solid choice! This went on my iPod
Expert: Very solid chart! It's good to see a chart that employees turns properly. As I was turning away from the screen I was worried it wasn't going to end well and was surprised to see the chart lead me back to a decent position.
Notes: I really liked this chart
---------------------------
Ice Palace
Song Choice: Not very rhythmically complex but it's good to see different kinds of songs.
Expert: The rhythm seemed to be more complicated than what was in the song but the rhythm did fit. I just couldn't actually get into it with the song tone. Though, it was nice to see the use of forced double steps with freezes to add difficult. Solid chart overall.
Challenge: Freezes felt forced and way over done. The movement was too complicated with the kind of rhythm and the freezes involved. I felt more frustrated with the chart than I enjoyed playing it.
Notes: Expert was good, Challenge was uneeded.
---------------------------
In Excelsius Deo
Song Choice: Awesome song choice! I was bopping my head to this!
Expert: Started out good then.... it fell. The intensity of the song just changed too much in the song and the chart never diverged from the obvious main beat. Chart was ok but the intense gallops mixed with the long freeze + jacks seemed to mix too well with me.
Notes: Excellent song choice, if the intensity of the chart was constant through out the song (or starting out less and increased) it would have been a better chart.
---------------------------
Joy to the World
Song Choice: Dancemania Christmas Speed!
Expert: I honestly felt like I was playing a DDR MAx 2 chart song/chart. This one was a stamina drainer for me, great use of complex turns and freezes. It was like Senorita Speed Mix in it's intensity.
Notes: I felt like I faced right a lot for much of the song but I was deliberately looking for that D:
---------------------------
Karisumasu
Song Choice: Felt like I was playing a simfile contest song... er wait I suppose I am lol.
Expert: I'm not sure where this chart was going. It almost felt like you changed direction of how the song should be played out every 16 measures or so. Felt frustrated.
Challenge: Didn't playing this chart the entire way through.
---------------------------
Last Christmas (Output Jack Trance Remix)
Song Choice: A bit smoother choice than what I chose. It's "ok", not my tastes.
Expert: Definitely over rated. This was an 8 at best. But the chart suffered a lot from leading you into a turn then a jump you have to twist real fast to get. While it upped the difficulty, I found it unpleasant. The beginning seemed out of no where and the end of the song went off beat. However, the chart was pretty consistent through out.
Notes: This was a biased judgement considering I did the Cascada version.
---------------------------
Memory of Snow
Song Choice: Vocal wise I was annoyed, melody wise I Found it catchy.
Expert: Chart felt jerky in some spots but it wasn't a BAD chart, coulda been worse (see Challenge).
Challenge: You tried too hard for this.
Notes: The song went off sync about 3/4 of the way through which really hurt it.
---------------------------
My Gifts
Song Choice: It sounded and felt like Curus 2.0
Expert: Once again, it felt a lot like Curus. The gallops felt out of place, though I heard the rhythm. The end kinda got wonky. Unfortunately, I don't like Curus nor it's chart.
Note: Biased because I don't like Curus lol.
---------------------------
NESmas
Song Choice: Neat idea.
Expert: Eh, flow wasn't very good at all, rhythm "fit" but it the over all feel of the song felt bleh.
Notes: I felt like I was playing an NES Mix course from a DDR Solo series.
---------------------------
Night of Fire (for Christmas Mix)
Song Choice: Haha I actually enjoyed this.
Expert: A lot of the streams felt like you were forced into awkward postions considering the jumps made after them. Almost would have rather to seen more streams. More coulda been done with the chart in my opinion.
Notes: Love the idea but I felt like the chart was playing it too conservative and the flow wasn't top notch.
---------------------------
Semesta Bertasbih
Song Choice: Not my cup of tea.
Expert: While it wasn't extravagant, I felt rather bored.
Challenge: More of expert.
---------------------------
Sevivon (Electro Mix)
Song Choice: Sevivon SOV SOV SOV... need I say more?
Expert: Huh. The chart started out great but kinda fizzled out at the end. The 12th jacks irked but that's my only reapl complaint.
Expert Doubles: This was a fun chart on doubles!
Notes: The 12th portions were a bit unnerving but a solid chart otherwise.
---------------------------
Silver Bells
Song Choice: Not a bad version, I enjoyed the song.
Expert: Purple note syndrom HSSSSSSSSS. Seriously, why the purple notes? This wasn't a 12th note song at all. Anyway, the long streams then the sparse steps during the chorus made the chart feel... odd.
---------------------------
Snow Flurries
Song Choice: Not a bad choice, rhythmly complicated and catchy.
Expert: I loved the rhythm but the flow was terrible. I'd bump the rating to a 9 at least.
Notes: Uncomplicated the flow of the chart, keep the rhythm.
---------------------------
Snow Monster
Song Choice: Not bad, not very dancish but I liked the sound of it alright.
Expert: Nothing constructive to say.
Challenge: Didn't touch.
---------------------------
Snow Quartz
Song Choice: A strange one but I somewhat enjoyed it.
Expert: The speed changes felt frustrating and totally unnecessary. Chart reamined pretty consistent but kinda frustrating during some freezes and slow downs.
Challenge: :-\
Notes: Challenge I had to stop. Expert would be better if you fixed the flow and took out the speed changes.
---------------------------
Snowman (trance remix)
Song Choice: Video game music is always hit and miss, this was a bunt. Good trance though.
Expert: Actually I felt like this was a solid chart. The end with the freezes was disappointing but it was a decent chart overall.
---------------------------
V2
Song Choice: Didn't know this existed but I enjoyed it. It barely sounds like Taka though.
Expert: It felt like a PIU chart that was converted into DDR. I really didn't enjoy it but it may have made a better 5 panel chart.
Notes: The flow was really bad and the freezes with double stepping was irritating.
And my votes are....
3- I'm Gettin' Nuttin' for Christmas
2- Joy to the World
1- Snowman (trance remix)
Edit: Totals
Im Gettin Nuttin for Christmas: 7
My Gifts: 6
Winter: 4
Night of Fire: 4
Jingle Bell Rock: 4
Semesta Bertasbih: 4
Deck the Hallcore: 2
Sevivon: 2
Joy to the World: 2
Snowman: 1
Song Choice: This reminds me of DeltaMAX for Christmas. Not really pleasent to listen to.
Expert: Adrupt flow and the difficulty didn't really feel like a 10, more like a 9 that tried too hard. Rhythm was predictable
Challenge: Definitely felt like a "Challenge" chart expanding on Expert. Not much more flow and jumps weren't really placed all that well.
Notes: I liked the idea but the song didn't really pull it off very well.
---------------------------
Deck the Hallcore
Song Choice: Nice redention of Deck the Halls. It won't be going on my iPod but I enjoyed playing it.
Expert: It's a simple chart, I felt like a bit more could have done but I enjoyed playing it. Towards the end there was a part where there was a jump that left me in an awkward position.
Notes: Good graphics, good custom song. I played it twice on the ITG2 I was on.
---------------------------
I'm Gettin' Nuttin' for Christmas
Song Choice: Very solid choice! This went on my iPod
Expert: Very solid chart! It's good to see a chart that employees turns properly. As I was turning away from the screen I was worried it wasn't going to end well and was surprised to see the chart lead me back to a decent position.
Notes: I really liked this chart
---------------------------
Ice Palace
Song Choice: Not very rhythmically complex but it's good to see different kinds of songs.
Expert: The rhythm seemed to be more complicated than what was in the song but the rhythm did fit. I just couldn't actually get into it with the song tone. Though, it was nice to see the use of forced double steps with freezes to add difficult. Solid chart overall.
Challenge: Freezes felt forced and way over done. The movement was too complicated with the kind of rhythm and the freezes involved. I felt more frustrated with the chart than I enjoyed playing it.
Notes: Expert was good, Challenge was uneeded.
---------------------------
In Excelsius Deo
Song Choice: Awesome song choice! I was bopping my head to this!
Expert: Started out good then.... it fell. The intensity of the song just changed too much in the song and the chart never diverged from the obvious main beat. Chart was ok but the intense gallops mixed with the long freeze + jacks seemed to mix too well with me.
Notes: Excellent song choice, if the intensity of the chart was constant through out the song (or starting out less and increased) it would have been a better chart.
---------------------------
Joy to the World
Song Choice: Dancemania Christmas Speed!
Expert: I honestly felt like I was playing a DDR MAx 2 chart song/chart. This one was a stamina drainer for me, great use of complex turns and freezes. It was like Senorita Speed Mix in it's intensity.
Notes: I felt like I faced right a lot for much of the song but I was deliberately looking for that D:
---------------------------
Karisumasu
Song Choice: Felt like I was playing a simfile contest song... er wait I suppose I am lol.
Expert: I'm not sure where this chart was going. It almost felt like you changed direction of how the song should be played out every 16 measures or so. Felt frustrated.
Challenge: Didn't playing this chart the entire way through.
---------------------------
Last Christmas (Output Jack Trance Remix)
Song Choice: A bit smoother choice than what I chose. It's "ok", not my tastes.
Expert: Definitely over rated. This was an 8 at best. But the chart suffered a lot from leading you into a turn then a jump you have to twist real fast to get. While it upped the difficulty, I found it unpleasant. The beginning seemed out of no where and the end of the song went off beat. However, the chart was pretty consistent through out.
Notes: This was a biased judgement considering I did the Cascada version.
---------------------------
Memory of Snow
Song Choice: Vocal wise I was annoyed, melody wise I Found it catchy.
Expert: Chart felt jerky in some spots but it wasn't a BAD chart, coulda been worse (see Challenge).
Challenge: You tried too hard for this.
Notes: The song went off sync about 3/4 of the way through which really hurt it.
---------------------------
My Gifts
Song Choice: It sounded and felt like Curus 2.0
Expert: Once again, it felt a lot like Curus. The gallops felt out of place, though I heard the rhythm. The end kinda got wonky. Unfortunately, I don't like Curus nor it's chart.
Note: Biased because I don't like Curus lol.
---------------------------
NESmas
Song Choice: Neat idea.
Expert: Eh, flow wasn't very good at all, rhythm "fit" but it the over all feel of the song felt bleh.
Notes: I felt like I was playing an NES Mix course from a DDR Solo series.
---------------------------
Night of Fire (for Christmas Mix)
Song Choice: Haha I actually enjoyed this.
Expert: A lot of the streams felt like you were forced into awkward postions considering the jumps made after them. Almost would have rather to seen more streams. More coulda been done with the chart in my opinion.
Notes: Love the idea but I felt like the chart was playing it too conservative and the flow wasn't top notch.
---------------------------
Semesta Bertasbih
Song Choice: Not my cup of tea.
Expert: While it wasn't extravagant, I felt rather bored.
Challenge: More of expert.
---------------------------
Sevivon (Electro Mix)
Song Choice: Sevivon SOV SOV SOV... need I say more?
Expert: Huh. The chart started out great but kinda fizzled out at the end. The 12th jacks irked but that's my only reapl complaint.
Expert Doubles: This was a fun chart on doubles!
Notes: The 12th portions were a bit unnerving but a solid chart otherwise.
---------------------------
Silver Bells
Song Choice: Not a bad version, I enjoyed the song.
Expert: Purple note syndrom HSSSSSSSSS. Seriously, why the purple notes? This wasn't a 12th note song at all. Anyway, the long streams then the sparse steps during the chorus made the chart feel... odd.
---------------------------
Snow Flurries
Song Choice: Not a bad choice, rhythmly complicated and catchy.
Expert: I loved the rhythm but the flow was terrible. I'd bump the rating to a 9 at least.
Notes: Uncomplicated the flow of the chart, keep the rhythm.
---------------------------
Snow Monster
Song Choice: Not bad, not very dancish but I liked the sound of it alright.
Expert: Nothing constructive to say.
Challenge: Didn't touch.
---------------------------
Snow Quartz
Song Choice: A strange one but I somewhat enjoyed it.
Expert: The speed changes felt frustrating and totally unnecessary. Chart reamined pretty consistent but kinda frustrating during some freezes and slow downs.
Challenge: :-\
Notes: Challenge I had to stop. Expert would be better if you fixed the flow and took out the speed changes.
---------------------------
Snowman (trance remix)
Song Choice: Video game music is always hit and miss, this was a bunt. Good trance though.
Expert: Actually I felt like this was a solid chart. The end with the freezes was disappointing but it was a decent chart overall.
---------------------------
V2
Song Choice: Didn't know this existed but I enjoyed it. It barely sounds like Taka though.
Expert: It felt like a PIU chart that was converted into DDR. I really didn't enjoy it but it may have made a better 5 panel chart.
Notes: The flow was really bad and the freezes with double stepping was irritating.
And my votes are....
3- I'm Gettin' Nuttin' for Christmas
2- Joy to the World
1- Snowman (trance remix)
Edit: Totals
Im Gettin Nuttin for Christmas: 7
My Gifts: 6
Winter: 4
Night of Fire: 4
Jingle Bell Rock: 4
Semesta Bertasbih: 4
Deck the Hallcore: 2
Sevivon: 2
Joy to the World: 2
Snowman: 1
Post #84 · Posté à 2010-12-31 01:02:40am il y a 13.7 années
mugentatsuya | |
---|---|
Member | |
533 Messages | |
Reg. 2007-09-18 | |
Third - Deck The Hallcore
Second - Christmas Accelerator
First - Silver Bells
Second - Christmas Accelerator
First - Silver Bells
Post #85 · Posté à 2010-12-31 03:03:34am il y a 13.7 années
hooky | |
---|---|
Member | |
2,683 Messages | |
Reg. 2007-07-28 | |
Third: Deck The Hallcore
Second: In Excelsius Deo
First: Winter
Honorable Mention: NIGHT OF FIRE (FOR CHRISTMAS MIX), JOY TO THE WORLD, Snowman (Trance Remix)
Second: In Excelsius Deo
First: Winter
Honorable Mention: NIGHT OF FIRE (FOR CHRISTMAS MIX), JOY TO THE WORLD, Snowman (Trance Remix)
Post #86 · Posté à 2010-12-31 04:07:58am il y a 13.7 années
Daiz | |
---|---|
Member+ | |
1,465 Messages | |
Reg. 2008-10-29 | |
"TAKING IT TO THE PIE" |
Edit: Woops, not every posted theirs in 1st, 2nd, 3rd order: recalculated:
I'm Gettin' Nuttin' for Christmas: 9
Winter: 7
My Gifts: 6
Night of Fire: 4
Jingle Bell Rock: 4
Deck the Hallcore: 4
Silver Bells: 3
Sevivon: 2
Semesta Bertasbih: 2
Joy to the World: 2
Christmas Accelerator: 2
In Excelsiu Deo: 2
Snowman: 1
I'm Gettin' Nuttin' for Christmas: 9
Winter: 7
My Gifts: 6
Night of Fire: 4
Jingle Bell Rock: 4
Deck the Hallcore: 4
Silver Bells: 3
Sevivon: 2
Semesta Bertasbih: 2
Joy to the World: 2
Christmas Accelerator: 2
In Excelsiu Deo: 2
Snowman: 1
Post #87 · Posté à 2010-12-31 05:13:30am il y a 13.7 années
Pandemonium X | |
---|---|
Member | |
10,362 Messages | |
Reg. 2007-04-06 | |
VOTE TIME
3rd: Deck the Hallcore 1 pt
2nd: Semesta Bertasbih 2pt
1st NESmas 3pts
I'm Gettin' Nuttin' for Christmas: 9
Winter: 7
My Gifts: 6
Deck the Hallcore: 5
Night of Fire: 4
Jingle Bell Rock: 4
Semesta Bertasbih: 4
NESmas: 3
Silver Bells: 3
Sevivon: 2
Joy to the World: 2
Christmas Accelerator: 2
In Excelsiu Deo: 2
Snowman: 1
3rd: Deck the Hallcore 1 pt
2nd: Semesta Bertasbih 2pt
1st NESmas 3pts
I'm Gettin' Nuttin' for Christmas: 9
Winter: 7
My Gifts: 6
Deck the Hallcore: 5
Night of Fire: 4
Jingle Bell Rock: 4
Semesta Bertasbih: 4
NESmas: 3
Silver Bells: 3
Sevivon: 2
Joy to the World: 2
Christmas Accelerator: 2
In Excelsiu Deo: 2
Snowman: 1
Post #88 · Posté à 2010-12-31 09:48:14am il y a 13.7 années
Braeden47 | |
---|---|
Member | |
569 Messages | |
Reg. 2008-01-02 | |
"X scale 20" |
3rd: Deck the Hallcore 1 pt
2nd: I'm gettin' Nuttin' for Christmas 2pts
1st Sevivon 3pts
I'm Gettin' Nuttin' for Christmas: 11
Winter: 7
My Gifts: 6
Deck the Hallcore: 6
Sevivon: 5
Night of Fire: 4
Jingle Bell Rock: 4
Semesta Bertasbih: 4
NESmas: 3
Silver Bells: 3
Joy to the World: 2
Christmas Accelerator: 2
In Excelsiu Deo: 2
Snowman: 1
2nd: I'm gettin' Nuttin' for Christmas 2pts
1st Sevivon 3pts
I'm Gettin' Nuttin' for Christmas: 11
Winter: 7
My Gifts: 6
Deck the Hallcore: 6
Sevivon: 5
Night of Fire: 4
Jingle Bell Rock: 4
Semesta Bertasbih: 4
NESmas: 3
Silver Bells: 3
Joy to the World: 2
Christmas Accelerator: 2
In Excelsiu Deo: 2
Snowman: 1
Post #89 · Posté à 2010-12-31 01:11:27pm il y a 13.7 années
ziv348 | |
---|---|
Member | |
294 Messages | |
Reg. 2008-01-22 | |
"proud to be #2400" |
Here are my picks:
1 - NESmas (+3)
2 - Jingle Bell Rock (+2)
3 - Night of Fire (+1)
Totals:
I'm Gettin' Nuttin' for Christmas: 11
Winter: 7
My Gifts: 6
Deck the Hallcore: 6
NESmas: 6
Jingle Bell Rock: 6
Sevivon: 5
Night of Fire: 5
Semesta Bertasbih: 4
Silver Bells: 3
Joy to the World: 2
Christmas Accelerator: 2
In Excelsiu Deo: 2
Snowman: 1
1 - NESmas (+3)
2 - Jingle Bell Rock (+2)
3 - Night of Fire (+1)
Totals:
I'm Gettin' Nuttin' for Christmas: 11
Winter: 7
My Gifts: 6
Deck the Hallcore: 6
NESmas: 6
Jingle Bell Rock: 6
Sevivon: 5
Night of Fire: 5
Semesta Bertasbih: 4
Silver Bells: 3
Joy to the World: 2
Christmas Accelerator: 2
In Excelsiu Deo: 2
Snowman: 1
Post #90 · Posté à 2011-01-02 04:16:41am il y a 13.7 années
Pandemonium X | |
---|---|
Member | |
10,362 Messages | |
Reg. 2007-04-06 | |
Voting will end 11:00 PM TONIGHT!!!!
Here are our winners.
1st: I'm Gettin' Nuttin' for Christmas (chart by Telperion)
2nd: Winter (chart by Daiz)
T3rd: MY GIFTS (chart by DMAxel), Deck the Hallcore (chart by xRGTMx), NESmas (chart by Braeden47), and Jingle Bell Rock (chart by Daiz)
I'd like to thank everyone who was a part of this. Also keep a look out for the next communality project to be announced in a few weeks.
Here are our winners.
1st: I'm Gettin' Nuttin' for Christmas (chart by Telperion)
2nd: Winter (chart by Daiz)
T3rd: MY GIFTS (chart by DMAxel), Deck the Hallcore (chart by xRGTMx), NESmas (chart by Braeden47), and Jingle Bell Rock (chart by Daiz)
I'd like to thank everyone who was a part of this. Also keep a look out for the next communality project to be announced in a few weeks.
Post #91 · Posté à 2011-01-02 09:37:21am il y a 13.7 années
RGTM | |
---|---|
Moderator+ | |
7,248 Messages | |
Reg. 2007-07-19 | |
"BBCode Not Allowed" |
I thought this was awesome. Now, for some celebratory music: Deck The Hallcore (Coal In Your Stocking Mix)
Post #92 · Posté à 2011-01-03 02:55:05am il y a 13.7 années
Daiz | |
---|---|
Member+ | |
1,465 Messages | |
Reg. 2008-10-29 | |
"TAKING IT TO THE PIE" |
Congrats Tel! your chart was definitely worthy
Post #93 · Posté à 2011-01-07 07:55:55am il y a 13.7 années
Telperion | |
---|---|
Member+ | |
2,003 Messages | |
Reg. 2009-04-25 | |
"btor2osly" |
Thanks everybody! I honestly wasn't expecting I'm Gettin' Nuttin' for Christmas to have the best reception out of the three sims I submitted.
Congratz to Daiz for taking 2nd with one of my personal faves. I really like how the votes shook out in the end, y'all have good taste
Congratz to Daiz for taking 2nd with one of my personal faves. I really like how the votes shook out in the end, y'all have good taste