Logo

Idea: Post Reporting & User Rating Penalties

Thread Locked Back To Forums

Post #1 · Posted at 2009-12-05 09:23:13am 14.3 years ago

Offline al2k4
al2k4 Avatar Admin
9,387 帖子
United Kingdom
Reg. 2006-05-01

Nintendo Switch Friend Code: SW-6451-2397-9509
"BEMANI Sound Team"
A post reporting feature may come in the future for the sake of forum post quality.

This is where users can flag any individuals' post as disruptive, irrelevant, offensive, etc... and an administrator can look at how many people have flagged the post and can take appropriate action.

While not banning outright, I have been thinking of a rating penalty system, where a percentage is taken away from their rating.

Each offense will add 10% to the penalty percentage.

The amount of rating taken away, or the penalty is as follows: (Current Rating+100) x Penalty%

So if a user has a rating of 75 and they have been disrupting the forums with image macros, useless YouTube videos. Their post may be reported and an offense is registered with the Zenius database. The site will add 10% to that user's penalty.

The user's new rating will be as follows:

New Rating = Current Rating - Penalty
New Rating = Current Rating - ((Current Rating + 100) x Penalty%)
New Rating = 75 - ((75 + 100) x 10%)
New Rating = 75 - (175 x 10%)
New Rating = 75 - 17.5
New Rating = 57.5

Offend ten times, and get 100% and this is what happens to the user:

New Rating = 75 - ((75 + 100) x 100%)
New Rating = 75 - (175 x 100%)
New Rating = 75 - 175
New Rating = -100

-100 means an unconditional ban on the user.

Feedback and suggestions welcome as I am trying to make the forums a better place for everyone to participate in.

Another note, 10% penalty will get removed every 2 weeks IF the user hasn't commited any offenses since then.

Post #2 · Posted at 2009-12-05 09:40:26am 14.3 years ago

Offline Silver Spirit
Silver Spirit Avatar Member
6,580 帖子
United States
Reg. 2008-09-14

Nintendo Switch Friend Code: SW-2249-7707-55923DS Friend Code: 2578-3309-2697
"i was born at a very young age"
'Bout time this was thrown out there.

Post #3 · Posted at 2009-12-05 09:54:03am 14.3 years ago

Offline Meseki
Meseki Avatar Member
681 帖子
United States
Reg. 2008-07-08

You're going to have to make sure it doesn't help your rating when it's negative.
IIDX Rank: SP 九段 (7/8)/ DP 七段 (5/8); 1P Side player
SP 11* Clears: 132/150 (88.00%); 12* Clears: 23/96 (23.96%)
Has access to CS 9th-EMP+PB+US, uses extended KOCs.

Post #4 · Posted at 2009-12-05 09:56:50am 14.3 years ago

Offline Bolt-Edge
Bolt-Edge Avatar Member
2,361 帖子
United States
Reg. 2008-06-03

"No."
absolute value, go.
A̷̴̷͎̣̪̯̰̺͕͕̦͙̙̥͚̤͔̺̰ͭ̃ͯ͆̋ͨͧͩ̏̓̓ͨͤͨ̈ͫ͗̎͢ͅw̷̳̯̠̥ͦ̇̽̀̀ͩͯ͆̈̎̾͛̏͒͑ͩ̑͑͡ͅa̵̯̤̗͈̞̱͎͔͕͖͈̤͎͓͍̝͈̍͌̆ͨͤ̏͆͛̕͢ͅk̸̢͇̫̳̖̥̣̜̤̟̫͓̝̙̰̮ͪ͗̔ͣͧͩ͊̅̒̏̆͜ͅȩ̵̴̻̻͈͇̣͎͈͈͖̮̪͎̻͉̀ͣͭ̔ͮͭ̈́̎͑̽͌ͯͮ̑̉͑̀͘͞n̙͚̫͈̻̰͓͂͆ͣ̉ͬͯͩ͌ͤ̎͗̂̅͊̎ͥ̒́͢͟͠ͅ ̡̄̇̐̏ͦ͑̋͒̍̀ͯ̍̆͌̄̚҉̵͏̣͕̺͈̤̣̱͉̥̗̲̙̟̩̗̪̳̦̹m̵̵̖̭̺̰̭̣ͧ̑̌̔ͩ͡y͋̇̃̎̚͜҉̠͚̺̣̯̟͖̙͉̘̞̥͙̼̯͉̬ͅ ̶̸̬̝̥̦̫̦͓̗͚̈́̆͊̉ͤͤ̿͡C̷̛̣̳͕͔̳̤̬̻̩͍̝͙̹̏̿̔͊ͪ̓̂̎͝ͅḩ̷̤͈͙̫̾ͤ̌ͩ̽͌͑̾ͩ̓̄͢ȋ̵̧̙̲̪̱͓͉̟̾ͬ̊̅ͧ͆̀͟͜l̢͕͚̺̰̘̠̜̼̪̥͔̪̤̫͇̟̏̇̆͛͌ͥͪ̐͋ͨ̈̾͐̑̏͘͘͟d̢̨̙̩̣̞̫̞̖͕͎̄ͦ͂ͪͭ͛̔̿͋̄̔̐̒ͥ̚̕͟͜ ̶̨͓̯̫̹͉͚̬͕̙̦̰͗͌̽ͪ͡ͅͅAͩͤ̍̔ͦ͋͑ͫ̐̓̿̈́ͬͨͭ͏̸͕͈̥̮͇͖̼̝̺̤̩͙̲̙̭̖͡͠ͅn̢̟͔̰̬̦̹͑͑̌͒͑̉́́ḑ̶̵̨̮̘̩̗̘̪̮̬̤̙͖̺̭̖͖͍͈͓̯͑͒̐̍͛ͧ̊̔ͫ̇͟ ̣̻͉͙̯̺̔͋ͣ̾ͤ̌̿̕̕͜ͅȩ̎ͤ̌́ͣ̇̃͋ͨ̀ͩͦ̔̎̿͟͏̡̯̞͎̳͈̘̺͍̯̳̥̳͡m̵̶̨͎̘̗̩̗̩̠̦̮̼͈͖̹̼͇͆̅ͤ̈́̊̊̏ͪ̾̂ͅb̧̧̨͚̞̯̤̻ͥͩ͐̉̾́r̨͚͎̜͓̲̥̤̜̤͙̫ͨͤ̆͋͒̑ͧͯ̎̚͘͜ͅa̴̋̽ͦͨͤ͑ͮ́̚͜͏̯̪̰̞̩͙̳͈̖͎̘̞͇̥͇̫c̴̢̣̝͖̭̬̫̻̩̆̉͂̓ͯ̔̽͑̌͊̌ͦ́͢ę̦͚̜̟̻͕̻̖̰̱̞̱̹̣̪̭̙ͦ̆ͦ͗̾̂ͪ͑̋̎̎̃̄ͬ͗͗̋̀ ̝̯̹̻̩͚̱͚̽̈́͂ͭͮͤ͘t̥͎̫̘̫̫̰͈͔̔̓̅̇̌̑̈́̒ͯ͌͐̎̀̅͑̆́ͅh̡̆̍ͬ̿̈́͊̄̌̃́̄͑̅̏ͤ͏̬̙̦͉̭͈̝͎̩̦͎̮̬̀ę̸̞̼̲̫̯̪͈̉͑͒̏ͭ͊̀̿̚ ̶̨̨̛̣͓̻̰̭̰̮͎̲̦̲͐̑̒ͥͯ̈͌̌̆͛g̛͉̫̼̙̩̤̦̣̖̙̹̮̳̾̿͌̐ͥ̈ͩͫ̚̕͜͡͠lͫ͆̄͋ͥ̂͛̀̚͏̸͕̦̥̗̦̻͇̜͎̹͎̺ͅơ̸̶̢͍͔͖̞͙͚̺̹̩͙̹͉͔ͣ̔ͤ̐ͧ̈̇̂̍ͯ̚ͅr̸̸̛̰̺̩͍̼̪͚̟̱͔̯̈͒̊̀ͭͦ͘y̧ͯ͛͋ͣ̐͆̉̅ͤ͐̂̓͊̕͏̵̪̪̦̩̼̣͔̦̪͎̗͔̮̻̞͖̕ ̡͉̺̲̘̖̲͚̭̲̜̦̞̪̗̤̹̱̲͚̇̽ͯͤ͜ṯ̹̲̖̦̝̮̲͓̲͉̘͛̓̆̽̇̓̈́̄ͧͨ̋͗͘͞͞ḩ̛̜̺̞̼͙̫͍̭̟̯̳̱̻͖͚͊͋̉ͥ̉ͤ̇ͨ̄̉ͨ̏̃̂ͅͅa̢̞̞̗͔̥̟͉̝̺̼̺̮̓̈ͥͪ͗ͧͭ̓́̀͘ͅt̛̥͉̘̣̳́̔͗͛ͦ̆̾͆͂̋ͧ̈ͥ̋̉͝ ̻̲͔͍̪͚̠̠̣̳̟̱̲̤̥͎͓̲̐̑̾͗̄̉̆̊ͤ̇͌̒ͦͥ̚̚͡͠i̴̛̩͓͖̹̥̹̣̥̼̼̮̠͋̅̆̐̎ͫ̒͊ͦ̏̐͌̈͂̐͌̿̚͞ş̜̗̩͖̻̺͉̜̝̯̟̺̰̭̥̟͖̳̈́̆̋̂ͣ̚͟ͅ ̥͔͔͖̰̙̰̬͕̲̞͓̤̎ͭ̌̎ͩͧͤ͗ͮͯ̾̔̑̈̂͘y͑͒̌ͬ̽̌ͧ͗̄̎͟͏͕̰̫̫͈͚̤̫̙o͆͗̓͐͒̏̀̿ͫ̾̑̈́̓ͧ̚̚҉̷̟̼̮̺̠͕͈͔̣̮̬̥̣͙͙̲̖̹͕͢͡͠u̠̳̱̩͚̩̮̖̩̝̗̫͖̞̲͕̞ͥ̎͑͗ͥ̍ͩͫͤ͑̔̎͑̒ͦ̒́͜͡r̢͈̝͔͎̤̝̻̝͉̻̻͉̰ͬ̍́ͤ͆͑ͩͦ̋ͮ̋̓̅ͬͫ̃̕ ̸̵̶̶̣͍̭̞̪̫͕̞̬̞̙̭̦͚̗͚̏͛̑̎̐͊͛̒̃ͭ̄̄ͬͩ͡b̶̴͎̳̰̫̞͔̰̰̺͉̻̮̲̪̜̏̽͋̓̐͌̋ͬ̊̽͋͋̈̀̓̀̆͜͢͞ͅi̛ͦ̒ͥ̕͜͞҉͓͖̲r̟̺̗̤̘̟̋ͦͪ̾̿͒̇̒̋ͩ̅͒ͮͫ̑͘͠ť̷̴̉̽ͫͩ̏͊ͬ͂͑̅ͥ͐́̅͗҉͏̣͉̦̜͢ͅh̵͎͙̲̰̳̯͖̄̿̉͑̎̾̎͑͗̍͑̾̐͊́ ̫̻͕̳̤͓͔̞̯̈́͌̇̅ͮ̒͛ͣ̀͝r̴̸͈͔͉̤̻̘̱̹̹̺̻͚̙͖͆̐͐ͯͩ͊ͭ̾̌̃̑ͯ̇͠i͎͔̥̬̜̝̝͚̤̪̖͈̙̞ͭͪ̿ͧ͗̀ġ̞̲̮̣̼͍̹̞͔͇̘ͬ̏͛̆ͪ̒̆́̕h̾ͣͤ̃̔ͬ͊̐ͬ̃̋̓ͦ̓͋͌͗̿͏̢̦͔̰̤͍̻̭̬̺̬̥̹͔͍͎ͅṯ̶̢̛̭̻̹͎̝̘̳̞̫̣̝̑̌̊̊͆̒͆̀͘͞

Post #5 · Posted at 2009-12-05 10:08:17am 14.3 years ago

Offline -Viper-
-Viper- Avatar Member+
2,407 帖子
United States
Reg. 2007-10-26

3DS Friend Code: 1091-8797-8693
Cool.

However, couldn't this be abused even more so than the -5's given out for stupid reasons?

Post #6 · Posted at 2009-12-05 10:12:07am 14.3 years ago

Offline Bolt-Edge
Bolt-Edge Avatar Member
2,361 帖子
United States
Reg. 2008-06-03

"No."
The flags would be evaluated by Al. Posts with a high number of flags have a higher chance of getting a penalty.
A̷̴̷͎̣̪̯̰̺͕͕̦͙̙̥͚̤͔̺̰ͭ̃ͯ͆̋ͨͧͩ̏̓̓ͨͤͨ̈ͫ͗̎͢ͅw̷̳̯̠̥ͦ̇̽̀̀ͩͯ͆̈̎̾͛̏͒͑ͩ̑͑͡ͅa̵̯̤̗͈̞̱͎͔͕͖͈̤͎͓͍̝͈̍͌̆ͨͤ̏͆͛̕͢ͅk̸̢͇̫̳̖̥̣̜̤̟̫͓̝̙̰̮ͪ͗̔ͣͧͩ͊̅̒̏̆͜ͅȩ̵̴̻̻͈͇̣͎͈͈͖̮̪͎̻͉̀ͣͭ̔ͮͭ̈́̎͑̽͌ͯͮ̑̉͑̀͘͞n̙͚̫͈̻̰͓͂͆ͣ̉ͬͯͩ͌ͤ̎͗̂̅͊̎ͥ̒́͢͟͠ͅ ̡̄̇̐̏ͦ͑̋͒̍̀ͯ̍̆͌̄̚҉̵͏̣͕̺͈̤̣̱͉̥̗̲̙̟̩̗̪̳̦̹m̵̵̖̭̺̰̭̣ͧ̑̌̔ͩ͡y͋̇̃̎̚͜҉̠͚̺̣̯̟͖̙͉̘̞̥͙̼̯͉̬ͅ ̶̸̬̝̥̦̫̦͓̗͚̈́̆͊̉ͤͤ̿͡C̷̛̣̳͕͔̳̤̬̻̩͍̝͙̹̏̿̔͊ͪ̓̂̎͝ͅḩ̷̤͈͙̫̾ͤ̌ͩ̽͌͑̾ͩ̓̄͢ȋ̵̧̙̲̪̱͓͉̟̾ͬ̊̅ͧ͆̀͟͜l̢͕͚̺̰̘̠̜̼̪̥͔̪̤̫͇̟̏̇̆͛͌ͥͪ̐͋ͨ̈̾͐̑̏͘͘͟d̢̨̙̩̣̞̫̞̖͕͎̄ͦ͂ͪͭ͛̔̿͋̄̔̐̒ͥ̚̕͟͜ ̶̨͓̯̫̹͉͚̬͕̙̦̰͗͌̽ͪ͡ͅͅAͩͤ̍̔ͦ͋͑ͫ̐̓̿̈́ͬͨͭ͏̸͕͈̥̮͇͖̼̝̺̤̩͙̲̙̭̖͡͠ͅn̢̟͔̰̬̦̹͑͑̌͒͑̉́́ḑ̶̵̨̮̘̩̗̘̪̮̬̤̙͖̺̭̖͖͍͈͓̯͑͒̐̍͛ͧ̊̔ͫ̇͟ ̣̻͉͙̯̺̔͋ͣ̾ͤ̌̿̕̕͜ͅȩ̎ͤ̌́ͣ̇̃͋ͨ̀ͩͦ̔̎̿͟͏̡̯̞͎̳͈̘̺͍̯̳̥̳͡m̵̶̨͎̘̗̩̗̩̠̦̮̼͈͖̹̼͇͆̅ͤ̈́̊̊̏ͪ̾̂ͅb̧̧̨͚̞̯̤̻ͥͩ͐̉̾́r̨͚͎̜͓̲̥̤̜̤͙̫ͨͤ̆͋͒̑ͧͯ̎̚͘͜ͅa̴̋̽ͦͨͤ͑ͮ́̚͜͏̯̪̰̞̩͙̳͈̖͎̘̞͇̥͇̫c̴̢̣̝͖̭̬̫̻̩̆̉͂̓ͯ̔̽͑̌͊̌ͦ́͢ę̦͚̜̟̻͕̻̖̰̱̞̱̹̣̪̭̙ͦ̆ͦ͗̾̂ͪ͑̋̎̎̃̄ͬ͗͗̋̀ ̝̯̹̻̩͚̱͚̽̈́͂ͭͮͤ͘t̥͎̫̘̫̫̰͈͔̔̓̅̇̌̑̈́̒ͯ͌͐̎̀̅͑̆́ͅh̡̆̍ͬ̿̈́͊̄̌̃́̄͑̅̏ͤ͏̬̙̦͉̭͈̝͎̩̦͎̮̬̀ę̸̞̼̲̫̯̪͈̉͑͒̏ͭ͊̀̿̚ ̶̨̨̛̣͓̻̰̭̰̮͎̲̦̲͐̑̒ͥͯ̈͌̌̆͛g̛͉̫̼̙̩̤̦̣̖̙̹̮̳̾̿͌̐ͥ̈ͩͫ̚̕͜͡͠lͫ͆̄͋ͥ̂͛̀̚͏̸͕̦̥̗̦̻͇̜͎̹͎̺ͅơ̸̶̢͍͔͖̞͙͚̺̹̩͙̹͉͔ͣ̔ͤ̐ͧ̈̇̂̍ͯ̚ͅr̸̸̛̰̺̩͍̼̪͚̟̱͔̯̈͒̊̀ͭͦ͘y̧ͯ͛͋ͣ̐͆̉̅ͤ͐̂̓͊̕͏̵̪̪̦̩̼̣͔̦̪͎̗͔̮̻̞͖̕ ̡͉̺̲̘̖̲͚̭̲̜̦̞̪̗̤̹̱̲͚̇̽ͯͤ͜ṯ̹̲̖̦̝̮̲͓̲͉̘͛̓̆̽̇̓̈́̄ͧͨ̋͗͘͞͞ḩ̛̜̺̞̼͙̫͍̭̟̯̳̱̻͖͚͊͋̉ͥ̉ͤ̇ͨ̄̉ͨ̏̃̂ͅͅa̢̞̞̗͔̥̟͉̝̺̼̺̮̓̈ͥͪ͗ͧͭ̓́̀͘ͅt̛̥͉̘̣̳́̔͗͛ͦ̆̾͆͂̋ͧ̈ͥ̋̉͝ ̻̲͔͍̪͚̠̠̣̳̟̱̲̤̥͎͓̲̐̑̾͗̄̉̆̊ͤ̇͌̒ͦͥ̚̚͡͠i̴̛̩͓͖̹̥̹̣̥̼̼̮̠͋̅̆̐̎ͫ̒͊ͦ̏̐͌̈͂̐͌̿̚͞ş̜̗̩͖̻̺͉̜̝̯̟̺̰̭̥̟͖̳̈́̆̋̂ͣ̚͟ͅ ̥͔͔͖̰̙̰̬͕̲̞͓̤̎ͭ̌̎ͩͧͤ͗ͮͯ̾̔̑̈̂͘y͑͒̌ͬ̽̌ͧ͗̄̎͟͏͕̰̫̫͈͚̤̫̙o͆͗̓͐͒̏̀̿ͫ̾̑̈́̓ͧ̚̚҉̷̟̼̮̺̠͕͈͔̣̮̬̥̣͙͙̲̖̹͕͢͡͠u̠̳̱̩͚̩̮̖̩̝̗̫͖̞̲͕̞ͥ̎͑͗ͥ̍ͩͫͤ͑̔̎͑̒ͦ̒́͜͡r̢͈̝͔͎̤̝̻̝͉̻̻͉̰ͬ̍́ͤ͆͑ͩͦ̋ͮ̋̓̅ͬͫ̃̕ ̸̵̶̶̣͍̭̞̪̫͕̞̬̞̙̭̦͚̗͚̏͛̑̎̐͊͛̒̃ͭ̄̄ͬͩ͡b̶̴͎̳̰̫̞͔̰̰̺͉̻̮̲̪̜̏̽͋̓̐͌̋ͬ̊̽͋͋̈̀̓̀̆͜͢͞ͅi̛ͦ̒ͥ̕͜͞҉͓͖̲r̟̺̗̤̘̟̋ͦͪ̾̿͒̇̒̋ͩ̅͒ͮͫ̑͘͠ť̷̴̉̽ͫͩ̏͊ͬ͂͑̅ͥ͐́̅͗҉͏̣͉̦̜͢ͅh̵͎͙̲̰̳̯͖̄̿̉͑̎̾̎͑͗̍͑̾̐͊́ ̫̻͕̳̤͓͔̞̯̈́͌̇̅ͮ̒͛ͣ̀͝r̴̸͈͔͉̤̻̘̱̹̹̺̻͚̙͖͆̐͐ͯͩ͊ͭ̾̌̃̑ͯ̇͠i͎͔̥̬̜̝̝͚̤̪̖͈̙̞ͭͪ̿ͧ͗̀ġ̞̲̮̣̼͍̹̞͔͇̘ͬ̏͛̆ͪ̒̆́̕h̾ͣͤ̃̔ͬ͊̐ͬ̃̋̓ͦ̓͋͌͗̿͏̢̦͔̰̤͍̻̭̬̺̬̥̹͔͍͎ͅṯ̶̢̛̭̻̹͎̝̘̳̞̫̣̝̑̌̊̊͆̒͆̀͘͞

Post #7 · Posted at 2009-12-05 10:12:28am 14.3 years ago

Offline PyroManiacX
PyroManiacX Avatar Member
3,758 帖子
United States
Reg. 2007-09-23

"Not dead yet!"
Yeah thats what I think too or they will find an comment offensive if someone doesnt agree with a comment
http://i26.photobucket.com/albums/c113/lordtoon/Song%20Title/MDCXCII.pnghttp://i26.photobucket.com/albums/c113/lordtoon/User%20Names/PyroManiacX.pnghttp://i849.photobucket.com/albums/ab54/zivrewards/ZIV%20Award%20Committee/PyromaniacX.png

Post #8 · Posted at 2009-12-05 10:20:05am 14.3 years ago

Offline Max
Max Avatar Member+
8,111 帖子
United States
Reg. 2008-02-05

Nintendo Network ID: maxninja1143DS Friend Code: 392661848995Game Center Nickname: maxninja114
"Charlie isn't real"
An EXTREMELY much better way than to just -5 someone for their posts, let's get this up Smile

Post #9 · Posted at 2009-12-05 10:55:08am 14.3 years ago

Offline silenttype01
silenttype01 Avatar Member+
8,022 帖子
United States
Reg. 2007-01-19

"DINGDONG♥HEARTS"
So this is why it took you so long to make this thread.

Thi doesn't seem like a bad idea, though it may have the potential to be abused.

There's a difference between seeing how many users flag a post and which users flag a post. One can simply make multiple accounts to flag a post - stupid I know, but it can happen. Rather than ask a question, I'd like to be corrected on what I'm thinking: the administrators wll be able to see who flags a post, right?


Post #10 · Posted at 2009-12-05 11:45:42am 14.3 years ago

Offline finalfan2cwiz
finalfan2cwiz Avatar Member+
966 帖子
United States
Reg. 2007-12-29

Origin: finalfan2cwizGame Center Nickname: Ddrplaya
Sounds like an awesome Idea Alan :-D

I do agree with silent though, I see there being a problem with people abusing this.

As long as when someone is flagged, you review it before final judgement of a penalty I think it will work out great

Post #11 · Posted at 2009-12-05 12:17:34pm 14.3 years ago

Offline Pandemonium X
Pandemonium X Avatar Member
10,358 帖子
United States
Reg. 2007-04-06

Nintendo Network ID: PandemoniumEJPNintendo Switch Friend Code: SW-2916-7192-8116
Quote: silenttype01
This doesn't seem like a bad idea, though it may have the potential to be abused.
Quoted for truth.

Post #12 · Posted at 2009-12-05 12:20:58pm 14.3 years ago

Offline silenttype01
silenttype01 Avatar Member+
8,022 帖子
United States
Reg. 2007-01-19

"DINGDONG♥HEARTS"
I thank pandy for reminding me. Quoting people without adding to the discussion, followed by a bunch of members quoting the same thing: does it count as a offense as well?

Post #13 · Posted at 2009-12-05 12:45:21pm 14.3 years ago

Offline Pandemonium X
Pandemonium X Avatar Member
10,358 帖子
United States
Reg. 2007-04-06

Nintendo Network ID: PandemoniumEJPNintendo Switch Friend Code: SW-2916-7192-8116
Quote: silenttype01
I thank pandy for reminding me. Quoting people without adding to the discussion, followed by a bunch of members quoting the same thing: does it count as a offense as well?
I added QFT now, is that better?

This gets me a little worried. Not that I'm going to be flagged for every little screw up I do no matter who big or small (you know who you are), but it's almost fraughting to post. I'm talking to the point where some people will be so paranoid, that they will not post. I am liking how you REALLY have to screw up for your points to go way down and it has to be reviewed by Al.

This is a very risky move I must say.Confused

Post #14 · Posted at 2009-12-05 01:09:54pm 14.3 years ago

Offline KKiONI
KKiONI Avatar Member
2,470 帖子
Canada
Reg. 2007-12-06

Nintendo Network ID: KKiONI3DS Friend Code: 2320-6631-1671
"BEEJAY REVEL A"
Quote: Pandemonium X
Quote: silenttype01
I thank pandy for reminding me. Quoting people without adding to the discussion, followed by a bunch of members quoting the same thing: does it count as a offense as well?
I added QFT now, is that better?

This gets me a little worried. Not that I'm going to be flagged for every little screw up I do no matter who big or small (you know who you are), but it's almost fraughting to post. I'm talking to the point where some people will be so paranoid, that they will not post. I am liking how you REALLY have to screw up for your points to go way down and it has to be reviewed by Al.

This is a very risky move I must say.Confused
You do make a good point. I myself am cautious of what I post so that I don't cause a disturbance of some kind (well most of the time at least). This idea does indeed have potential, but we have to consider some of the worst things that can go wrong so they can be worked out and improved. Mostly being flagged for something very minor. Now instead of selecting from categories, may I suggest having a text input so that one could enter their own reason for flagging? It's hard to explain my logic behind how it would be better over just selecting a category, but one thing I do know is that one could explain more in detail why he/she flagged someone else (for example an minor argument that progressed into a huge argument in a thread)

Post #15 · Posted at 2009-12-05 01:12:21pm 14.3 years ago

Offline Max
Max Avatar Member+
8,111 帖子
United States
Reg. 2008-02-05

Nintendo Network ID: maxninja1143DS Friend Code: 392661848995Game Center Nickname: maxninja114
"Charlie isn't real"
Quote: KKiONI
...Now instead of selecting from categories, may I suggest having a text input so that one could enter their own reason for flagging? It's hard to explain my logic behind how it would be better over just selecting a category, but one thing I do know is that one could explain more in detail why he/she flagged someone else (for example an minor argument that progressed into a huge argument in a thread)
This could actually work out, because anybody on this site can easily click a link to flag someone without giving much care/not even knowing/following "the crowd".

This way it would actually narrow it down to explaining the actions of the user flagging the person's post.

Post #16 · Posted at 2009-12-05 01:16:44pm 14.3 years ago

Offline KKiONI
KKiONI Avatar Member
2,470 帖子
Canada
Reg. 2007-12-06

Nintendo Network ID: KKiONI3DS Friend Code: 2320-6631-1671
"BEEJAY REVEL A"
Quote: Max
Quote: KKiONI
...Now instead of selecting from categories, may I suggest having a text input so that one could enter their own reason for flagging? It's hard to explain my logic behind how it would be better over just selecting a category, but one thing I do know is that one could explain more in detail why he/she flagged someone else (for example an minor argument that progressed into a huge argument in a thread)
This could actually work out, because anybody on this site can easily click a link to flag someone without giving much care/not even knowing/following "the crowd".

This way it would actually narrow it down to explaining the actions of the user flagging the person's post.
This is exactly what I'm trying to point out. If reports are consistent, then a penalty can be given, but if the reports all different, then it could be either be discredited or it can be looked into more if need be

Post #17 · Posted at 2009-12-05 01:20:43pm 14.3 years ago

Offline Pandemonium X
Pandemonium X Avatar Member
10,358 帖子
United States
Reg. 2007-04-06

Nintendo Network ID: PandemoniumEJPNintendo Switch Friend Code: SW-2916-7192-8116
Quote: Max
Quote: KKiONI
...Now instead of selecting from categories, may I suggest having a text input so that one could enter their own reason for flagging? It's hard to explain my logic behind how it would be better over just selecting a category, but one thing I do know is that one could explain more in detail why he/she flagged someone else (for example an minor argument that progressed into a huge argument in a thread)
This could actually work out, because anybody on this site can easily click a link to flag someone without giving much care/not even knowing/following "the crowd".

This way it would actually narrow it down to explaining the actions of the user flagging the person's post.

Not only that, It would be revived by Al. So someone can't just say "Flag this guy, he did not put a period at the end of his post" or "This guy is a moron, flag him".

OR

Something I just thought of. For a post to be a flagged, it has to be flagged so many times. This way we don't have member A bullying member B. Example: a post has to be flanged say 5 times by different members to have User Rating Penalties.

Post #18 · Posted at 2009-12-05 01:33:13pm 14.3 years ago

Offline KKiONI
KKiONI Avatar Member
2,470 帖子
Canada
Reg. 2007-12-06

Nintendo Network ID: KKiONI3DS Friend Code: 2320-6631-1671
"BEEJAY REVEL A"
Quote: Pandemonium X
Quote: Max
Quote: KKiONI
...Now instead of selecting from categories, may I suggest having a text input so that one could enter their own reason for flagging? It's hard to explain my logic behind how it would be better over just selecting a category, but one thing I do know is that one could explain more in detail why he/she flagged someone else (for example an minor argument that progressed into a huge argument in a thread)
This could actually work out, because anybody on this site can easily click a link to flag someone without giving much care/not even knowing/following "the crowd".

This way it would actually narrow it down to explaining the actions of the user flagging the person's post.

Not only that, It would be revived by Al. So someone can't just say "Flag this guy, he did not put a period at the end of his post" or "This guy is a moron, flag him".

OR

Something I just thought of. For a post to be a flagged, it has to be flagged so many times. This way we don't have member A bullying member B. Example: a post has to be flanged say 5 times by different members to have User Rating Penalties.
Oh do you mean like if a member posted something that broke posting rules and like 3 members for example flagged it saying the same thing, the problem would only be reviewed until the flag count reaches 5? If that's what you mean, I think that sounds pretty good. The number 5 sounds a bit lenient, but that's just my opinion.

Post #19 · Posted at 2009-12-05 01:54:39pm 14.3 years ago

Offline Pandemonium X
Pandemonium X Avatar Member
10,358 帖子
United States
Reg. 2007-04-06

Nintendo Network ID: PandemoniumEJPNintendo Switch Friend Code: SW-2916-7192-8116
I got another question. Can you get flagged for old comment?

Post #20 · Posted at 2009-12-05 01:56:15pm 14.3 years ago

Offline silenttype01
silenttype01 Avatar Member+
8,022 帖子
United States
Reg. 2007-01-19

"DINGDONG♥HEARTS"
Obviously.

Alan knows better so he'll ignore those.
Thread Locked Back To Forums

0 User(s) Viewing This Thread (Past 15 Minutes)

©2006-2024 Zenius -I- vanisher.com -5th style- IIPrivacy Policy
Web Server: 4% · Database: 8% · Server Time: 2024-03-28 16:39:50
This page took 0.008 seconds to execute.
Theme: starlight · Language: chinesetraditional
Reset Theme & Language