Rank the DDR Games from worst to best (in your opinion)

What's your list? mine is this.

16. MAX
15. X
14. 1st Mix
13. 2013
12. 2014
11. Supernova
10. MAX 2
9. Extreme
8. 3rd Mix
7. 4th Mix
6. X2
5. X3 Vs 2nd Mix
4. 2nd Mix
3. A
2. Supernova
1. 5th Mix
(I didn't put A20 on here cause it hasn't been out long enough for my full conclusion on it)

This is an extremely difficult question, as so many different factors make me love each DDR game differently. But if I had to go off of every factor of what I love about every game (Content, nostalgia, look, etc.), I'd go with this.

16 // X
15-13 // 1st mix - 3rd mix
12 // 5th mix
11 // 4th mix
10 // MAX 2
9 // Supernova
8 // MAX
7 // Supernova 2
6 // X2
5 // 2013
4 // X3 vs. 2nd mix
3 // EXTREME
2 // Ace
1 // 2014

Most of these were very, very hard to chose (Except X) and are very close in quality (Except X)

1st place: Ace
2nd: X3 vs 2nd Mix
3rd: Extreme
4th: 5th Mix
5th: 2014
6th: SuperNOVA
7th: 4th Mix
8th: X2
9th: X
10th: SuperNOVA 2

Haven't actually played the rest.

---

Haven't played many of the arcade games, but:

2013 > X2 > A > Extreme > X3 > 2014 > SuperNOVA 2 > SuperNOVA > a wall you can't climb > X

X2 > A > 2014 > 2013 > EXTREME > Supernova 2 > X3 > Supernova > X

---

A > EXTREME > MAX2 > 2014 > X3 > X2 > SN2 > SN1 > X

---

Of the mainline series games that I’ve played: Ace > 5th > 3rd (Korean v2) > Extreme > 2014 > Max 2 > 4th Plus > Max > X3 > X2 > SN > SN2 > X

For me...

Extreme > X2 > 5thmix > Supernova > Supernova 2 > 3rdmix > 4thmix > A > DDR MAX > DDR MAX 2 > 2013 > X3 > 2014 > X

---

1) EXTREME
2) 5th mix
3) 4th mix plus
4)3rd mix plus
5) MAX2 (cause it had all the good max stuff plus all the returning KOs)
6)MAX
7) 2nd mix
8) 1st mix
9) SN 2
10) X2
11) X3
12)A
12)SN
13)2013-2014
14) X

Of the ones I've played for extended periods of time/more than once:
Ace > Max 2 > 5th Mix > Supernova 2 > X2 > Supernova > 2013/2014 > Extreme > X

---

SuperNOVA 2 > Ace > EXTREME > 4th Mix PLUS > Everything else

SN2 had a great selection in new songs, the best chart quality in "normal" songs (especially considering there are very few "boring" charts) and very cool boss songs IMO

Very surprised to see that everyone has SN2 so far down...

---

I'm honestly more surprised MAX 2 is ranked so low; they improved a lot of the issues MAX1 had (brought back older songs, brought back the ratings chart, etc.). I do, however, love the fact everyone hates X.

I haven't really played a lot of the AC DDR games, so...

A > Extreme > MAX 2 > 4th Mix Plus (admittedly I have not played this one, but would love to have a CHD of that if I ever got a DDR cab) > 5th Mix > MAX 1 > 3rd Mix Korea Ver (so many songs missing, and Knott's Berry Farm had it for the longest time. XDD) > USA > X (never played that one, but I'm with the hivemind. XD)

Didn't mention stuff like SuperNova 1/2 because I didn't get to really play them, since where I lived was an arcade desert before Round1 came to the area, but I did once play SN2 when I was at DisneyQuest... too bad the people I played it with kept picking Xepher; I have a bit of a grudge with that song because of it was practically the only time I got to play SN2 at the arcade...

With me, even though I have the SN games low on my list, there's a huge gulf in between those and X, hence "a wall you can't climb". It's only down that low because I don't have the older games to put on that list to fill the gaps :v

A > X2 > 2014 > X3 > 3rd > SN2 > Extreme > X > 5th > max2 > 2013

unpopular opinion

A > 5th > X > X2 > SN2 > X3 > MAX2 > SN > Extreme > Max > 2013 > 4th > 1st-3rd > 2014

---

16. DDR X. Ugly theme, terrible new announcer, terrible X-special charts, terrible western cabs, what about this game aside from On the Bounce do I even consider worth a shit?

15. DDR 2013. This is the poorest mix of the modern era, in my opinion. Very generic theme and a songlist that made me wish Japan would just stop creating music. If I recall correctly, also plagued with crashes.

14. DDR 1st/1.5. Gets points for being the game that started it all, at least. Introduced us to the duo of PARANOiA and Trip Machine that remain the two most remixed Konami originals to this day, but also had some of that weirdness that could only stem from the first game ever made in the franchise. A curious piece of video game history.

13. DDR 2014. Lower than most would put it, right? I just thought this installment was rather sloppy. Remember that bug where selecting EGOISM 440 could crash the machine? Yeah, that was funny. The game's most known for the Replicant d-Ignition event that nobody fuckin' liked.

12. DDR MAX. Yeah, it introduced Healing Vision Angelic Mix and MAX300, and had some songs like FLASH IN THE NIGHT that really deserve more love, but the engine was pretty janked and getting rid of the difficulty ratings was a dumb idea. Thankfully, they brought them back in the console release.

11. DDR 2nd. The game where KONAMI ironed out a lot of weird shit in the 1st game and added more of everything that made it work. Not much more to say about this one.

10. DDR SuperNOVA. Personally, my favourite menu music in DDR! Also... uh... it had Healing-D-Vision? Yeah, this game was weird. After four years of absence following EXTREME, DDR returned with this game, and it was universally considered "eh". Hardcore players would be hanging onto their r21s for a few more years, but these were EVERYWHERE in spaces that encouraged casual play. Shocking considering EXTREME only featured a single 16 while this game had a few 17s and even 18s. (None of the 18s being good)

9. DDR 3rd/3rd PLUS. Arguably the most famous mix of DDR in history, being the basis for DS EuroMIX, DDR USA, and being literally EVERYWHERE. While it has the legendary status, it doesn't hold up too well today, with some pretty questionable charts in the upper difficulties, and the "jukebox" songwheel not being a good choice for a game with this amount of music. It worked with 10-20 songs, but now there's just too many.

8. DDR X3 vs 2nd Mix. The HD remake of 2nd Mix in the game was really cool and the game had some cool originals (with it expecting you to play Trip Machine Evolution and Paranoia Revolution on 2ND MIX MODE originally. Like fuck that was gonna happen) but it fell flat in the theme department and felt like, aside from 2nd Mix mode, these songs could've just been updated into X2 and nothing of worth would've been lost.

7. DDR SuperNOVA2. I struggled for some time deciding where to put the two SuperNOVA games on this list, but I decided around the middle as these games really... felt like a mix of both the worst of DDR and best of DDR. SuperNOVA2 was the first game to make Marvelous judgement a standard in gameplay, adding a MASSIVE amount of replay value for high-tier players. It's just a shame the timing window for it was shitty and unpredictable. Also, this game is notable for being the last game before the announcer swap that we've sadly had to live with up until current day.

6. DDR MAX2. MAX wasn't that great of an AC mix, but I feel like this one really put the franchise back on track. With an impressive increase in songs and the introduction of Challenge courses, I think the actual best thing about this game is that bloody colour scheme. Is there ANYONE who doesn't like the black theme? Looks beautiful. The only thing that holds this back is that, in my opinion, the big soundtrack doesn't really have too many... enjoyable new songs in it. Sorry.

5. DDR 5th. Many consider this an extremely underrated mix, and while I agree that it's one of the better ones, I think most people just say that because of how much stuff was removed from this in MAX. The songs in this game give it a very distinct, unique personality among DDR mixes, with bizzare stuff like the theme from Enter the Dragon. It's an interesting game for sure, and the uniqueness definitely bumped it up a few places.

4. DDR 4th/4th PLUS. Looking back on the games from 1 to 5, this one was the best in my opinion. A VERY unique theme with even a custom songwheel that hasn't been seen before or since, a cool female announcer, this game was original as hell and the songlist was pretty damn good too. An all-around classic mix.

3. DDR A/Ace. Fuck me, I struggled to place this one the most. I hate the menu music and the overall theme of the game is rather average, so why does this rank so high? One word: playability. For the first time, they have fixed Marvelous timing so scoring is now much more fun and much less luck-based. This single change shot the game from about 10th position all the way up here because it's simply the best engine DDR has ever had.

2. DDR EXTREME. What a lot of people to be consider overrated, I consider to be placed right at the top with the best. I don't care what people think, even though the theme was essentially a green MAX2, the amount of good content in this was staggering at the time. They improved the courses, added more charts, had some crossovers no one would've ever thought would make it... It's the best 573 mix of all time and you can't change my mind.

1. DDR X2. No surprises here if you know me. The crossover game was strong with this one, and considering it brought many of my all-time favourite songs and charts to DDR, it's only a good thing. The events were cool, the theme was sleek yet understated, and it's the game that really brought me back to the franchise in my early teens after being semi-familiar as a wee lad.

So there's my list. Probably debatable as all hell, but it's my opinion, so whatever.

---

Extreme > SN2 > SN 1 > A > X3 vs. 2nd Mix

Some of the first ones I played are dear to me. Definitely Extreme and Supernova were my favorites.

Based on my personal opinion about the songlist and the events involved, even if i didn't played all of them:

The worst: X
- 2014
- SN
- 1st mix
- SN2
- 2nd mix
- 2013
- X3 vs 2nd mix
- 5th mix
- MAX
- 3rd mix
- MAX 2
- 4th mix
- EXTREME
- A
The Best: X2

Uhhhhh I have a bias toward the new stuff, and on just gonna rank the arcade ones I've actually been able to play.

(Least to most favorite)

5th mix
MAX2
X (the only reason it's even this far up is 'cause of Zero, I can't lie)
Supernova
Extreme
Supernova2
2013/2014 (not even sure how to rank it when I prolly played this the least)
X3 (actually didn't play much at all except for what was on the Wii game, but the soundtrack is that baller)
A
D D R ECKS TWOOOOOOOOOOO come on

A20 is a contender for being second best, so far. Can't imagine how to dethrone X2 for me. I loved the soundtrack, a bunch of the charts, obviously when the character designs were actually new, watching people stretch their sanity over Replicant D Action...

---

[Rank] : [Game] - [Song+Charts] / [Interface Design+Functionality] = [Average Rating]
17th : DDR 1st - 6.8 / 6.3 = 6.5
16th : 2ndMIX (including append versions) - 7.0 / 6.8 = 6.9
14th : DDR (2014) - 6.3 / 8.3 = 7.3
14th : 4thMIX (and 4thMIX PLUS) - 8.0 / 6.5 = 7.3
13th : DDRMAX - 7.0 / 8.0 = 7.5
12th : 5thMIX - 7.3 / 8.0 = 7.6
10th : DDR (2013) - 7.3 / 8.3 = 7.8
10th : SuperNOVA - 7.0 / 8.6 = 7.8
9th : 3rdMIX (and 3rdMIX PLUS) - 8.0 / 7.8 = 7.9
7th : DDRMAX2 - 7.8 / 8.3 = 8.0
7th : DDR X - 7.5 / 8.6 = 8.0
5th : SuperNOVA2 - 7.8 / 8.4 = 8.1
5th : DDR X3 vs. 2ndMIX - 8.3 / 7.9 = 8.1
4th : EXTREME - 8.6 / 7.8 = 8.2
3rd : A20 (may change over time) - 8.5 / 8.4 = 8.4
2nd : DDR X2 - 8.6 / 8.5 = 8.6
1st : DDR A - 8.5 / 9.4 = 8.9

---