Step Rating Scales Poll

ITG scale all day long

---

Guitar Hero/Drummania.

Sounds legit.

Original- 4
X- 5
Mungyodance-1

I like the GFDM scale too. The XG scale was a good idea - scale to 10 with decimal points to the hundredths. But as it is, I prefer the ITG scale.

Not adding GF/DM because it's pretty much the same as MGD.

Original- 5
X- 5
Mungyodance-1

since this seems to have been missed

---

Edit: SORRY FOR NEVER PLAYING ITG

Imma vote for the Mungyodance scale too, just because it's so specific yet so easy to understand.

---

So here's the new list of votes:

Original- 0
X- 5
ITG- 3
Mungyodance- 2

Spirit of Nightmare needs to clarify his answer.

I'll choose ITG (modified) scale. The original ITG was 1-13, but ITG 3 was going to have 1-14, and who's to say it couldn't have gone to 15 eventually (the ITG theme recognizes a 15 bar chart).

The Mungyodance scale seems like the most logical because you could show the difference between an easy 7 or a hard 7 or a medium 7 by making them 70 79 and 75 respectively, but due to the limit of 100, it would become akward if this was the original scale (DDR X would have just made it 1-200, and it would have been a MESS again), thus I like the ITG scale because it's familiar and can always increase without defying logic or artificial boundaries. If an MGD scale was initially created and Max 300 was given a 95, then MaxX Unlimited got a 100, you now have Max.(period), PSMO, TLOM, Max300 SMMMOni, and on all getting a rating of 100, then the same mess of no way to differentiate between a really, really hard 100 or a relatively easy 100 (basically you need a scale that can expand).

---

Aren't there ratings in MGD that are more than 100?

Original- 0
X- 5
ITG- 4
Mungyodance- 2

But that's invalid. The expert level Mungyodance songs had ratings over 100, up to 160 (signifying a 16-footer on the DDR/ITG scale). Therefore, the scale fits in the entire modified ITG scale.

---

Then I CHANGE my vote to MGD (shame I've never played it but I was making assumptions about it huh?).

---

Don't forget that when you assume, you make an ass out of u and me.

I guess I'll also vote for Mungyodance because that's essentially what I was getting at on a scale of 1-100, with going higher if necessary. But they also need a groove radar to work on songs that have weaknesses of yours. I can jump into Afronova in 3rd mix knowing that I suck at consecutive jumps, but on Extreme I see the groove radar with all the air.

Original- 0
X- 5
ITG- 3
Mungyodance- 4

Fixed it for you there.

---

Here's my cheat sheet that converts DDR X scale to Mungyodance scale:

19 -> 140
18 -> 131
17 -> 122
16 -> 113
15 -> 104
14 -> 95-104
everything else /1.5

asdf I vote MGD

---

I'll vote for X scale.

---

Original- 0
X- 6
ITG- 3
Mungyodance- 5

My vote is for the DDR X scale... but I think I like it more because it's what I'm used to

Original- 0
X- 7
ITG- 3
Mungyodance- 5