Post #361 · Posted at 2015-04-06 09:30:59pm 9.1 years ago
 ledgam3r1279 | |
|---|---|
 |
Member+ |
| 995 Posts | |
 | |
| Reg. 2011-10-14 | |
| "now led_light for short" | |
Wow, the 6 people who voted were the 6 people actually competing that round. Meanwhile, there are people who are voting in the singles rounds despite not competing in singles (or is that just me?).
Anyway, here's some better-late-than-never replies:
Just a little thing on rhythm choice: about halfway through the song, there's a part in the song with a 4th and an 8th, that was not stepped accordingly (beats 172-180).
has the same thing; I guess you were expecting to be a little more different?
was great, though M29-36 and M62-69 are an obvious direct copy+paste with a single arrow added into M65 that breaks the flow and makes you double step out of place.
Is great, though I wasn't a fan of the break in M40 as it leaves you guessing how to start the next pattern. Otherwise completely solid.
M39-42 should be one long 12345678 run (keep alternating feet!). I guess I could add something to make that more clear.
Thanks for the feedback, guys!
Anyway, here's some better-late-than-never replies:
Quote: mf32892
Just a little thing on rhythm choice: about halfway through the song, there's a part in the song with a 4th and an 8th, that was not stepped accordingly (beats 172-180). has the same thing; I guess you were expecting to be a little more different?Quote: Spork!
in M9/73 it has a very unusual stretch compared to all the other patterns.
You won't believe how many times I revised this particular pattern. I think it makes sense for the song, but I guess I can't satisfy everybody.Quote: Spork!
The spin in M61 leaves you backward unless you double step it weird or start with a different foot than what seems natural.
It's less of a spin and more of a crossover if you keep alternating feet and end the pattern on your right foot. After that, you can either footswitch or add some ghost steps to prepare yourself for the next measure.Quote: Spork!
was great, though M29-36 and M62-69 are an obvious direct copy+paste with a single arrow added into M65 that breaks the flow and makes you double step out of place.Quote: ledgam3r1279
IMO copy+paste works just fine if done well,
. . . although I'm not sure what you mean by "out of place" or what this "break" actually is.Quote: Spork!
Is great, though I wasn't a fan of the break in M40 as it leaves you guessing how to start the next pattern. Otherwise completely solid.Thanks for the feedback, guys!
Post #362 · Posted at 2015-04-06 10:18:12pm 9.1 years ago
| hooky | |
|---|---|
 |
Member |
| 2,683 Posts | |
| | |
| Reg. 2007-07-28 | |
Quote: ledgam3r1279
there are people who are voting in the singles rounds despite not competing in singles
This is allowed.
Anyway, I'm going to start playing the files in a bit.
Post #363 · Posted at 2015-04-06 10:34:20pm 9.1 years ago
| DDRDAIKENKAI | |
|---|---|
 |
Member+ |
| 441 Posts | |
| | |
| Reg. 2006-11-25 | |
| "djSOUTA" | |
[DIAVOLO BRACKET]
That Man [Oni-91] - 1
Rattlesnake [Pandemonium X] - 1
BLACK.by X-Cross Fade [tsugaru7reveng] - 1
Red Balloon [Astroman129] - 1
[FUBUKI BRACKET]
Pizza Rolls [Loodee] - 1
No Tears [CLOUDIO] - 1
童話回廊 [Silverhawke]
내가 제일 잘 나가 [Pie-kun] - 2
[DO BACK BURN BRACKET]
Move That Body [Gameoson]
Copy & Paste [DDRDAIKENKAI] - 1
tiger yamato [xXMokou98xX] - 2
Come & Get it [hooky]
[CHRONOXIA BRACKET]
tig-hug [TaroNuke]
恋愛レボリューション２１ -秋葉工房MIX- [Scarz] - 2
LOVE IS TIMING [chewi]
3 [tamtamino] - 1
That Man [Oni-91] - 1
Rattlesnake [Pandemonium X] - 1
BLACK.by X-Cross Fade [tsugaru7reveng] - 1
Red Balloon [Astroman129] - 1
[FUBUKI BRACKET]
Pizza Rolls [Loodee] - 1
No Tears [CLOUDIO] - 1
童話回廊 [Silverhawke]
내가 제일 잘 나가 [Pie-kun] - 2
[DO BACK BURN BRACKET]
Move That Body [Gameoson]
Copy & Paste [DDRDAIKENKAI] - 1
tiger yamato [xXMokou98xX] - 2
Come & Get it [hooky]
[CHRONOXIA BRACKET]
tig-hug [TaroNuke]
恋愛レボリューション２１ -秋葉工房MIX- [Scarz] - 2
LOVE IS TIMING [chewi]
3 [tamtamino] - 1
Post #364 · Posted at 2015-04-07 12:49:14am 9.1 years ago
| ledgam3r1279 | |
|---|---|
|
Member+ |
| 995 Posts | |
| | |
| Reg. 2011-10-14 | |
| "now led_light for short" | |
Quote: hooky
Quote: ledgam3r1279
there are people who are voting in the singles rounds despite not competing in singles
This is allowed.
I never said it was a bad thing; I'm just trying to say that there should be more people voting.
Post #365 · Posted at 2015-04-07 12:57:19am 9.1 years ago
| chewi | |
|---|---|
 |
Member+ |
| 8,537 Posts | |
| Not Set | |
| Reg. 2008-02-24 | |
There's not as many people who play Doubles so it makes sense there's less votes. Personally, I don't care for doubles that much / don't know a lot about it so I wouldn't feel comfortable judging double charts. I'm sure many people feel the same...
Post #366 · Posted at 2015-04-07 05:24:15am 9.1 years ago
| ledgam3r1279 | |
|---|---|
|
Member+ |
| 995 Posts | |
| | |
| Reg. 2011-10-14 | |
| "now led_light for short" | |
Fair enough.
[DIAVOLO BRACKET]
That Man [Oni-91] - 2
Rattlesnake [Pandemonium X] - 1
BLACK.by X-Cross Fade [tsugaru7reveng] - 2
Red Balloon [Astroman129] - 1
[FUBUKI BRACKET]
Pizza Rolls [Loodee] - 1
No Tears [CLOUDIO] - 2
童話回廊 [Silverhawke]
내가 제일 잘 나가 [Pie-kun] - 3
DO BACK BURN BRACKET
Move That Body [Gameoson]
Copy & Paste [DDRDAIKENKAI] - 2
tiger yamato [xXMokou98xX] - 3
Come & Get it [hooky]
[CHRONOXIA BRACKET]
tig-hug [TaroNuke]
恋愛レボリューション２１ -秋葉工房MIX- [Scarz] - 3
LOVE IS TIMING [chewi] - 1
3 [tamtamino] - 1
That Man [Oni-91] - 2
Rattlesnake [Pandemonium X] - 1
BLACK.by X-Cross Fade [tsugaru7reveng] - 2
Red Balloon [Astroman129] - 1
[FUBUKI BRACKET]
Pizza Rolls [Loodee] - 1
No Tears [CLOUDIO] - 2
童話回廊 [Silverhawke]
내가 제일 잘 나가 [Pie-kun] - 3
DO BACK BURN BRACKET
Move That Body [Gameoson]
Copy & Paste [DDRDAIKENKAI] - 2
tiger yamato [xXMokou98xX] - 3
Come & Get it [hooky]
[CHRONOXIA BRACKET]
tig-hug [TaroNuke]
恋愛レボリューション２１ -秋葉工房MIX- [Scarz] - 3
LOVE IS TIMING [chewi] - 1
3 [tamtamino] - 1
Post #367 · Posted at 2015-04-07 07:28:38pm 9.1 years ago
| Pandemonium X | |
|---|---|
 |
Member |
| 10,360 Posts | |
| | |
| Reg. 2007-04-06 | |
  | |
[DIAVOLO BRACKET]
That Man [Oni-91] - 2
Rattlesnake [Pandemonium X] - 1
BLACK.by X-Cross Fade [tsugaru7reveng] - 3
Red Balloon [Astroman129] - 1
[FUBUKI BRACKET]
Pizza Rolls [Loodee] - 2
No Tears [CLOUDIO] - 2
童話回廊 [Silverhawke]
내가 제일 잘 나가 [Pie-kun] - 4 (Match of the round)
DO BACK BURN BRACKET
Move That Body [Gameoson] - 1
Copy & Paste [DDRDAIKENKAI] - 2
tiger yamato [xXMokou98xX] - 3
Come & Get it [hooky] - 1
[CHRONOXIA BRACKET]
tig-hug [TaroNuke] - 1
恋愛レボリューション２１ -秋葉工房MIX- [Scarz] - 3
LOVE IS TIMING [chewi] - 1
3 [tamtamino] - 2
----------------------
TOP 5
1. I Am the Best [Pie-kun]
2. 童話回廊 [Silverhawke]
3. Move That Body [Gameoson]
4. BLACK. By X-Cross Fade [tsugaru7reveng]
5. That Man [Oni-91]
There's going to be some major upsets this round I can tell.
That Man [Oni-91] - 2
Rattlesnake [Pandemonium X] - 1
BLACK.by X-Cross Fade [tsugaru7reveng] - 3
Red Balloon [Astroman129] - 1
[FUBUKI BRACKET]
Pizza Rolls [Loodee] - 2
No Tears [CLOUDIO] - 2
童話回廊 [Silverhawke]
내가 제일 잘 나가 [Pie-kun] - 4 (Match of the round)
DO BACK BURN BRACKET
Move That Body [Gameoson] - 1
Copy & Paste [DDRDAIKENKAI] - 2
tiger yamato [xXMokou98xX] - 3
Come & Get it [hooky] - 1
[CHRONOXIA BRACKET]
tig-hug [TaroNuke] - 1
恋愛レボリューション２１ -秋葉工房MIX- [Scarz] - 3
LOVE IS TIMING [chewi] - 1
3 [tamtamino] - 2
----------------------
TOP 5
1. I Am the Best [Pie-kun]
2. 童話回廊 [Silverhawke]
3. Move That Body [Gameoson]
4. BLACK. By X-Cross Fade [tsugaru7reveng]
5. That Man [Oni-91]
There's going to be some major upsets this round I can tell.
Post #368 · Posted at 2015-04-07 07:52:15pm 9.1 years ago
| chewi | |
|---|---|
|
Member+ |
| 8,537 Posts | |
| Not Set | |
| Reg. 2008-02-24 | |
That's for sure, I'm upset you didn't vote for me. 
Post #369 · Posted at 2015-04-07 08:32:46pm 9.1 years ago
[DIAVOLO BRACKET]
That Man [Oni-91] - 3
Rattlesnake [Pandemonium X] - 1
BLACK.by X-Cross Fade [tsugaru7reveng] - 4
Red Balloon [Astroman129] - 1
[FUBUKI BRACKET]
Pizza Rolls [Loodee] - 2
No Tears [CLOUDIO] - 3
童話回廊 [Silverhawke]
내가 제일 잘 나가 [Pie-kun] - 5
[DO BACK BURN BRACKET]
Move That Body [Gameoson] - 1
Copy & Paste [DDRDAIKENKAI] - 3
tiger yamato [xXMokou98xX] - 4
Come & Get it [hooky] - 1
[CHRONOXIA BRACKET]
tig-hug [TaroNuke] - 1
恋愛レボリューション２１ -秋葉工房MIX- [Scarz] - 4
LOVE IS TIMING [chewi] - 1
3 [tamtamino] - 2
That Man [Oni-91] - 3
Rattlesnake [Pandemonium X] - 1
BLACK.by X-Cross Fade [tsugaru7reveng] - 4
Red Balloon [Astroman129] - 1
[FUBUKI BRACKET]
Pizza Rolls [Loodee] - 2
No Tears [CLOUDIO] - 3
童話回廊 [Silverhawke]
내가 제일 잘 나가 [Pie-kun] - 5
[DO BACK BURN BRACKET]
Move That Body [Gameoson] - 1
Copy & Paste [DDRDAIKENKAI] - 3
tiger yamato [xXMokou98xX] - 4
Come & Get it [hooky] - 1
[CHRONOXIA BRACKET]
tig-hug [TaroNuke] - 1
恋愛レボリューション２１ -秋葉工房MIX- [Scarz] - 4
LOVE IS TIMING [chewi] - 1
3 [tamtamino] - 2
Post #370 · Posted at 2015-04-07 09:22:34pm 9.1 years ago
[DIAVOLO BRACKET]
That Man [Oni-91] - 4
Rattlesnake [Pandemonium X] - 1
BLACK.by X-Cross Fade [tsugaru7reveng] - 5
Red Balloon [Astroman129] - 1
[FUBUKI BRACKET]
Pizza Rolls [Loodee] - 3
No Tears [CLOUDIO] - 3
童話回廊 [Silverhawke] - 1
내가 제일 잘 나가 [Pie-kun] - 5
[DO BACK BURN BRACKET]
Move That Body [Gameoson] - 1
Copy & Paste [DDRDAIKENKAI] - 3
tiger yamato [xXMokou98xX] - 5
Come & Get it [hooky] - 1
[CHRONOXIA BRACKET]
tig-hug [TaroNuke] - 1
恋愛レボリューション２１ -秋葉工房MIX- [Scarz] - 5
LOVE IS TIMING [chewi] - 2
3 [tamtamino] - 2
NOTES:
TOP 5
童話回廊 [Silverhawke]
I Am the Best [Pie-kun]
That Man [Oni-91]
Copy & Paste [DDRDAIKENKAI]
Pizza Rolls [Loodee]/BLACK.by X-Cross Fade [tsugaru7reveng] (tied for 5th)
That Man [Oni-91] - 4
Rattlesnake [Pandemonium X] - 1
BLACK.by X-Cross Fade [tsugaru7reveng] - 5
Red Balloon [Astroman129] - 1
[FUBUKI BRACKET]
Pizza Rolls [Loodee] - 3
No Tears [CLOUDIO] - 3
童話回廊 [Silverhawke] - 1
내가 제일 잘 나가 [Pie-kun] - 5
[DO BACK BURN BRACKET]
Move That Body [Gameoson] - 1
Copy & Paste [DDRDAIKENKAI] - 3
tiger yamato [xXMokou98xX] - 5
Come & Get it [hooky] - 1
[CHRONOXIA BRACKET]
tig-hug [TaroNuke] - 1
恋愛レボリューション２１ -秋葉工房MIX- [Scarz] - 5
LOVE IS TIMING [chewi] - 2
3 [tamtamino] - 2
NOTES:
Oni-91 vs. Pandemonium X
That Man was good clean fun, and I'm a sucker for swing... Actually, both song choices were really good. But the steps for Rattlesnake could use sometwerking tweaking, I mean tweaking!
tsugaru7reveng vs. Astroman129
Both files were very good, but BLACK.by X-Cross Fade was just a bit better (even if it wasn't a boss-level chart like I would have liked for the song. Come on, it's just screaming to be hard!)
Loodee vs. CLOUDIO
Pizza Rolls was pretty tight (also thank you for including rolls in Pizza Rolls
). No Tears isn't bad but there were a lot of missed opportunities for jumps.
Silverhawke vs. Pie-kun
Arrogant song choice much, Pie-kun? Kidding, of course. Both files are excellent, but Silverhawke's entry was just a little bit better.
Gameoson vs. DDRDAIKENKAI
Oh crap, Copy & Paste is REALLY good. I'm getting Ctrl+F4'd this round aren't I?
xXMokou98Xx vs. hooky
Come & Get It was not only sloppy, but WHAT THE HELL WERE THOSE SPEEDUPS? Just… no. For lessons on how to use BPM changes, please consult tiger yamato.
TaroNuke vs. Scarz
Both files are very good, but Renai Revolution is a bit more polished. tig-hug had a few rough spots.
chewi vs. tamtamino
3's steps are a bit inconsistent; changing the patterns to avoid repetition is fine and in fact encouraged, but changing the rhythms randomly like what happens in 3 isn't. The 333 combo was cute though. LOVE IS TIMING is okay I guess, at the very least it tends to be stepped more consistently.
That Man was good clean fun, and I'm a sucker for swing... Actually, both song choices were really good. But the steps for Rattlesnake could use some
tsugaru7reveng vs. Astroman129
Both files were very good, but BLACK.by X-Cross Fade was just a bit better (even if it wasn't a boss-level chart like I would have liked for the song. Come on, it's just screaming to be hard!)
Loodee vs. CLOUDIO
Pizza Rolls was pretty tight (also thank you for including rolls in Pizza Rolls
). No Tears isn't bad but there were a lot of missed opportunities for jumps.Silverhawke vs. Pie-kun
Arrogant song choice much, Pie-kun? Kidding, of course.
Both files are excellent, but Silverhawke's entry was just a little bit better.Gameoson vs. DDRDAIKENKAI
Oh crap, Copy & Paste is REALLY good. I'm getting Ctrl+F4'd this round aren't I?
xXMokou98Xx vs. hooky
Come & Get It was not only sloppy, but WHAT THE HELL WERE THOSE SPEEDUPS? Just… no. For lessons on how to use BPM changes, please consult tiger yamato.
TaroNuke vs. Scarz
Both files are very good, but Renai Revolution is a bit more polished. tig-hug had a few rough spots.
chewi vs. tamtamino
3's steps are a bit inconsistent; changing the patterns to avoid repetition is fine and in fact encouraged, but changing the rhythms randomly like what happens in 3 isn't. The 333 combo was cute though. LOVE IS TIMING is okay I guess, at the very least it tends to be stepped more consistently.
TOP 5
童話回廊 [Silverhawke]
I Am the Best [Pie-kun]
That Man [Oni-91]
Copy & Paste [DDRDAIKENKAI]
Pizza Rolls [Loodee]/BLACK.by X-Cross Fade [tsugaru7reveng] (tied for 5th)
Post #371 · Posted at 2015-04-08 05:20:22am 9.1 years ago
| hooky | |
|---|---|
|
Member |
| 2,683 Posts | |
| | |
| Reg. 2007-07-28 | |
VOTES
[DIAVOLO BRACKET]
That Man [Oni-91] - 4
Rattlesnake [Pandemonium X] - 2
BLACK.by X-Cross Fade [tsugaru7reveng] - 6
Red Balloon [Astroman129] - 1
[FUBUKI BRACKET]
Pizza Rolls [Loodee] - 3
No Tears [CLOUDIO] - 4
童話回廊 [Silverhawke] - 2
내가 제일 잘 나가 [Pie-kun] - 5
[DO BACK BURN BRACKET]
Move That Body [Gameoson] - 1
Copy & Paste [DDRDAIKENKAI] - 4
tiger yamato [xXMokou98xX] - 5
Come & Get it [hooky] - 1
[CHRONOXIA BRACKET]
tig-hug [TaroNuke] - 1
恋愛レボリューション２１ -秋葉工房MIX- [Scarz] - 6
LOVE IS TIMING [chewi] - 2
3 [tamtamino] - 3
REVIEWS
[DIAVOLO BRACKET]
That Man [Oni-91] - 4
Rattlesnake [Pandemonium X] - 2
BLACK.by X-Cross Fade [tsugaru7reveng] - 6
Red Balloon [Astroman129] - 1
[FUBUKI BRACKET]
Pizza Rolls [Loodee] - 3
No Tears [CLOUDIO] - 4
童話回廊 [Silverhawke] - 2
내가 제일 잘 나가 [Pie-kun] - 5
[DO BACK BURN BRACKET]
Move That Body [Gameoson] - 1
Copy & Paste [DDRDAIKENKAI] - 4
tiger yamato [xXMokou98xX] - 5
Come & Get it [hooky] - 1
[CHRONOXIA BRACKET]
tig-hug [TaroNuke] - 1
恋愛レボリューション２１ -秋葉工房MIX- [Scarz] - 6
LOVE IS TIMING [chewi] - 2
3 [tamtamino] - 3
REVIEWS
[DIAVOLO BRACKET]
That Man [Oni-91] - HM
Pretty good file. Definitely not what I would expect in this competition. Then again, you're the one with the out-of-left-field song choices. Expert chart seemed slightly off with the 12ths, but I'm sure they're fine. 8/10.
Rattlesnake [Pandemonium X] - WINNER
Okay, this was pretty fun. BPM was doubled, but it works just fine considering the rhythms. 9/10.
---------------------------------------------
BLACK.by X-Cross Fade [tsugaru7reveng] - WINNER
This was pretty good; felt a little offsync (probably just me). Was really fun. 9/10.
Red Balloon [Astroman129] - HM
Good file, I just liked the other one more. Jump stream didn't fit right IMO. Also, the song has a similar melody to Gold Dust by DJ Fresh, and that distracted me. 8/10.
---------------------------------------------
---------------------------------------------
[FUBUKI BRACKET]
Pizza Rolls [Loodee]
I guess it's not a bad file, but maybe you should have moved each difficulty up one and made a new Basic chart. Expert felt like it was hard for the sake of being hard; the speed was too low IMO for that level of difficulty on Expert.
I will compliment your use of rolls, however, given the title of the song. ;) 7/10.
No Tears [CLOUDIO] - WINNER
I liked this. It's pretty fun, and the difficulty is right where it needs to be. I did feel like there were some doublesteps near the beginning. 8/10.
---------------------------------------------
童話回廊 [Silverhawke] - WINNER
I liked this. The irregularity of the song means that you have to play this a few times to get it down. It caught me off-guard. Also had to go down to x1.5 to play this (not a complaint). 8.25/10.
I Am the Best [Pie-kun] - HM
I liked this one as well. The Expert chart was very nice. Felt slightly offsync, didn't damage the quality of the file though. Sorry Pie, but I had to nitpick to get a winner. 8/10.
---------------------------------------------
---------------------------------------------
[DO BACK BURN BRACKET]
Move That Body [Gameoson]
First BPM change (measure 12) seems messed up. While it's on-sync, the beats don't even match up at all. 7.75/10.
Expert: Pretty good chart, can't really say much about it aside the above. 8/10.
Challenge: See above. It also seemed a little bit too difficult at the beginning. 7.5/10.
Copy & Paste [DDRDAIKENKAI] - WINNER!
I loved this file. Please make more like this. 8.5/10.
Expert: Pretty standard chart, something I'd definitely play on pad. 8/10.
Challenge: Wow, that was pretty good! I think it's more of a 9, but I really loved it! 9/10.
---------------------------------------------
tiger yamato [xXMokou98xX] - HM vs Come & Get It [hooky]
Funny how we both used gimmicks in our files this week. TBH, yours are more erratic but fit better with the song. I really messed up measure 50 in my file. While your stops keep the notes in the proper places, the one in measure 50 of C&GI turns what should be a 4th-16th-8th triple tap into all 4th notes, which apparently is confusing since that's what people seem to be complaining about (some are complaining about the BPM changes, but that's more subjective imo). Anyway, I hope I win this round, but I wouldn't be mad if you did. I believe this is the furthest I've gone so far, so I did something right. I give tiget yamato an 8/10.
---------------------------------------------
---------------------------------------------
[CHRONOXIA BRACKET]
tig-hug [TaroNuke] - HM
I really really really really really really like... this. Apologies to Carly Rae. I still don't understand what rolls are for though. 8.5/10.
恋愛レボリューション２１ -秋葉工房MIX- [Scarz] - WINNER
I liked this just slightly more. 8.75/10.
---------------------------------------------
LOVE IS TIMING [chewi] - HM
I liked this, but it honestly could have used a Challenge chart. 8/10.
3 [tamtamino] - WINNER
Pretty good Expert chart. Loved the spins when Britney sings "180 degrees".
I think measures 16 and 20 should be more similar since the structure of those parts of the song are pretty much identical. Otherwise, it's really good. 8.5/10.
That Man [Oni-91] - HM
Pretty good file. Definitely not what I would expect in this competition. Then again, you're the one with the out-of-left-field song choices. Expert chart seemed slightly off with the 12ths, but I'm sure they're fine. 8/10.
Rattlesnake [Pandemonium X] - WINNER
Okay, this was pretty fun. BPM was doubled, but it works just fine considering the rhythms. 9/10.
---------------------------------------------
BLACK.by X-Cross Fade [tsugaru7reveng] - WINNER
This was pretty good; felt a little offsync (probably just me). Was really fun. 9/10.
Red Balloon [Astroman129] - HM
Good file, I just liked the other one more. Jump stream didn't fit right IMO. Also, the song has a similar melody to Gold Dust by DJ Fresh, and that distracted me. 8/10.
---------------------------------------------
---------------------------------------------
[FUBUKI BRACKET]
Pizza Rolls [Loodee]
I guess it's not a bad file, but maybe you should have moved each difficulty up one and made a new Basic chart. Expert felt like it was hard for the sake of being hard; the speed was too low IMO for that level of difficulty on Expert.
I will compliment your use of rolls, however, given the title of the song. ;) 7/10.
No Tears [CLOUDIO] - WINNER
I liked this. It's pretty fun, and the difficulty is right where it needs to be. I did feel like there were some doublesteps near the beginning. 8/10.
---------------------------------------------
童話回廊 [Silverhawke] - WINNER
I liked this. The irregularity of the song means that you have to play this a few times to get it down. It caught me off-guard. Also had to go down to x1.5 to play this (not a complaint). 8.25/10.
I Am the Best [Pie-kun] - HM
I liked this one as well. The Expert chart was very nice. Felt slightly offsync, didn't damage the quality of the file though. Sorry Pie, but I had to nitpick to get a winner. 8/10.
---------------------------------------------
---------------------------------------------
[DO BACK BURN BRACKET]
Move That Body [Gameoson]
First BPM change (measure 12) seems messed up. While it's on-sync, the beats don't even match up at all. 7.75/10.
Expert: Pretty good chart, can't really say much about it aside the above. 8/10.
Challenge: See above. It also seemed a little bit too difficult at the beginning. 7.5/10.
Copy & Paste [DDRDAIKENKAI] - WINNER!
I loved this file. Please make more like this. 8.5/10.
Expert: Pretty standard chart, something I'd definitely play on pad. 8/10.
Challenge: Wow, that was pretty good! I think it's more of a 9, but I really loved it! 9/10.
---------------------------------------------
tiger yamato [xXMokou98xX] - HM vs Come & Get It [hooky]
Funny how we both used gimmicks in our files this week. TBH, yours are more erratic but fit better with the song. I really messed up measure 50 in my file. While your stops keep the notes in the proper places, the one in measure 50 of C&GI turns what should be a 4th-16th-8th triple tap into all 4th notes, which apparently is confusing since that's what people seem to be complaining about (some are complaining about the BPM changes, but that's more subjective imo). Anyway, I hope I win this round, but I wouldn't be mad if you did. I believe this is the furthest I've gone so far, so I did something right. I give tiget yamato an 8/10.
---------------------------------------------
---------------------------------------------
[CHRONOXIA BRACKET]
tig-hug [TaroNuke] - HM
I really really really really really really like... this. Apologies to Carly Rae. I still don't understand what rolls are for though. 8.5/10.
恋愛レボリューション２１ -秋葉工房MIX- [Scarz] - WINNER
I liked this just slightly more. 8.75/10.
---------------------------------------------
LOVE IS TIMING [chewi] - HM
I liked this, but it honestly could have used a Challenge chart. 8/10.
3 [tamtamino] - WINNER
Pretty good Expert chart. Loved the spins when Britney sings "180 degrees".
I think measures 16 and 20 should be more similar since the structure of those parts of the song are pretty much identical. Otherwise, it's really good. 8.5/10.Post #372 · Posted at 2015-04-08 11:28:39am 9.1 years ago
| tsugaru7reveng | |
|---|---|
 |
Member+ |
| 1,430 Posts | |
 | |
| Reg. 2006-06-02 | |
[DIAVOLO BRACKET]
That Man [Oni-91] - 5
Rattlesnake [Pandemonium X] - 2
BLACK.by X-Cross Fade [tsugaru7reveng] - 6
Red Balloon [Astroman129] - 1
[FUBUKI BRACKET]
Pizza Rolls [Loodee] - 3
No Tears [CLOUDIO] - 5
童話回廊 [Silverhawke] - 3
내가 제일 잘 나가 [Pie-kun] - 5
NOTE: This one IMO is a REALLY TIGHT MATCHUP. I'd love to give both of these votes.
[DO BACK BURN BRACKET]
Move That Body [Gameoson] - 1
Copy & Paste [DDRDAIKENKAI] - 5
tiger yamato [xXMokou98xX] - 6
Come & Get it [hooky] - 1
[CHRONOXIA BRACKET]
tig-hug [TaroNuke] - 1
恋愛レボリューション２１ -秋葉工房MIX- [Scarz] - 7
LOVE IS TIMING [chewi] - 3
3 [tamtamino] - 3
That Man [Oni-91] - 5
Rattlesnake [Pandemonium X] - 2
BLACK.by X-Cross Fade [tsugaru7reveng] - 6
Red Balloon [Astroman129] - 1
[FUBUKI BRACKET]
Pizza Rolls [Loodee] - 3
No Tears [CLOUDIO] - 5
童話回廊 [Silverhawke] - 3
내가 제일 잘 나가 [Pie-kun] - 5
NOTE: This one IMO is a REALLY TIGHT MATCHUP. I'd love to give both of these votes.
[DO BACK BURN BRACKET]
Move That Body [Gameoson] - 1
Copy & Paste [DDRDAIKENKAI] - 5
tiger yamato [xXMokou98xX] - 6
Come & Get it [hooky] - 1
[CHRONOXIA BRACKET]
tig-hug [TaroNuke] - 1
恋愛レボリューション２１ -秋葉工房MIX- [Scarz] - 7
LOVE IS TIMING [chewi] - 3
3 [tamtamino] - 3
Post #373 · Posted at 2015-04-08 09:54:07pm 9.1 years ago
| Gameoson | |
|---|---|
 |
Member |
| 955 Posts | |
| | |
| Reg. 2014-03-03 | |
 | |
Quote: hooky
Move That Body [Gameoson]
First BPM change (measure 12) seems messed up. While it's on-sync, the beats don't even match up at all.
First BPM change (measure 12) seems messed up. While it's on-sync, the beats don't even match up at all.
I have no idea what you're trying to say here.
Post #374 · Posted at 2015-04-09 01:48:18am 9.1 years ago
Quote: hooky
I liked [LOVE IS TIMING], but it honestly could have used a Challenge chart.
Politely disagreeing. Not everything needs to be hard.Post #375 · Posted at 2015-04-09 03:03:33am 9.1 years ago
| Pandemonium X | |
|---|---|
|
Member |
| 10,360 Posts | |
| | |
| Reg. 2007-04-06 | |
| |
Quote: Gameoson
Quote: hooky
Move That Body [Gameoson]
First BPM change (measure 12) seems messed up. While it's on-sync, the beats don't even match up at all.
First BPM change (measure 12) seems messed up. While it's on-sync, the beats don't even match up at all.
I have no idea what you're trying to say here.
Post #376 · Posted at 2015-04-09 12:14:57pm 9.1 years ago
| Oni-91 | |
|---|---|
 |
Moderator+ |
| 13,505 Posts | |
 | |
| Reg. 2006-10-20 | |
| |
| "Popular bisexual disaster" | |
Last updated: 2015-04-09 12:17pm
Quote: chewi
Quote: hooky
I liked [LOVE IS TIMING], but it honestly could have used a Challenge chart.
Politely disagreeing. Not everything needs to be hard.And no, that's not a challenge to anyone reading to make an ITG 11 out of it. You're better than this, guys.
(Also votes coming up tonight when I'm in a position to actually review these, you might get proper reviews too if you're nice)
Post #377 · Posted at 2015-04-09 02:26:36pm 9.1 years ago
| Loodee | |
|---|---|
 |
Member+ |
| 275 Posts | |
 | |
| Reg. 2014-06-26 | |
[DIAVOLO BRACKET]
That Man [Oni-91] - 6
Rattlesnake [Pandemonium X] - 2
BLACK.by X-Cross Fade [tsugaru7reveng] - 6
Red Balloon [Astroman129] - 2
[FUBUKI BRACKET]
Pizza Rolls [Loodee] - 3
No Tears [CLOUDIO] - 5
童話回廊 [Silverhawke] - 4
내가 제일 잘 나가 [Pie-kun] - 5
[DO BACK BURN BRACKET]
Move That Body [Gameoson] - 2
Copy & Paste [DDRDAIKENKAI] - 5
I have to agree on the bpm changes in Move That Body being unnecessary, except for perhaps the one in the middle. The 1.5x speedup near the beginning definitely felt unneeded. The steps were really nice though, interesting patterns and only a few spots where I felt the rhythm was missed. Fun to play, especially with cmods
Copy & Paste was not at all a bad file. Although there were one or two spots where I think the rhythm didn't match up, the steps are very solid and I have no real complaints as far as charting quality goes. The song however, has a lot less options for fun steps, which is why it doesn't match up to Move That Body.
tiger yamato [xXMokou98xX] - 7
Come & Get it [hooky] - 1
I can't say that tiger yamato was the most fun thing ever to play, but the steps are as good as can be for the song and the gimmicks fit well.
Come & Get it could probably have been a much better file, but it has it's flaws, some of which have already been pointed out, most notably the speedup and the gimmicks. Cmodding can bypass those issues, but I still felt that during big parts of the song, especially in the first half, the steps didn't match the rhythm very well at all. Either that, or there was some crazy layering going on that I couldn't keep up with. It's far from a boring file though, which is imo probably one of the worst traits a chart can have. Potential in this file for sure, just needs some fair polishing.
[CHRONOXIA BRACKET]
tig-hug [TaroNuke] - 1
恋愛レボリューション２１ -秋葉工房MIX- [Scarz] - 7
(not voting on this one, can't decide)
恋愛レボリューション２１ -秋葉工房MIX could have used a
chart. I felt there were lots of missed steps in the 
, making it feel like a watered down imaginary chart in some places
LOVE IS TIMING [chewi] - 3
3 [tamtamino] - 4
I completely agree with hooky, imo this song screams for a , much more so than 恋愛レボリューション. The rhythm isn't easy to accurately step, but as it stands right now, the totally doesn't make the song justice. Don't get me wrong, the heavy chart is fine for what it is, but there is so much more that could have been done by just following sounds in the song.
To be fair, 3 wasn't anything too interesting either, mostly due to the song. Making the player spin when the vocals go "180 degrees" was neat though V:
That Man [Oni-91] - 6
Rattlesnake [Pandemonium X] - 2
BLACK.by X-Cross Fade [tsugaru7reveng] - 6
Red Balloon [Astroman129] - 2
[FUBUKI BRACKET]
Pizza Rolls [Loodee] - 3
No Tears [CLOUDIO] - 5
童話回廊 [Silverhawke] - 4
내가 제일 잘 나가 [Pie-kun] - 5
[DO BACK BURN BRACKET]
Move That Body [Gameoson] - 2
Copy & Paste [DDRDAIKENKAI] - 5
I have to agree on the bpm changes in Move That Body being unnecessary, except for perhaps the one in the middle. The 1.5x speedup near the beginning definitely felt unneeded. The steps were really nice though, interesting patterns and only a few spots where I felt the rhythm was missed. Fun to play, especially with cmods
Copy & Paste was not at all a bad file. Although there were one or two spots where I think the rhythm didn't match up, the steps are very solid and I have no real complaints as far as charting quality goes. The song however, has a lot less options for fun steps, which is why it doesn't match up to Move That Body.
tiger yamato [xXMokou98xX] - 7
Come & Get it [hooky] - 1
I can't say that tiger yamato was the most fun thing ever to play, but the steps are as good as can be for the song and the gimmicks fit well.
Come & Get it could probably have been a much better file, but it has it's flaws, some of which have already been pointed out, most notably the speedup and the gimmicks. Cmodding can bypass those issues, but I still felt that during big parts of the song, especially in the first half, the steps didn't match the rhythm very well at all. Either that, or there was some crazy layering going on that I couldn't keep up with. It's far from a boring file though, which is imo probably one of the worst traits a chart can have. Potential in this file for sure, just needs some fair polishing.
[CHRONOXIA BRACKET]
tig-hug [TaroNuke] - 1
恋愛レボリューション２１ -秋葉工房MIX- [Scarz] - 7
(not voting on this one, can't decide)
恋愛レボリューション２１ -秋葉工房MIX could have used a
chart. I felt there were lots of missed steps in the , making it feel like a watered down imaginary chart in some places LOVE IS TIMING [chewi] - 3
3 [tamtamino] - 4
Quote: chewi
Quote: hooky
I liked [LOVE IS TIMING], but it honestly could have used a Challenge chart.
Politely disagreeing. Not everything needs to be hard. , much more so than 恋愛レボリューション. The rhythm isn't easy to accurately step, but as it stands right now, the totally doesn't make the song justice. Don't get me wrong, the heavy chart is fine for what it is, but there is so much more that could have been done by just following sounds in the song.To be fair, 3 wasn't anything too interesting either, mostly due to the song. Making the player spin when the vocals go "180 degrees" was neat though V:
Post #378 · Posted at 2015-04-09 02:44:53pm 9.1 years ago
| CLOUDIO | |
|---|---|
 |
Member |
| 474 Posts | |
 | |
| Reg. 2012-11-28 | |
| "also known as MEGAtive" | |
[DIAVOLO BRACKET]
That Man [Oni-91] - 6
Rattlesnake [Pandemonium X] - 3
BLACK.by X-Cross Fade [tsugaru7reveng] - 7
Red Balloon [Astroman129] - 2
[FUBUKI BRACKET]
Pizza Rolls [Loodee] - 3
No Tears [CLOUDIO] - 5
童話回廊 [Silverhawke] - 5
내가 제일 잘 나가 [Pie-kun] - 5
[DO BACK BURN BRACKET]
Move That Body [Gameoson] - 2
Copy & Paste [DDRDAIKENKAI] - 6
tiger yamato [xXMokou98xX] - 8
Come & Get it [hooky] - 1
[CHRONOXIA BRACKET]
tig-hug [TaroNuke] - 1
恋愛レボリューション２１ -秋葉工房MIX- [Scarz] - 8
LOVE IS TIMING [chewi] - 4
3 [tamtamino] - 4
That Man [Oni-91] - 6
Rattlesnake [Pandemonium X] - 3
BLACK.by X-Cross Fade [tsugaru7reveng] - 7
Red Balloon [Astroman129] - 2
[FUBUKI BRACKET]
Pizza Rolls [Loodee] - 3
No Tears [CLOUDIO] - 5
童話回廊 [Silverhawke] - 5
내가 제일 잘 나가 [Pie-kun] - 5
[DO BACK BURN BRACKET]
Move That Body [Gameoson] - 2
Copy & Paste [DDRDAIKENKAI] - 6
tiger yamato [xXMokou98xX] - 8
Come & Get it [hooky] - 1
[CHRONOXIA BRACKET]
tig-hug [TaroNuke] - 1
恋愛レボリューション２１ -秋葉工房MIX- [Scarz] - 8
LOVE IS TIMING [chewi] - 4
3 [tamtamino] - 4
Post #379 · Posted at 2015-04-09 04:56:14pm 9.1 years ago
Quote: Pandemonium X
Quote: Gameoson
Quote: hooky
Move That Body [Gameoson]
First BPM change (measure 12) seems messed up. While it's on-sync, the beats don't even match up at all.
First BPM change (measure 12) seems messed up. While it's on-sync, the beats don't even match up at all.
I have no idea what you're trying to say here.
The whole idea of that BPM change was that the song was becoming more intense, but wasn't built up quite enough to be full speed yet. It's pretty much the same idea behind the BPM changes in INNOCENCE OF SILENCE.
I'll admit, a lot of Move That Body (both
and ) was me trying some new things. Personally I found it to be a lot of fun, but I can see why some people are turned off by it.Post #380 · Posted at 2015-04-09 06:19:04pm 9.1 years ago
| chewi | |
|---|---|
|
Member+ |
| 8,537 Posts | |
| Not Set | |
| Reg. 2008-02-24 | |
Quote: Loodee
but there is so much more that could have been done by just following sounds in the song.
Just my opinion again, but I really don't like when I play a chart and the steps follow the song closely. If I wanted to do that, I would go play IIDX or something. I prefer to make my files flow in a way where you're "dancing", like in DDR... fun charts are good.