Logo

Rating Scales Poll - 2016

Register Log In Back To Forums

Post #1 · Posted at 2016-03-04 02:10:48am 8 years ago

Offline Braeden47
Braeden47 Avatar Member
569 Posts
United States
Reg. 2008-01-02

"X scale 20"
Many years ago there was a poll for rating scales in DDR and other 4-panel dance games.
To see if people preferred the classic scale or the X scale.

Vote for one of these choices:

Classic Scale
DDR 1-10, no ratings above 10.

ITG Scale
ITG 1-13, no ratings above 13

Extended ITG Scale
An open ended ITG scale that goes 1-22 and up.

DDR X Scale
The 1-20 scale in the X series of DDR games

Mungyodance scale
This is the ITG scale multiplied by 10.


Also, keep a running count of how many of each:
Classic Scale - 0
ITG Scale - 0
Extended ITG Scale - 0
DDR X scale -0
Mungyodance Scale - 0


Post #2 · Posted at 2016-03-04 02:15:51am 8 years ago

Offline 01angel
01angel Avatar Member
2,755 Posts
United States
Reg. 2015-11-27

Game Center Nickname: 0/1 ANGEL
"Mostly just lurking."
I like the DDR X Scale, but that's just me.
Don't forget, I'm angel for yoooooooou(|[*'v'*]|)
~Eternal Ham World Order member~
http://i.imgur.com/2YKgcAX.png
(●´∪`|♪。o.゚。*・Newest Simfile: Novi plan drugi san / Filip Baloš 。o.゚。*・♪|´∪`●)
http://orig02.deviantart.net/0c84/f/2017/023/f/7/_200_watcher_gift__f2u_alt_2_0_blinky_icon_emote_by_the01angel-dawhax6.gif

Post #3 · Posted at 2016-03-04 02:18:49am 8 years ago

Offline CuzcoBlocko
CuzcoBlocko Avatar Member
2,947 Posts
United States
Reg. 2013-10-26

"[Art by LilyBreez]"
Classic scale works for me. Maybe the ITG scale.

Post #4 · Posted at 2016-03-04 02:23:14am 8 years ago

Offline DDR Addict
DDR Addict Avatar Member
1,464 Posts
United States
Reg. 2009-09-23

Nintendo Network ID: RimeTM3DS Friend Code: 3454-0657-8756
"Let's Do the Rain Dance"
Quote
Also, keep a running count of how many of each:
Classic Scale - 0
ITG Scale - 0
Extended ITG Scale - 0
DDR X scale -0
Mungyodance Scale - 0

Heyo, responders...

Anyway, my vote is DDR X scale all the way. Can't believe it's been 8 years and it's still an uphill battle for its acceptance!

Classic Scale - 1
ITG Scale - 0
Extended ITG Scale - 0
DDR X scale - 2
Mungyodance Scale - 0

P.S. As per Pump it Up Pro (which is, for all intents and purposes, In the Groove 3 ~5 Arrow Boogaloo~, and has a lot of the same staff), the ITG scale actually goes to 15.

Post #5 · Posted at 2016-03-04 02:54:05am 8 years ago

Offline -Viper-
-Viper- Avatar Member+
2,407 Posts
United States
Reg. 2007-10-26

3DS Friend Code: 1091-8797-8693

Last updated: 2016-03-04 02:56am
I would vote classic scale (with flashing 10 footers for charts that deserve higher). Asthetically I just like it better than the X-scale.

Classic Scale - 2
ITG Scale - 0
Extended ITG Scale - 0
DDR X scale - 2
Mungyodance Scale - 0

Post #6 · Posted at 2016-03-04 03:48:40am 8 years ago

Offline fygar939
fygar939 Avatar Member
298 Posts
United States
Reg. 2011-06-05

"BEMANI Sound Team ¥"PON¥"

Last updated: 2016-03-04 03:58am
Classic Scale - 2
ITG Scale - 0
Extended ITG Scale - 0
DDR X scale - 3
Mungyodance Scale - 0

I've never heard anything about the extended ITG scale (then again, I'm not in the ITG or R21 community). Is it appended to original ITG scale and not more precise as the X-Scale was to the Classic Scale?

Post #7 · Posted at 2016-03-04 04:10:40am 8 years ago

Offline Nezemarth
Nezemarth Avatar Member+
745 Posts
United States
Reg. 2014-12-09

"Two milkmen go comedy"
Personally, I'm also a fan of the X-Scale, as it provides the perfect amount of detail of a song's difficulty for me.

Classic Scale - 2
ITG Scale - 0
Extended ITG Scale - 0
DDR X scale - 4
Mungyodance Scale - 0
Quote: xXMokou98Xx
If I spend an hour or so to make a [..] beautiful standard chart and a fun light chart and it's required for the comp, play it, or at least look it over other wise I don't see the point anymore[.]
http://inori.s-ul.eu/hLfhCqrG
~DDR Supernova 3 Stepper~
~Profile Picture from MeriNY~

Post #8 · Posted at 2016-03-04 04:23:45am 8 years ago

Offline chewi
chewi Avatar Member+
8,537 Posts
Not Set
Reg. 2008-02-24

Classic Scale - 2
ITG Scale - 0
Extended ITG Scale - 0
DDR X scale - 5
Mungyodance Scale - 0
https://zenius-i-vanisher.com/simfiles/Vibe%20Vibe%20Relaxation/Vibe%20Vibe%20Relaxation.png?1677865262

Post #9 · Posted at 2016-03-04 05:08:50am 8 years ago

Offline Silver Spirit
Silver Spirit Avatar Member
6,580 Posts
United States
Reg. 2008-09-14

Nintendo Switch Friend Code: SW-2249-7707-55923DS Friend Code: 2578-3309-2697
"i was born at a very young age"

Last updated: 2016-03-04 05:17am
Classic Scale - 2
ITG Scale - 1
Extended ITG Scale - 0
DDR X scale - 5
Mungyodance Scale - 0

Would pick the x scale but we still don't have an official benchmark of what constitutes a 20, so...

Quote
I've never heard anything about the extended ITG scale (then again, I'm not in the ITG or R21 community). Is it appended to original ITG scale and not more precise as the X-Scale was to the Classic Scale?
It's appended, yeah.

EDIT: Given DDR Addict's point, changing my vote.

Post #10 · Posted at 2016-03-04 05:28:41am 8 years ago

Offline ledgam3r1279
ledgam3r1279 Avatar Member+
993 Posts
United States
Reg. 2011-10-14

"now led_light for short"
Classic Scale - 2
ITG Scale - 0
Extended ITG Scale - 1
DDR X scale - 6
Mungyodance Scale - 0

If we did have a 20, it would be pushing the limits of what is humanly possible anyway, and 20 seems like the perfect number to stop on too.
DDR A3 Rival Code: 3115-3633 | Like my work? Become a patron today!
Latest Simfiles:
https://zenius-i-vanisher.com/simfiles/The%20Complete%20led_light%20Collection/Demon%20Lord/Demon%20Lord-jacket.pnghttps://zenius-i-vanisher.com/simfiles/The%20Complete%20led_light%20Collection/Anarchy/Anarchy-jacket.pnghttps://zenius-i-vanisher.com/simfiles/The%20Complete%20led_light%20Collection/Bewitched/Bewitched-jacket.pnghttps://zenius-i-vanisher.com/simfiles/The%20Complete%20led_light%20Collection/The%20Most%20Wanted%20Person%20In%20the%20United%20States/The%20Most%20Wanted%20Person%20In%20the%20United%20States-jacket.pnghttps://zenius-i-vanisher.com/simfiles/The%20Complete%20led_light%20Collection/999%20%28666%20Camellia%27s%20Unofficial%20Rejected%20Remix%29/999%20%28666%20Camellia%27s%20Unofficial%20Rejected%20Remix%29-jacket.pnghttps://zenius-i-vanisher.com/simfiles/The%20Complete%20led_light%20Collection/God%20Sees%20All%20%28Odyssey%20Eurobeat%20Bootleg%29/God%20Sees%20All%20%28Odyssey%20Eurobeat%20Bootleg%29-jacket.pnghttps://zenius-i-vanisher.com/simfiles/The%20Complete%20led_light%20Collection/Up%20N%27%20Down/Up%20N%27%20Down-jacket.png

Post #11 · Posted at 2016-03-04 06:12:30am 8 years ago

Offline brunobg24
brunobg24 Avatar Member
386 Posts
Peru
Reg. 2012-12-24

"hi kids"
Classic Scale - 2
ITG Scale - 0
Extended ITG Scale - 1
DDR X scale - 7
Mungyodance Scale - 0

I think everyone should use DDR X scale.
Check out my YouTube channel with stuff related to BEMANI and music games!
Check my simfiles in this thread!
Latest simfiles on Z-i-V:
https://zenius-i-vanisher.com/simfiles/Z-I-v%20Summer%20Contest%202020/R.I.P/R.I.P-jacket.png https://zenius-i-vanisher.com/simfiles/Z-I-v%20Summer%20Contest%202020/Dual%20Bladez/Dual%20Bladez-jacket.png https://zenius-i-vanisher.com/simfiles/Z-I-v%20Summer%20Contest%202020/amaterasu/amaterasu-jacket.png https://zenius-i-vanisher.com/simfiles/Z-I-v%20Summer%20Contest%202020/Say%20So/Say%20So-jacket.png https://zenius-i-vanisher.com/simfiles/Z-I-v%20Battle%20Royale%202020/Fin.ArcDeaR/Fin.ArcDeaR-jacket.png

Post #12 · Posted at 2016-03-04 06:16:37am 8 years ago

Offline NuVirus
NuVirus Avatar Member
694 Posts
United States
Reg. 2011-10-10

Classic Scale - 2
ITG Scale - 0
Extended ITG Scale - 2
DDR X scale - 7
Mungyodance Scale - 0

Quote: ledgam3r1279
If we did have a 20, it would be pushing the limits of what is humanly possible anyway, and 20 seems like the perfect number to stop on too.

Clearly, no one on here keeps up with the ITG scene nowadays...typical Z-i-V...
"I never really got better, I just learned to accept that some people aren't meant to be happy in this world. It makes it easier when you're not hoping for something that will never come." -IndependentThinker2

Post #13 · Posted at 2016-03-04 06:38:37am 8 years ago

Offline xXMokou98Xx
xXMokou98Xx Avatar Member
2,461 Posts
United States
Reg. 2010-07-07

Nintendo Network ID: pinkscones
"meme school"
Classic Scale - 2
ITG Scale - 0
Extended ITG Scale - 3
DDR X scale - 7
Mungyodance Scale - 0

I like the feel of the Extended scale moreso than the X scale. Meanwhile I use Classic Scale for simfiles. Go figure.
Yiss ©Ayumi Promotions, 2012
http://imgur.com/Gly172P.pnghttp://i.imgur.com/alUsLeu.jpg

Post #14 · Posted at 2016-03-04 07:52:46am 8 years ago

Offline ledgam3r1279
ledgam3r1279 Avatar Member+
993 Posts
United States
Reg. 2011-10-14

"now led_light for short"
Quote: NuVirus
Clearly, no one on here keeps up with the ITG scene nowadays...typical Z-i-V...

I meant to say humanly possible in terms of the ability to clear it (within some reason) and in terms of the possibility to "speed dance" with it, not a "f*** you, you're going to fail no matter what" kind of chart. There's pretty much zero possibility that Konami is going to release a chart that would be rated anything higher than a 20, and even if such charts exist, they would've lost their fun factor a long time ago no matter what gimmicks are used (even the 19s are already stretching it).
DDR A3 Rival Code: 3115-3633 | Like my work? Become a patron today!
Latest Simfiles:
https://zenius-i-vanisher.com/simfiles/The%20Complete%20led_light%20Collection/Demon%20Lord/Demon%20Lord-jacket.pnghttps://zenius-i-vanisher.com/simfiles/The%20Complete%20led_light%20Collection/Anarchy/Anarchy-jacket.pnghttps://zenius-i-vanisher.com/simfiles/The%20Complete%20led_light%20Collection/Bewitched/Bewitched-jacket.pnghttps://zenius-i-vanisher.com/simfiles/The%20Complete%20led_light%20Collection/The%20Most%20Wanted%20Person%20In%20the%20United%20States/The%20Most%20Wanted%20Person%20In%20the%20United%20States-jacket.pnghttps://zenius-i-vanisher.com/simfiles/The%20Complete%20led_light%20Collection/999%20%28666%20Camellia%27s%20Unofficial%20Rejected%20Remix%29/999%20%28666%20Camellia%27s%20Unofficial%20Rejected%20Remix%29-jacket.pnghttps://zenius-i-vanisher.com/simfiles/The%20Complete%20led_light%20Collection/God%20Sees%20All%20%28Odyssey%20Eurobeat%20Bootleg%29/God%20Sees%20All%20%28Odyssey%20Eurobeat%20Bootleg%29-jacket.pnghttps://zenius-i-vanisher.com/simfiles/The%20Complete%20led_light%20Collection/Up%20N%27%20Down/Up%20N%27%20Down-jacket.png

Post #15 · Posted at 2016-03-04 08:11:59am 8 years ago

Offline DDRDAIKENKAI
DDRDAIKENKAI Avatar Member+
441 Posts
United States
Reg. 2006-11-25

"djSOUTA"
Classic Scale - 2
ITG Scale - 1
Extended ITG Scale - 3
DDR X scale - 7
Mungyodance Scale - 0

Eh, it's what I'm used to. Although I'm getting pretty acclimated to the X-scale nowadays. Not enough to rate my own files yet, but enough to understand other songs' difficulty accordingly

Post #16 · Posted at 2016-03-04 09:19:24am 8 years ago

Offline midnightclubx
midnightclubx Avatar Member
1,080 Posts
United States
Reg. 2014-06-06

Classic Scale - 3
ITG Scale - 1
Extended ITG Scale - 3
DDR X scale - 7
Mungyodance Scale - 0

Sure, the X scale shows exactly what to expect in terms of boss songs, but I've always preferred the simple 1-10 scale.

That being said, NeonFM's difficulty scale, where it uses a 0-100% scale, is probably the most accurate you would find, and wouldn't need to re-do the scale to compliment harder songs. >>

Post #17 · Posted at 2016-03-04 09:22:26am 8 years ago

Offline Spirit of Nightmare
Spirit of Nightmare Avatar Member
2,719 Posts
Sweden
Reg. 2007-12-19

"Focul tău nu ne mai încălzește"
Classic Scale - 3
ITG Scale - 1
Extended ITG Scale - 4
DDR X scale - 7
Mungyodance Scale - 0

This was a coin flip for me between the original ITG scale and the Extended ITG scale. I realize that even in DDR, if I had to convert from X scale, I have to use the extended ITG scale as the method, as there are those songs that would be too hard for a standard ITG 13 (we all should know which 4 I'm referring to)
Quote: Quickman
hot diggity shit nightmare you cheeky bastard

Post #18 · Posted at 2016-03-04 09:29:42am 8 years ago

Offline CynicalOkie
CynicalOkie Avatar Member
541 Posts
United States
Reg. 2011-02-27

3DS Friend Code: 5370-1122-8774
"Care cup is empty! c[_]"
Classic Scale - 3
ITG Scale - 1
Extended ITG Scale - 4
DDR X scale - 8
Mungyodance Scale - 0

Short answer: The X-scale is fine

Long answer: Sure, the X-scale has a few faults, but I don't think any rating system will have its perfection without any errors or misrated songs. It's still, however, more precise when it comes to how difficult a song is. Easy just to say it's a 14, rather than trying to figure out if it's a very hard 9 or an easy 10 on the old scale or such.

Post #19 · Posted at 2016-03-04 12:44:54pm 8 years ago

Offline Oni-91
Oni-91 Avatar Moderator+
13,489 Posts
United Kingdom
Reg. 2006-10-20

Nintendo Switch Friend Code: SW-3445-5569-17913DS Friend Code: 008736577880
"Ambivalent Viennetta"
Abstaining from voting, but if the Extended ITG scale is the same as ITG until 14+, what's the point of the ITG scale in this poll? It's made redundant by the Extended one surely?
ZIv Mod Squad: "I'm a trash panda now, don't worry about it"
Can you make music? ZENIUS -I- MANIA 2023 NEEDS YOU
https://pbs.twimg.com/media/FvT2ARPaQAAxRVX.jpg:large

Post #20 · Posted at 2016-03-04 01:06:10pm 8 years ago

Offline NicholasNRG
NicholasNRG Avatar Member
635 Posts
Puerto Rico
Reg. 2014-06-21

"Just Play Along"
X-Scale for sure.
Register Log In Back To Forums

0 User(s) Viewing This Thread (Past 15 Minutes)

©2006-2024 Zenius -I- vanisher.com -5th style- IIPrivacy Policy
Web Server: 5% · Database: 4% · Server Time: 2024-03-29 00:10:38
This page took 0.018 seconds to execute.
Theme: starlight · Language: englishuk
Reset Theme & Language