ZIv Simfile Tournament of Immortals 3

8bit Princess

Kinda neat, generally liked the crossover usage (although I'd tone it down a bit personally on that front). My only complaints are minor nitpicks with pitch relevance and such.

~~~
A Geisha's Dream

Meh, I wasn't really digging much of this chart. Some parts feel overly simplistic and other parts (like b226) just don't match the music at all. Also could I get clarification on b177? I still don't know if that's supposed to be a crossover or an unintentional doublestep, but it bugs me a lot regardless.

~~~
Can I get get get

Funky lol.

I actually kinda enjoyed this chart, very few things stuck out to me as questionable. A few missed notes here and there but it's pretty consistent throughout so it's not really much to complain about.

~~~
Echoes

Some neat ideas in this chart, I'm kinda torn on some other ones though (the stop I'm very on the fence about). Also b23.375, I've slowed this down and I still can't hear anything that note is going to in the music. The Freeze/12th island taps though were a pretty nice touch.

~~~
Get it Done

Before anything else, I'm just gonna be quite honest, I really really don't like the spins in this chart at all. I rarely ever look at spins as something to use in a chart unless there's like a really defined moment in the music calling for it. I'd just have them as maybe lateral crossovers or something. It's not the worst thing in the world, but for me personally I'd just rather not play them.

THAT BEING SAID, I thought the rest of the chart was pretty interesting and followed the music relatively well. I don't think I have anything really to say other than the spins. Good.

~~~
Got the Rhythm

Chart is incredibly sporadic and unnecessary jerky almost the entire chart. Bleh, I just don't see much foundation in this and it just seems like the arrows were placed haphazardly without much consideration of how the player has to twist his body so much just to hit the arrows (I'm not saying that twisty movements are bad by any means. It just seems to me that there really isn't much structure in this chart and kinda ends up like a being an experimental chart gone wrong).

~~~
I Still Wonder

Crossover usage was good, generally followed the music pretty good. Chart is good. But holy shit those vocals haha

~~~
in motion

Really weird song with some interesting arrow quantizations. It's got some nice variety to it. I guess my only complaint is that I wish you followed the music a bit more accurately (I wish those stops were marked with mines or something but asking ZIv people to put mines in a chart is I'm sure asking too much for some reason).

~~~
Koubuki Beatrix

It's an interesting song choice but as I've mentioned earlier my main problem with this simfile is that it's too repetitive or my tastes. :/

~~~
Like a Robot

What the fuck is the song holy shit haha

I really liked the doublesteps you used to accent the "Why do you" lyrics, as well as the jack usage and mostly the consistency of the chart is pretty well done. But god this song is definitely the most... unique in the pack.

~~~
Make up syndrome

I absolutely hated the vocals in this oh my god. I don't think the song really lends to much as it tends to be repetitive a lot. The chart was okay but god I am not a fan of this song I'm sorry.

~~~
make.believe

I gotta admit this chart is pretty well done. The freeze/crossover accenting for the most part is really well done. The one thing that bugs me: I really think that jump at the end should be removed. Regardless, really good job on this.

~~~
Moshi Moshi

Best background ever

Chart wise, I'm not very fond of how all the bursts face one way the entire time (I think this chart has a tendency to face one way a lot actually). Doublestep at b181.5 is kind of annoying. That speedup is pretty jarring on how you have next to no reaction time for the next jump. Bleh, not my cup of tea.

~~~
Pinkie's Lie

I'm not really a fan of how you switch between the vocals and the instruments so jarringly. The crossovers kinda felt more excessive than was necessary ( at this bpm though it's not that much of an issue). I've never really liked this song in general from WinDEU's pack either cuz it's really repetitive (as is Wooden Toaster in general I find). On the plus side, no doublesteps or anything that disrupted the flow really. I'm kind of just meh on this one.

~~~
RPG

There wasn't too much to complain about, personally though I just think this chart is kinda bland and nothing all that special compared to other files. It's not bad, just kinda eh for me.

~~~
Soriaro Days (i probably spelled this wrong oops)

I actually liked this file a lot, the jump and hold usage is pretty sick. I can kinda let the spins slide but I'm still not very fond of them. But still good chart. good child.

~~~
Sweet Angel

I don't really think this song lends itself to much variety, but even still it was an okay chart (I wish you'd put a stream at m15 to spice it up a little but eh). I kinda enjoyed it.

~~~
Todestriab

Interesting song choice. It seemed pretty fun for the most part (the hold section in the middle was really well done with accenting the correct instrument you were going for and not the more obvious instrument going with it). One beef I have though is the end how the difficulty spikes up like that. I'd be much happier if you just left the same rhythms like you had in an earlier section. Overall though kinda neat.

~~~
Top the Charts

Eh, I don't really agree with any of your patterning ideas; it feels like you threw them in at random almost (like I'm confused on some some hold usage that would really be better as jumps, or some jacks that felt kinda thrown in). idk I didn't get into this chart much.

~~~
Under the Blue Sky

Those crossovers at the beginning; are those supposed to be laterals? Cuz you either have to doublestep them or footswitch on the left/right arrows to actually hit them with alternating your feet. I don't know it kinda bugged me.

Chart was okay, I wasn't much for it though honestly. Meh.

~~~
Zenius -I- Vanisher

I'm just so used to mute's chart to this that I really can't get into this chart. Nothing really wrong with it (well I kinda have some nitpicks), I just prefer his version more. :/