Post #581 · Posted at 2016-05-11 11:04:02pm 9.1 years ago
![]() | |
---|---|
![]() |
Moderator+ |
13,518 Posts | |
![]() | |
Reg. 2006-10-20 | |
![]() ![]() | |
"Popular bisexual disaster" |
xRGTMx
HARD [ddrstepper] - bye
New Day [darkanine] - 1
Brand New World [Oni-91] - 4
doll of love [Telperion] - 4
Dualive [tsugaru7reveng] - 2
Mayday [Spork!] - 1
Fat Finger [Lisek] - 5
Dua Dua Duuua [vincentw] - 4
Blow [chewi] - 2
Kung-fu Empire [Gameoson] - 4
少女アリスと箱庭幻想コンチェルト [Aegis] - 1
ロプノールの商隊 [brunobg24] - 2
Vrosteroid [Loodee] - 3
Dynamite [ledgam3r1279] - 0
Glitchtastic [Feraligatr] - 5
HARD [ddrstepper] - bye
New Day [darkanine] - 1
Brand New World [Oni-91] - 4
doll of love [Telperion] - 4
Dualive [tsugaru7reveng] - 2
Mayday [Spork!] - 1
Fat Finger [Lisek] - 5
Dua Dua Duuua [vincentw] - 4
Blow [chewi] - 2
Kung-fu Empire [Gameoson] - 4
少女アリスと箱庭幻想コンチェルト [Aegis] - 1
ロプノールの商隊 [brunobg24] - 2
Vrosteroid [Loodee] - 3
Dynamite [ledgam3r1279] - 0
Glitchtastic [Feraligatr] - 5
Post #582 · Posted at 2016-05-13 06:25:19am 9 years ago
![]() | |
---|---|
![]() |
Member+ |
2,004 Posts | |
![]() | |
Reg. 2009-04-25 | |
![]() | |
"btor2osly" |
VOTES
TOTES (I checked my math this time)
xRGTMx
HARD [ddrstepper] - I just get so hard
New Day [darkanine] - 1
Brand New World [Oni-91] - 4
doll of love [Telperion] - 4
Dualive [tsugaru7reveng] - 2
Mayday [Spork!] - 2
Fat Finger [Lisek] - 5
Dua Dua Duuua [vincentw] - 4
Blow [chewi] - 3
Kung-fu Empire [Gameoson] - 5
少女アリスと箱庭幻想コンチェルト [Aegis] - 1
ロプノールの商隊 [brunobg24] - 2
Vrosteroid [Loodee] - 4
Dynamite [ledgam3r1279] - 0
Glitchtastic [Feraligatr] - 6
100% HARD
NOTES: This would have been a hard file for xRGTMx to take down, anyway
50% New Day
50% Brand New World
NOTES: I liked both too much to choose between them...
---- doll of love
---- Dualive
NOTES: Dualive is a fr*cking #banqer (also I agree it's very bizarre how similar our titles sound hahaha)
60% Mayday
40% Fat Finger
NOTES: Two great files - each in their own way - both marred by small technical issues. Close matchup.
45% Dua Dua Duuua
55% Blow
NOTES: Having both of the "concept simfiles" artists in one bracket is tough as nails.
60% Kung-fu Empire
40% 少女アリスと箱庭幻想コンチェルト
NOTES: I probably hate both of you for making me choose between two technical simfiles set to IIDX songs that I have grossly overplayed. Go step something else, boys.
20% ロプノールの商隊
80% Vrosteroid
NOTES: Don't let the percentages fool you - this is a ridiculously strong matchup, probably my 1st and 3nd favorite files of the round.
30% Dynamite
70% Glitchtastic
NOTES: Not convinced by Glitchtastic's rhythm choices, but enough of an attempt was made. Dynamite's jumps just gave me Unreal flashbacks.
NOTES: This would have been a hard file for xRGTMx to take down, anyway

50% New Day
50% Brand New World
NOTES: I liked both too much to choose between them...
---- doll of love
---- Dualive
NOTES: Dualive is a fr*cking #banqer (also I agree it's very bizarre how similar our titles sound hahaha)
60% Mayday
40% Fat Finger
NOTES: Two great files - each in their own way - both marred by small technical issues. Close matchup.
45% Dua Dua Duuua
55% Blow
NOTES: Having both of the "concept simfiles" artists in one bracket is tough as nails.
60% Kung-fu Empire
40% 少女アリスと箱庭幻想コンチェルト
NOTES: I probably hate both of you for making me choose between two technical simfiles set to IIDX songs that I have grossly overplayed. Go step something else, boys.
20% ロプノールの商隊
80% Vrosteroid
NOTES: Don't let the percentages fool you - this is a ridiculously strong matchup, probably my 1st and 3nd favorite files of the round.
30% Dynamite
70% Glitchtastic
NOTES: Not convinced by Glitchtastic's rhythm choices, but enough of an attempt was made. Dynamite's jumps just gave me Unreal flashbacks.
TOTES (I checked my math this time)
xRGTMx
HARD [ddrstepper] - I just get so hard
New Day [darkanine] - 1
Brand New World [Oni-91] - 4
doll of love [Telperion] - 4
Dualive [tsugaru7reveng] - 2
Mayday [Spork!] - 2
Fat Finger [Lisek] - 5
Dua Dua Duuua [vincentw] - 4
Blow [chewi] - 3
Kung-fu Empire [Gameoson] - 5
少女アリスと箱庭幻想コンチェルト [Aegis] - 1
ロプノールの商隊 [brunobg24] - 2
Vrosteroid [Loodee] - 4
Dynamite [ledgam3r1279] - 0
Glitchtastic [Feraligatr] - 6
Post #583 · Posted at 2016-05-13 06:31:22am 9 years ago
My ratings
xRGTMx
HARD [ddrstepper] - bye
New Day [darkanine] - 1
Brand New World [Oni-91] - 6
doll of love [Telperion] - 4
Dualive [tsugaru7reveng] - 4
Mayday [Spork!] - 6
Fat Finger [Lisek] - 5
Dua Dua Duuua [vincentw] - 4
Blow [chewi] - 6
Kung-fu Empire [Gameoson] - 5
少女アリスと箱庭幻想コンチェルト [Aegis] - 3
ロプノールの商隊 [brunobg24] - 2
Vrosteroid [Loodee] - 5
Dynamite [ledgam3r1279] - 0
Glitchtastic [Feraligatr] - 7
xRGTMx
HARD [ddrstepper] - bye
New Day [darkanine] - 1
Brand New World [Oni-91] - 6
doll of love [Telperion] - 4
Dualive [tsugaru7reveng] - 4
Mayday [Spork!] - 6
Fat Finger [Lisek] - 5
Dua Dua Duuua [vincentw] - 4
Blow [chewi] - 6
Kung-fu Empire [Gameoson] - 5
少女アリスと箱庭幻想コンチェルト [Aegis] - 3
ロプノールの商隊 [brunobg24] - 2
Vrosteroid [Loodee] - 5
Dynamite [ledgam3r1279] - 0
Glitchtastic [Feraligatr] - 7
Post #584 · Posted at 2016-05-13 09:05:08am 9 years ago
![]() | |
---|---|
![]() |
Member |
2,956 Posts | |
![]() | |
Reg. 2013-10-26 | |
"[Art by LilyBreez]" |
Last updated: 2016-05-13 10:15pm
Ayy that's not how you vote. One point per bracket only.
xRGTMx
HARD [ddrstepper] - bye
New Day [darkanine] - 1
Brand New World [Oni-91] - 5
doll of love [Telperion] - 4
Dualive [tsugaru7reveng] - 3
Mayday [Spork!] - 3
Fat Finger [Lisek] - 5
Dua Dua Duuua [vincentw] - 4
Blow [chewi] - 4
Kung-fu Empire [Gameoson] - 5
少女アリスと箱庭幻想コンチェルト [Aegis] - 2
ロプノールの商隊 [brunobg24] - 2
Vrosteroid [Loodee] - 5
Dynamite [ledgam3r1279] - 0
Glitchtastic [Feraligatr] - 7
Alrighty, so now that I fixed the totals, let's add some more totals!
...vincentw, Lisek, and Oni-91 in a lower tier?? What? What's going on here?
I'll be honest, PURELY because of Hard, I played the files in the opposite direction (so Feraligatr vs. ledgam3r1279, then brunobg24 vs. Loodee...). I ran into 3 REALLY good brackets and then after that things just started getting mediocre and not all that impressive like some people seem to believe. Beware of my lonely opinions haha.
Okay, totals.
xRGTMx
HARD [ddrstepper] - 63
New Day [darkanine] - 2
Brand New World [Oni-91] - 5
doll of love [Telperion] - 5 Seriously this has to win. It's very good.
Dualive [tsugaru7reveng] - 3
Mayday [Spork!] - 4
Fat Finger [Lisek] - 5
Dua Dua Duuua [vincentw] - 4
Blow [chewi] - 5 Could this be a glimmer of hope for chewi?
Kung-fu Empire [Gameoson] - 5
少女アリスと箱庭幻想コンチェルト [Aegis] - 3
ロプノールの商隊 [brunobg24] - 2
Vrosteroid [Loodee] - 6 This should really win too.
Dynamite [ledgam3r1279] - 0
Glitchtastic [Feraligatr] - 8
Holy crap Feraligatr's steamrolling his bracket. Dynamite had some problems but I didn't think they'd be THIS bad. I'm actually surprised ledgam3r1279 has 0... He's usually pretty good! ... In any case, sorry, led... ;-;
Oh, by the way, I honestly want Feraligatr to win the whole contest. He's the only one who made it to Round 2 whose sims I have consistently enjoyed/gave points to. It'll probably be someone like bruno/Gameoson/Telperion but that's who I want to win.
As always, my comments are available here. Be warned, though, I don't really have anything to say for many files this week like I did with round 1 and the qualifiers.
xRGTMx
HARD [ddrstepper] - bye
New Day [darkanine] - 1
Brand New World [Oni-91] - 5
doll of love [Telperion] - 4
Dualive [tsugaru7reveng] - 3
Mayday [Spork!] - 3
Fat Finger [Lisek] - 5
Dua Dua Duuua [vincentw] - 4
Blow [chewi] - 4
Kung-fu Empire [Gameoson] - 5
少女アリスと箱庭幻想コンチェルト [Aegis] - 2
ロプノールの商隊 [brunobg24] - 2
Vrosteroid [Loodee] - 5
Dynamite [ledgam3r1279] - 0
Glitchtastic [Feraligatr] - 7
Alrighty, so now that I fixed the totals, let's add some more totals!
♥5 doll of love
♥5 Vrosteriod
♥4 Alice in Mystic Garden
H4 Lop Nur no shoutai
H4 Kung-fu Empire
♥3 Mayday
♥3 Glitchtastic
♥3 HARD [bye]
H2 Dualive
♥2 New Day
♥1 Blow
♥0 Dynamite
.. Dua Dua Dua
.. Fat Finger
.. Brand New World
-- xRGTMx [dropped out]
♥5 Vrosteriod
♥4 Alice in Mystic Garden
H4 Lop Nur no shoutai
H4 Kung-fu Empire
♥3 Mayday
♥3 Glitchtastic
♥3 HARD [bye]
H2 Dualive
♥2 New Day
♥1 Blow
♥0 Dynamite
.. Dua Dua Dua
.. Fat Finger
.. Brand New World
-- xRGTMx [dropped out]
...vincentw, Lisek, and Oni-91 in a lower tier?? What? What's going on here?
I'll be honest, PURELY because of Hard, I played the files in the opposite direction (so Feraligatr vs. ledgam3r1279, then brunobg24 vs. Loodee...). I ran into 3 REALLY good brackets and then after that things just started getting mediocre and not all that impressive like some people seem to believe. Beware of my lonely opinions haha.
Okay, totals.
xRGTMx
HARD [ddrstepper] - 63
New Day [darkanine] - 2
Brand New World [Oni-91] - 5
doll of love [Telperion] - 5 Seriously this has to win. It's very good.
Dualive [tsugaru7reveng] - 3
Mayday [Spork!] - 4
Fat Finger [Lisek] - 5
Dua Dua Duuua [vincentw] - 4
Blow [chewi] - 5 Could this be a glimmer of hope for chewi?
Kung-fu Empire [Gameoson] - 5
少女アリスと箱庭幻想コンチェルト [Aegis] - 3
ロプノールの商隊 [brunobg24] - 2
Vrosteroid [Loodee] - 6 This should really win too.
Dynamite [ledgam3r1279] - 0
Glitchtastic [Feraligatr] - 8
Holy crap Feraligatr's steamrolling his bracket. Dynamite had some problems but I didn't think they'd be THIS bad. I'm actually surprised ledgam3r1279 has 0... He's usually pretty good! ... In any case, sorry, led... ;-;
Oh, by the way, I honestly want Feraligatr to win the whole contest. He's the only one who made it to Round 2 whose sims I have consistently enjoyed/gave points to. It'll probably be someone like bruno/Gameoson/Telperion but that's who I want to win.
As always, my comments are available here. Be warned, though, I don't really have anything to say for many files this week like I did with round 1 and the qualifiers.
Post #585 · Posted at 2016-05-13 04:50:54pm 9 years ago
![]() | |
---|---|
![]() |
Member+ |
1,000 Posts | |
![]() | |
Reg. 2011-10-14 | |
"now led_light for short" |
I'm sorry, but to everyone who complained that there are "too many jumps" (I assume you're referring to the
chart, but maybe
and
are included too, I don't know), please explain why. Is there a certain section in particular that needs to be changed? Is there some kind of stigma against jumps that I don't know about? Has this ever been a problem with songs like 隅田川夏恋歌
or Fascination ~eternal love mix~
? I'm just confused about where this is coming from, because I don't recall hearing anything like this before.





Post #586 · Posted at 2016-05-13 06:21:54pm 9 years ago
![]() | |
---|---|
![]() |
Member+ |
2,004 Posts | |
![]() | |
Reg. 2009-04-25 | |
![]() | |
"btor2osly" |
Fascination ~eternal love mix~
is not exactly well-loved, and if 隅田川夏恋歌 wasn't such a good song, the reception for the
chart would probably be less positive too. I called out Unreal in my review, but I think 隅田川夏恋歌 is a slightly fairer comparison, even though it's got a much smaller proportion of jumps to taps.


Post #587 · Posted at 2016-05-13 10:29:43pm 9 years ago
![]() | |
---|---|
![]() |
Member+ |
8,620 Posts | |
![]() | |
Reg. 2008-02-24 | |
"icon by hypnosispkmn@tumblr" |
xRGTMx
HARD [ddrstepper]
New Day [darkanine] - 2
Brand New World [Oni-91] - 5
PASS
doll of love [Telperion] - 5
Dualive [tsugaru7reveng] - 4
Mayday [Spork!] - 4
Fat Finger [Lisek] - 5
PASS
Dua Dua Duuua [vincentw] - 4
Blow [chewi] - 5
Kung-fu Empire [Gameoson] - 5
少女アリスと箱庭幻想コンチェルト [Aegis] - 3
PASS
ロプノールの商隊 [brunobg24] - 3
Vrosteroid [Loodee] - 6
Dynamite [ledgam3r1279] - 0
Glitchtastic [Feraligatr] - 8
PASS
HARD [ddrstepper]
New Day [darkanine] - 2
Brand New World [Oni-91] - 5
PASS
doll of love [Telperion] - 5
Dualive [tsugaru7reveng] - 4
Mayday [Spork!] - 4
Fat Finger [Lisek] - 5
PASS
Dua Dua Duuua [vincentw] - 4
Blow [chewi] - 5
Kung-fu Empire [Gameoson] - 5
少女アリスと箱庭幻想コンチェルト [Aegis] - 3
PASS
ロプノールの商隊 [brunobg24] - 3
Vrosteroid [Loodee] - 6
Dynamite [ledgam3r1279] - 0
Glitchtastic [Feraligatr] - 8
PASS
Post #588 · Posted at 2016-05-14 10:05:02am 9 years ago
![]() | |
---|---|
![]() |
Member+ |
1,430 Posts | |
![]() | |
Reg. 2006-06-02 | |
xRGTMx
HARD [ddrstepper]
New Day [darkanine] - 2
Brand New World [Oni-91] - 6
doll of love [Telperion] - 5
Dualive [tsugaru7reveng] - 4
Mayday [Spork!] - 4
Fat Finger [Lisek] - 6
Dua Dua Duuua [vincentw] - 4
Blow [chewi] - 6
Kung-fu Empire [Gameoson] - 5
少女アリスと箱庭幻想コンチェルト [Aegis] - 4
ロプノールの商隊 [brunobg24] - 4
Vrosteroid [Loodee] - 6
Dynamite [ledgam3r1279] - 0
Glitchtastic [Feraligatr] - 8
https://twitter.com/t7r_returns/status/731420943730368513
HARD [ddrstepper]
New Day [darkanine] - 2
Brand New World [Oni-91] - 6
doll of love [Telperion] - 5
Dualive [tsugaru7reveng] - 4
Mayday [Spork!] - 4
Fat Finger [Lisek] - 6
Dua Dua Duuua [vincentw] - 4
Blow [chewi] - 6
Kung-fu Empire [Gameoson] - 5
少女アリスと箱庭幻想コンチェルト [Aegis] - 4
ロプノールの商隊 [brunobg24] - 4
Vrosteroid [Loodee] - 6
Dynamite [ledgam3r1279] - 0
Glitchtastic [Feraligatr] - 8
https://twitter.com/t7r_returns/status/731420943730368513
Post #589 · Posted at 2016-05-14 10:34:14am 9 years ago
xRGTMx
HARD [ddrstepper]
New Day [darkanine] - 3
Brand New World [Oni-91] - 5
doll of love [Telperion] - 6
Dualive [tsugaru7reveng] - 4
Mayday [Spork!] - 5
Fat Finger [Lisek] - 5
Dua Dua Duuua [vincentw] - 5
Blow [chewi] - 5
Kung-fu Empire [Gameoson] - 6
少女アリスと箱庭幻想コンチェルト [Aegis] - 3
ロプノールの商隊 [brunobg24] - 3 this file's really good yo
Vrosteroid [Loodee] - 6
Dynamite [ledgam3r1279] - 0
Glitchtastic [Feraligatr] - 9
HARD [ddrstepper]
New Day [darkanine] - 3
Brand New World [Oni-91] - 5
doll of love [Telperion] - 6
Dualive [tsugaru7reveng] - 4
Mayday [Spork!] - 5
Fat Finger [Lisek] - 5
Dua Dua Duuua [vincentw] - 5
Blow [chewi] - 5
Kung-fu Empire [Gameoson] - 6
少女アリスと箱庭幻想コンチェルト [Aegis] - 3
ロプノールの商隊 [brunobg24] - 3 this file's really good yo
Vrosteroid [Loodee] - 6
Dynamite [ledgam3r1279] - 0
Glitchtastic [Feraligatr] - 9
Post #590 · Posted at 2016-05-14 11:25:36am 9 years ago
Fixing Loodee's.
xRGTMx
HARD [ddrstepper] - +1 round
New Day [darkanine] - 3
Brand New World [Oni-91] - 6
doll of love [Telperion] - 6
Dualive [tsugaru7reveng] - 4
Mayday [Spork!] - 5
Fat Finger [Lisek] - 6
Dua Dua Duuua [vincentw] - 5
Blow [chewi] - 6
Kung-fu Empire [Gameoson] - 6
少女アリスと箱庭幻想コンチェルト [Aegis] - 4
ロプノールの商隊 [brunobg24] - 4
Vrosteroid [Loodee] - 6
Dynamite [ledgam3r1279] - 0
Glitchtastic [Feraligatr] - 9
I'll vote before the deadline. Wow, almost everyone is in a tight bracket.
xRGTMx
HARD [ddrstepper] - +1 round
New Day [darkanine] - 3
Brand New World [Oni-91] - 6
doll of love [Telperion] - 6
Dualive [tsugaru7reveng] - 4
Mayday [Spork!] - 5
Fat Finger [Lisek] - 6
Dua Dua Duuua [vincentw] - 5
Blow [chewi] - 6
Kung-fu Empire [Gameoson] - 6
少女アリスと箱庭幻想コンチェルト [Aegis] - 4
ロプノールの商隊 [brunobg24] - 4
Vrosteroid [Loodee] - 6
Dynamite [ledgam3r1279] - 0
Glitchtastic [Feraligatr] - 9
I'll vote before the deadline. Wow, almost everyone is in a tight bracket.
Post #591 · Posted at 2016-05-14 02:29:13pm 9 years ago
![]() | |
---|---|
![]() |
Member |
479 Posts | |
![]() | |
Reg. 2011-09-08 | |
xRGTMx
HARD [ddrstepper] - bye
New Day [darkanine] - 4
Brand New World [Oni-91] - 6
doll of love [Telperion] - 7
Dualive [tsugaru7reveng] - 4
Mayday [Spork!] - 5
Fat Finger [Lisek] - 6
Dua Dua Duuua [vincentw] - 5
Blow [chewi] - 7
Kung-fu Empire [Gameoson] - 6
少女アリスと箱庭幻想コンチェルト [Aegis] - 5
ロプノールの商隊 [brunobg24] - 4
Vrosteroid [Loodee] - 7
Dynamite [ledgam3r1279] - 0
Glitchtastic [Feraligatr] - 10
HARD [ddrstepper] - bye
New Day [darkanine] - 4
Brand New World [Oni-91] - 6
doll of love [Telperion] - 7
Dualive [tsugaru7reveng] - 4
Mayday [Spork!] - 5
Fat Finger [Lisek] - 6
Dua Dua Duuua [vincentw] - 5
Blow [chewi] - 7
Kung-fu Empire [Gameoson] - 6
少女アリスと箱庭幻想コンチェルト [Aegis] - 5
ロプノールの商隊 [brunobg24] - 4
Vrosteroid [Loodee] - 7
Dynamite [ledgam3r1279] - 0
Glitchtastic [Feraligatr] - 10
Post #592 · Posted at 2016-05-14 03:19:17pm 9 years ago
VOTES with comments
As before, I played the two hardest charts of each song on keyboard and rated them and left a short comment on each chart.
Here's how the rating scale from 0-10 works:
4 - Okay: Many mistakes.
6 - Good: Little to no mistakes.
8 - Great: No big mistakes, and the chart was fun to play.
10 - Flawless: The chart was perfect and super fun to play.
If you want me to do a full review for your chart or you have a question about my review, PM me.
NOTE: One thing that I noticed with a few charts is that the arrows were quantized incorrectly. These charts had 24th swing, but the steps were mainly 16ths. These charts were Fat Finger and Glitchtastic.
HARD
- Hard: 7.5 - Well, that was an interesting song, to say the least. But the chart was good. I might have made the BPM 84, but the current BPM worked.
- Expert: 7.5 - Fun chart as well. This definitely had a chance at beating whatever xRGTMx would’ve submitted.
New Day - Thanks for all the votes on my chart. Let the best chart win!
Brand New World
- Medium: 7.5 - I figured I’d play this chart even though it’s the chart I’m up against. Great chart. I liked the use of freezes in this chart.
- Hard: 8 - This was a great chart and fun to play. I enjoyed the off-beats and streams in this chart.
doll of love
- Hard: 8.5 - Wow, that was fun. I had to play the chart a couple times through to get it right, which just means that it was a challenging chart, and it gives it replay value. There was nothing about this chart I didn’t like. Clever use of freezes and patterns.
- Expert: 8 - I liked the addition of an easy challenge chart. It was well stepped and there was really not much to say about it. It kind of seemed like it was choreographed a bit, as well, which is cool.
Dualive
- Medium: 8 - Cool chart!
- Hard: 8 - Good chart overall. I liked the off-beat jumps in some places, but, to me, they seemed a tad bit overused. Other than that, I really liked the file.
WINNER: doll of love - Both of these files were really good, but doll of love had a super fun Hard chart that was just a bit more fun and complex than Dualive’s Hard chart.
Mayday
- Hard: 7 - That was a very unique chart, and overall I liked it. The gimmicks were cool and fun, and the chart was okay too. I didn’t like the steps that much though, but there was no real errors I could find. Also, I don’t think stepping to vocals is that good in stepcharts, mainly because vocals aren’t perfectly timed, but with the song there was really no other choice.
- Expert: 7.5 - I liked this chart a little more. Again, I’m not a big fan of stepping to vocals, but in this case it kind of worked. The chart’s steps were good and fun.
Fat Finger
- Medium: 7.5 - This was a pretty good chart, and I have no complaints about it. I liked what you did with the mines.
- Hard: 7 - This chart was good and all, but the timing of the steps was off. A big portion, if not the entire song, was in 24th swing, but however, none of that was stepped. A lot of the 16ths in the song, especially toward the end, should have been 24ths, and the same goes for the 32nds. Other than that, the chart was decent and fun to play.
WINNER: Mayday - This was a really close matchup, but Mayday gets the vote because it was a unique chart that stood out. I might have given the vote to Fat Finger if the steps were quantized correctly. Both charts were good, and it was hard to pick a winner.
Dua Dua Duuua
- Medium:22 7.5 - This was a good stepchart with neat gimmicks. I liked it.
- Hard: 8 - I thought this stepchart was pretty creative, especially with the 1, 2, 3 and the step, jump, and hand. It was an interesting song choice, but you made it work.
Blow
- Hard: 7.5 - The steps were pretty basic, but they worked well. I liked your use of double-steps (maybe they were crossovers, but I did them as double-steps) and because they were with 4th notes, it made the chart more interesting instead of taking away from it.
- Expert: 7.5 - This chart was good as well, and the steps were kind of fun. There were some minor things I didn’t like, but that is just my opinion.
WINNER: Dua Dua Duuua - Dua Dua Duuua’s charts were quite interesting and fun to play, but so were Blow’s charts. This was a really close call, but I picked Dua Dua Duuua because of its nice-flowing patterns and creative stepcharts.
Kung-fu Empire
- Hard: 8 - This was a well-flowing chart, with basic, but fun, patterns. I liked it, especially the slowdown at the end.
- Expert: 8.5 - This chart was great and well stepped. It had complex patterns which made it fun to play. I was somewhat surprised that there wasn’t other rhythms besides 16ths, but it worked out.
Alice in Mystic Garden
- Medium: 7.5 - This was a good fun chart. I probably would have picked a different choice for the BPM, maybe 2x speed or 1.5x speed. However that didn’t take away from the overall value of the chart.
- Hard: 8 - This chart was fun as well, and had basic, but fun patterns. I liked it.
WINNER: Kung-fu Empire - Although I liked playing Alice in Mystic Garden, I liked playing Kung-fu Empire a bit more. Both charts were great, but I picked Kung-fu Empire for its smooth patterns and neat slowdown.
ロプノールの商隊
- Hard: 7.5 - It was a great chart, but it didn’t stand out that much. However, this chart was fun to play.
- Expert: 8.5 - This chart was great. However I noticed a slight mistake in the rhythm of the notes. The red, yellow, and blue jumps at m70 should actually be 6th note (green/purple) jumps, if I’m not mistaken. That also applies to the Hard chart as well. The rest of the chart was good, and I didn’t see any other problems.
Vrosteroid
- Hard: 8 - This chart was cool, especially with the gimmicks. I liked the slowdown in the chart as well. I might have done this chart at half-speed for the BPM, but it worked well at the current BPM.
- Expert: 8.5 - This chart was good as well, and I liked what you did with the mines. Overall good chart.
WINNER - Vrosteroid - Honestly, this could have gone either way; it was really close. Both charts were well stepped. However Vrosteroid had unique speed gimmicks and a slowdown that ロプノールの商隊 didn’t have.
Dynamite
- Medium: 8 - I liked the chart a lot, and the speed changes were neat, too. Great chart!
- Hard: 9 - Holy crap, that was fun! I loved the jump-step-jump patterns at 200 BPM, and I’m sure if I played this chart on pad, those would feel like actual twerking. Great chart!
Glitchtastic
- Hard: 7 - The chart was good, but the song was indeed in 24th swing, but the steps were not. So a lot of those 16ths should have been 12ths and 24ths. Other that that, the chart was good.
- Expert: 8 - The chart was fun, but as I said, the song was in 24th swing, but instead, there was a weird combination of 16ths and 12ths. The chart was still fun though.
WINNER: Dynamite - I have no idea why Dynamite is going without any points when it was one of the best charts this round. I may have given my vote to Glitchtastic if its steps were quantized correctly. Both charts’ patterns were good, but I loved Dynamite’s twerk-jumps and overall patterns.
As before, I played the two hardest charts of each song on keyboard and rated them and left a short comment on each chart.
Here's how the rating scale from 0-10 works:
4 - Okay: Many mistakes.
6 - Good: Little to no mistakes.
8 - Great: No big mistakes, and the chart was fun to play.
10 - Flawless: The chart was perfect and super fun to play.
If you want me to do a full review for your chart or you have a question about my review, PM me.
NOTE: One thing that I noticed with a few charts is that the arrows were quantized incorrectly. These charts had 24th swing, but the steps were mainly 16ths. These charts were Fat Finger and Glitchtastic.
HARD
- Hard: 7.5 - Well, that was an interesting song, to say the least. But the chart was good. I might have made the BPM 84, but the current BPM worked.
- Expert: 7.5 - Fun chart as well. This definitely had a chance at beating whatever xRGTMx would’ve submitted.
New Day - Thanks for all the votes on my chart. Let the best chart win!
Brand New World
- Medium: 7.5 - I figured I’d play this chart even though it’s the chart I’m up against. Great chart. I liked the use of freezes in this chart.
- Hard: 8 - This was a great chart and fun to play. I enjoyed the off-beats and streams in this chart.
doll of love
- Hard: 8.5 - Wow, that was fun. I had to play the chart a couple times through to get it right, which just means that it was a challenging chart, and it gives it replay value. There was nothing about this chart I didn’t like. Clever use of freezes and patterns.
- Expert: 8 - I liked the addition of an easy challenge chart. It was well stepped and there was really not much to say about it. It kind of seemed like it was choreographed a bit, as well, which is cool.
Dualive
- Medium: 8 - Cool chart!
- Hard: 8 - Good chart overall. I liked the off-beat jumps in some places, but, to me, they seemed a tad bit overused. Other than that, I really liked the file.
WINNER: doll of love - Both of these files were really good, but doll of love had a super fun Hard chart that was just a bit more fun and complex than Dualive’s Hard chart.
Mayday
- Hard: 7 - That was a very unique chart, and overall I liked it. The gimmicks were cool and fun, and the chart was okay too. I didn’t like the steps that much though, but there was no real errors I could find. Also, I don’t think stepping to vocals is that good in stepcharts, mainly because vocals aren’t perfectly timed, but with the song there was really no other choice.
- Expert: 7.5 - I liked this chart a little more. Again, I’m not a big fan of stepping to vocals, but in this case it kind of worked. The chart’s steps were good and fun.
Fat Finger
- Medium: 7.5 - This was a pretty good chart, and I have no complaints about it. I liked what you did with the mines.
- Hard: 7 - This chart was good and all, but the timing of the steps was off. A big portion, if not the entire song, was in 24th swing, but however, none of that was stepped. A lot of the 16ths in the song, especially toward the end, should have been 24ths, and the same goes for the 32nds. Other than that, the chart was decent and fun to play.
WINNER: Mayday - This was a really close matchup, but Mayday gets the vote because it was a unique chart that stood out. I might have given the vote to Fat Finger if the steps were quantized correctly. Both charts were good, and it was hard to pick a winner.
Dua Dua Duuua
- Medium:
- Hard: 8 - I thought this stepchart was pretty creative, especially with the 1, 2, 3 and the step, jump, and hand. It was an interesting song choice, but you made it work.
Blow
- Hard: 7.5 - The steps were pretty basic, but they worked well. I liked your use of double-steps (maybe they were crossovers, but I did them as double-steps) and because they were with 4th notes, it made the chart more interesting instead of taking away from it.
- Expert: 7.5 - This chart was good as well, and the steps were kind of fun. There were some minor things I didn’t like, but that is just my opinion.
WINNER: Dua Dua Duuua - Dua Dua Duuua’s charts were quite interesting and fun to play, but so were Blow’s charts. This was a really close call, but I picked Dua Dua Duuua because of its nice-flowing patterns and creative stepcharts.
Kung-fu Empire
- Hard: 8 - This was a well-flowing chart, with basic, but fun, patterns. I liked it, especially the slowdown at the end.
- Expert: 8.5 - This chart was great and well stepped. It had complex patterns which made it fun to play. I was somewhat surprised that there wasn’t other rhythms besides 16ths, but it worked out.
Alice in Mystic Garden
- Medium: 7.5 - This was a good fun chart. I probably would have picked a different choice for the BPM, maybe 2x speed or 1.5x speed. However that didn’t take away from the overall value of the chart.
- Hard: 8 - This chart was fun as well, and had basic, but fun patterns. I liked it.
WINNER: Kung-fu Empire - Although I liked playing Alice in Mystic Garden, I liked playing Kung-fu Empire a bit more. Both charts were great, but I picked Kung-fu Empire for its smooth patterns and neat slowdown.
ロプノールの商隊
- Hard: 7.5 - It was a great chart, but it didn’t stand out that much. However, this chart was fun to play.
- Expert: 8.5 - This chart was great. However I noticed a slight mistake in the rhythm of the notes. The red, yellow, and blue jumps at m70 should actually be 6th note (green/purple) jumps, if I’m not mistaken. That also applies to the Hard chart as well. The rest of the chart was good, and I didn’t see any other problems.
Vrosteroid
- Hard: 8 - This chart was cool, especially with the gimmicks. I liked the slowdown in the chart as well. I might have done this chart at half-speed for the BPM, but it worked well at the current BPM.
- Expert: 8.5 - This chart was good as well, and I liked what you did with the mines. Overall good chart.
WINNER - Vrosteroid - Honestly, this could have gone either way; it was really close. Both charts were well stepped. However Vrosteroid had unique speed gimmicks and a slowdown that ロプノールの商隊 didn’t have.
Dynamite
- Medium: 8 - I liked the chart a lot, and the speed changes were neat, too. Great chart!
- Hard: 9 - Holy crap, that was fun! I loved the jump-step-jump patterns at 200 BPM, and I’m sure if I played this chart on pad, those would feel like actual twerking. Great chart!
Glitchtastic
- Hard: 7 - The chart was good, but the song was indeed in 24th swing, but the steps were not. So a lot of those 16ths should have been 12ths and 24ths. Other that that, the chart was good.
- Expert: 8 - The chart was fun, but as I said, the song was in 24th swing, but instead, there was a weird combination of 16ths and 12ths. The chart was still fun though.
WINNER: Dynamite - I have no idea why Dynamite is going without any points when it was one of the best charts this round. I may have given my vote to Glitchtastic if its steps were quantized correctly. Both charts’ patterns were good, but I loved Dynamite’s twerk-jumps and overall patterns.
Awards
Most Fun Chart: Dynamite / Runner-up: doll of love
Coolest Song: doll of love / Runner-up: Brand New World
TOTALS
xRGTMx
HARD [ddrstepper] - bye
New Day [darkanine] - 4
Brand New World [Oni-91] - 6
doll of love [Telperion] - 8
Dualive [tsugaru7reveng] - 4
Mayday [Spork!] - 6
Fat Finger [Lisek] - 6
Dua Dua Duuua [vincentw] - 6
Blow [chewi] - 7
Kung-fu Empire [Gameoson] - 7
Alice in Mystic Garden [Aegis] - 5 - I don't know why the title was in Japanese when the simfile's title was in English.
ロプノールの商隊 [brunobg24] - 4
Vrosteroid [Loodee] - 8
Dynamite [ledgam3r1279] - 1
Glitchtastic [Feraligatr] - 10
Post #593 · Posted at 2016-05-15 07:20:23pm 9 years ago
xRGTMx
HARD [ddrstepper] - bye
New Day [darkanine] - 4
Brand New World [Oni-91] - 6
PASS
doll of love [Telperion] - 9
Dualive [tsugaru7reveng] - 4
Mayday [Spork!] - 6
Fat Finger [Lisek] - 6
Didn't I start off 4pt behind? xD I did NOT see this close of a matchup happening, especially with my file being as risky as it is. Lisek, I saw your entry and my heart dropped - your song choice is significantly better this week in my eyes. *brohug* I'm happy with whatever happens. I got a good match in
Dua Dua Duuua [vincentw] - 6
Blow [chewi] - 8
Kung-fu Empire [Gameoson] - 7
Alice in Mystic Garden [Aegis] - 5
PASS
ロプノールの商隊 [brunobg24] - 4
Vrosteroid [Loodee] - 9
Dynamite [ledgam3r1279] - 1
Glitchtastic [Feraligatr] - 11
Not gonna lie, I love them both, but the hectic nature of Glitchtastic won me over. The jumps in Dynamite aren't bad, I dunno why people are angsty about them xD
If I PASS'd on your bracket, it means I found both files to be equal, and couldn't decide on a winner. Consider it a dual HM. Cannot wait to see how the rest of this round goes - there are some CRAZY close matches. Full reviews will be starting again this next week, I'll have time available again
(and I can get NuVirus his full R1 review I keep forgetting to pull together...so sorry bro)
HARD [ddrstepper] - bye
New Day [darkanine] - 4
Brand New World [Oni-91] - 6
PASS
doll of love [Telperion] - 9
Dualive [tsugaru7reveng] - 4
Mayday [Spork!] - 6
Fat Finger [Lisek] - 6
Didn't I start off 4pt behind? xD I did NOT see this close of a matchup happening, especially with my file being as risky as it is. Lisek, I saw your entry and my heart dropped - your song choice is significantly better this week in my eyes. *brohug* I'm happy with whatever happens. I got a good match in

Dua Dua Duuua [vincentw] - 6
Blow [chewi] - 8
Kung-fu Empire [Gameoson] - 7
Alice in Mystic Garden [Aegis] - 5
PASS
ロプノールの商隊 [brunobg24] - 4
Vrosteroid [Loodee] - 9
Dynamite [ledgam3r1279] - 1
Glitchtastic [Feraligatr] - 11
Not gonna lie, I love them both, but the hectic nature of Glitchtastic won me over. The jumps in Dynamite aren't bad, I dunno why people are angsty about them xD
If I PASS'd on your bracket, it means I found both files to be equal, and couldn't decide on a winner. Consider it a dual HM. Cannot wait to see how the rest of this round goes - there are some CRAZY close matches. Full reviews will be starting again this next week, I'll have time available again

Post #594 · Posted at 2016-05-15 09:13:37pm 9 years ago
![]() | |
---|---|
![]() |
Member |
694 Posts | |
![]() | |
Reg. 2011-10-10 | |
xRGTMx
HARD [ddrstepper] - bye
New Day [darkanine] - 4
Brand New World [Oni-91] - 7
doll of love [Telperion] - 10
Dualive [tsugaru7reveng] - 4
Mayday [Spork!] - 7
Fat Finger [Lisek] - 6
Dua Dua Duuua [vincentw] - 7
Blow [chewi] - 8
Kung-fu Empire [Gameoson] - 7
Alice in Mystic Garden [Aegis] - 6
ロプノールの商隊 [brunobg24] - 5
Vrosteroid [Loodee] - 9
Dynamite [ledgam3r1279] - 1
Glitchtastic [Feraligatr] - 12
HARD [ddrstepper] - bye
New Day [darkanine] - 4
Brand New World [Oni-91] - 7
doll of love [Telperion] - 10
Dualive [tsugaru7reveng] - 4
Mayday [Spork!] - 7
Fat Finger [Lisek] - 6
Dua Dua Duuua [vincentw] - 7
Blow [chewi] - 8
Kung-fu Empire [Gameoson] - 7
Alice in Mystic Garden [Aegis] - 6
ロプノールの商隊 [brunobg24] - 5
Vrosteroid [Loodee] - 9
Dynamite [ledgam3r1279] - 1
Glitchtastic [Feraligatr] - 12
Post #595 · Posted at 2016-05-15 11:39:00pm 9 years ago
![]() | |
---|---|
![]() |
Member+ |
1,000 Posts | |
![]() | |
Reg. 2011-10-14 | |
"now led_light for short" |
Last updated: 2016-05-15 11:49pm
Quote: darkanine
Alice in Mystic Garden [Aegis] - 5 - I don't know why the title was in Japanese when the simfile's title was in English.
Because 少女アリスと箱庭幻想コンチェルト is the actual title of the song? Even if a simfile only has the romanized title and not the original for whatever reason, the original title is (or at least should be for consistency) shown in the totals regardless. This has been done for at least the past few contests, if I recall (including this one).Post #596 · Posted at 2016-05-16 12:16:58am 9 years ago
OK, no problem. I just got confused and spent longer than I should have looking for the right simfile to play.
Post #597 · Posted at 2016-05-16 03:29:10am 9 years ago
I called it Alice in Mystic Garden because that's how it shows up on the Copula OST I bought.
If people are more familiar with "少女アリスと箱庭幻想コンチェルト" and want to use that, then I can't blame them.
xRGTMx
HARD [ddrstepper] - bye
I would have liked to see what you would have made, xRGTMx.
New Day [darkanine] - 4
Brand New World [Oni-91] - 8
doll of love [Telperion] - 11
Dualive [tsugaru7reveng] - 4
Mayday [Spork!] - 7
Fat Finger [Lisek] - 7
Dua Dua Duuua [vincentw] - 8
Blow [chewi] - 8
Kung-fu Empire [Gameoson] - 7
Alice in Mystic Garden [Aegis] - 6
So much hype.
ロプノールの商隊 [brunobg24] - 5
Vrosteroid [Loodee] - 10
Dynamite [ledgam3r1279] - 1
Glitchtastic [Feraligatr] - 13
If people are more familiar with "少女アリスと箱庭幻想コンチェルト" and want to use that, then I can't blame them.
xRGTMx
HARD [ddrstepper] - bye
I would have liked to see what you would have made, xRGTMx.
New Day [darkanine] - 4
Brand New World [Oni-91] - 8
doll of love [Telperion] - 11
Dualive [tsugaru7reveng] - 4
Mayday [Spork!] - 7
Fat Finger [Lisek] - 7
Dua Dua Duuua [vincentw] - 8
Blow [chewi] - 8
Kung-fu Empire [Gameoson] - 7
Alice in Mystic Garden [Aegis] - 6
So much hype.

ロプノールの商隊 [brunobg24] - 5
Vrosteroid [Loodee] - 10
Dynamite [ledgam3r1279] - 1
Glitchtastic [Feraligatr] - 13
Post #598 · Posted at 2016-05-16 03:18:38pm 9 years ago
![]() | |
---|---|
![]() |
Member+ |
6,086 Posts | |
![]() | |
Reg. 2013-08-17 | |
"five minute white boy challenge" |
New Day [darkanine] - 4
Brand New World [Oni-91] - 8
doll of love [Telperion] - 11
Dualive [tsugaru7reveng] - 4
Mayday [Spork!] - 8
Fat Finger [Lisek] - 7
Dua Dua Duuua [vincentw] - 9
Blow [chewi] - 8
Kung-fu Empire [Gameoson] - 7
Alice in Mystic Garden [Aegis] - 7
ロプノールの商隊 [brunobg24] - 5
Vrosteroid [Loodee] - 10
Dynamite [ledgam3r1279] - 1
Glitchtastic [Feraligatr] - 13
Brand New World [Oni-91] - 8
doll of love [Telperion] - 11
Dualive [tsugaru7reveng] - 4
Mayday [Spork!] - 8
Fat Finger [Lisek] - 7
Dua Dua Duuua [vincentw] - 9
Blow [chewi] - 8
Kung-fu Empire [Gameoson] - 7
Alice in Mystic Garden [Aegis] - 7
ロプノールの商隊 [brunobg24] - 5
Vrosteroid [Loodee] - 10
Dynamite [ledgam3r1279] - 1
Glitchtastic [Feraligatr] - 13
Post #599 · Posted at 2016-05-16 04:59:41pm 9 years ago
![]() | |
---|---|
![]() |
Member+ |
697 Posts | |
![]() | |
Reg. 2013-12-23 | |
"cuppa" |
Dayum. These close matchups are making me out of breath.
xRGTMx
HARD [ddrstepper] - bye
New Day [darkanine] - 5
Brand New World [Oni-91] - 8
doll of love [Telperion] - 12
Dualive [tsugaru7reveng] - 4
Mayday [Spork!] - 9
Fat Finger [Lisek] - 7
Dua Dua Duuua [vincentw] - 9
Blow [chewi] - 8
Kung-fu Empire [Gameoson] - 7
Alice in Mystic Garden [Aegis] - 8
ロプノールの商隊 [brunobg24] - 5
Vrosteroid [Loodee] - 11
Dynamite [ledgam3r1279] - 1
Glitchtastic [Feraligatr] - 14
tiny comments:
- I'm pretty sure that b276-b280 in Lop Nur should have been in equal 12ths.
- Gameoson vs Aegis is the toughest decision in the round imo. Huge kudos to both of you.
- My bracket looks just like me in Round 1 last year but the other way around. chewi put on a fight, that's for sure. Thanks for all the votes!
xRGTMx
HARD [ddrstepper] - bye
New Day [darkanine] - 5
Brand New World [Oni-91] - 8
doll of love [Telperion] - 12
Dualive [tsugaru7reveng] - 4
Mayday [Spork!] - 9
Fat Finger [Lisek] - 7
Dua Dua Duuua [vincentw] - 9
Blow [chewi] - 8
Kung-fu Empire [Gameoson] - 7
Alice in Mystic Garden [Aegis] - 8
ロプノールの商隊 [brunobg24] - 5
Vrosteroid [Loodee] - 11
Dynamite [ledgam3r1279] - 1
Glitchtastic [Feraligatr] - 14
tiny comments:
- I'm pretty sure that b276-b280 in Lop Nur should have been in equal 12ths.
- Gameoson vs Aegis is the toughest decision in the round imo. Huge kudos to both of you.
- My bracket looks just like me in Round 1 last year but the other way around. chewi put on a fight, that's for sure. Thanks for all the votes!
Post #600 · Posted at 2016-05-16 05:21:39pm 9 years ago
![]() | |
---|---|
![]() |
Member |
2,956 Posts | |
![]() | |
Reg. 2013-10-26 | |
"[Art by LilyBreez]" |
So now it goes...
ddrstepper
Oni-91
Telperion
Spork!
vincentw
Aegis
Loodee
Feraligatr
Correct me if I'm wrong.
ddrstepper
Oni-91
Telperion
Spork!
vincentw
Aegis
Loodee
Feraligatr
Correct me if I'm wrong.