Logo

Current Record For Most Songs In A Dance Game

     
Thread Locked | Back To Forums

Post #21 · Posted at 2012-01-14 11:36:28am 2.9 years ago

Offline Daniel_BMS
Daniel_BMS Avatar Badge Member+
191 Posts
United States
Reg. 2007-09-01
22.6pts
Log in to send this user a private messageYouTube
Xbox Gamer Tag: DanielBMS
I posted this to take care of the off chance that somebody might know something I may not find, but for now I am going with my research that concludes that Mungyodance 3 has the record. It's a Stepmania based game that has a theme designed around the content so it counts as a dance game.

Post #22 · Posted at 2012-01-14 12:21:40pm 2.9 years ago

Offline AnonyWolf
AnonyWolf Avatar Badge Member+
1,312 Posts
United States
Reg. 2009-10-17
154.7pts
Log in to send this user a private messageSkype: theanonywolfFacebookTwitter: AnonyWolfSoundcloudTumblrYouTube
PlayStation Network: AnonyWolfSteam: AnonyWolf3DS Friend Code: 3883-7652-3160
"Everything Will Be Jolly..."
StepMania engines do not count.

Try again.
http://card.psnprofiles.com/1/AnonyWolf.png

Post #23 · Posted at 2012-01-14 03:08:13pm 2.9 years ago

Offline Max
Max Avatar Badge Member+
7,698 Posts
United States
Reg. 2008-02-05
612.2pts
Log in to send this user a private messageWindows Live Messenger: maxxunlimited114[at]hotmail.comSkype: Julian AlayonFacebookTwitter: maxninja09Google+TumblrYouTube
PlayStation Network: maxninja114Wii Friend Code: 3095166183267994Nintendo Network ID: maxninja114Steam: maxninja093DS Friend Code: 392661848995Game Center Nickname: maxninja114GREE Username: Julian
"GARUGAMESH"
Quote: AnonyWolf
StepMania engines do not count.

Try again.
This x100000000000000

Post #24 · Posted at 2012-01-14 07:45:35pm 2.9 years ago

Offline mageman17
mageman17 Avatar Badge Member
1,979 Posts
Qatar
Reg. 2008-06-15
294.5pts
Log in to send this user a private messageYahoo Instant Messenger: japanese_youngsterSkype: mageman17Facebook
"MAGGLE"
I dunno, I really don't count DLC for home consoles as part of the songlist, since it's added-on content and made after the game's songlist has been finalized. But then again, Rock Band is not a dance game.

On a guess, I'd say X2 AC. Or maybe even Pump NX or Fiesta (whichever has more old content, particularly Caution).
https://fbcdn-sphotos-h-a.akamaihd.net/hphotos-ak-prn2/v/1062382_10201572769465595_128160513_n.jpg?oh=9754e27f3e3abfc87705f8fbb04171b7&oe=51EF2FCF&__gda__=1374640178_2eb448a145b3702ac93532ea3195d6c3

Post #25 · Posted at 2012-01-16 12:01:24am 2.9 years ago

Offline FlameyBoy
FlameyBoy Avatar Badge Member
90 Posts
United States
Reg. 2011-03-09
37.7pts
Log in to send this user a private message
I personally don't get why MGD3 doesn't count if ITG does, but okay. They're both SM.

For "legitimate" games, X3 seems to be the winner right now. Fiesta EX only has about 300 normal songs.

Post #26 · Posted at 2012-01-16 02:27:41am 2.9 years ago

Offline Daniel_BMS
Daniel_BMS Avatar Badge Member+
191 Posts
United States
Reg. 2007-09-01
22.6pts
Log in to send this user a private messageYouTube
Xbox Gamer Tag: DanielBMS
The idea that non commercial games can't be real video games is regressive. Especially when you consider how much work went into Mungyodance 3.

Post #27 · Posted at 2012-01-16 02:39:23am 2.9 years ago

Offline Max
Max Avatar Badge Member+
7,698 Posts
United States
Reg. 2008-02-05
612.2pts
Log in to send this user a private messageWindows Live Messenger: maxxunlimited114[at]hotmail.comSkype: Julian AlayonFacebookTwitter: maxninja09Google+TumblrYouTube
PlayStation Network: maxninja114Wii Friend Code: 3095166183267994Nintendo Network ID: maxninja114Steam: maxninja093DS Friend Code: 392661848995Game Center Nickname: maxninja114GREE Username: Julian
"GARUGAMESH"

Last updated: 2012-01-16 02:48am
Quote: Daniel_BMS
The idea that non commercial games can't be real video games is regressive. Especially when you consider how much work went into Mungyodance 3.
It is only recognized by about 3 to 5k people while DDR, PIU, and even ITG is recognized worldwide, has close to millions of followers or people who can recognize it off the bat, IS MADE BY A LEGITIMATE GAME COMPANY, and have people that actually work on brand new releases about each year.

MGD3 is just a SM theme with songs that anyone can put into it, would i consider it an indie game? Technically not seeing that it's only a SM theme pack, Stepmania is surely an indie game but not something that's a theme for the game, that would just be additional content for the game. Oh hey! We were having discussions about DLC content and how it technically doesn't count in terms of the game's in-game songs since they are ADDITIONAL CONTENT to a game that was already put out as is, so i still go under my backing that DDR still has the higher songlist than any other Dance game out there.

APPEND: If i offend any simfile makers or stepmania theme makers, i am sorry, but basing a record for a game that is not recognized as an official game in itself when in reality the "game" is just really a stepmania theme pack is just bogus to me. Stepmania would be a much more reasonable answer but MGD3? Come on...

Post #28 · Posted at 2012-01-16 02:42:54am 2.9 years ago

Online Pie-kun Chatting
Pie-kun Avatar Badge Member+
6,019 Posts
United States
Reg. 2007-03-25
969.0pts
Log in to send this user a private messageWindows Live Messenger: piepiepie75[at]hotmail.comAOL Instant Messenger: piepiepie75Skype: piepiepie75FacebookTwitter: pie_kunTumblr
CROSS×BEATS User ID: 61742417
Quote: Max
DDR, PIU, and even ITG is recognized worldwide, has close to millions of followers or people who can recognize it off the bat

DDR yes. PIU maybe. ITG lolno.



Post #29 · Posted at 2012-01-16 02:44:37am 2.9 years ago

Offline Max
Max Avatar Badge Member+
7,698 Posts
United States
Reg. 2008-02-05
612.2pts
Log in to send this user a private messageWindows Live Messenger: maxxunlimited114[at]hotmail.comSkype: Julian AlayonFacebookTwitter: maxninja09Google+TumblrYouTube
PlayStation Network: maxninja114Wii Friend Code: 3095166183267994Nintendo Network ID: maxninja114Steam: maxninja093DS Friend Code: 392661848995Game Center Nickname: maxninja114GREE Username: Julian
"GARUGAMESH"
Quote: Pie-kun
Quote: Max
DDR, PIU, and even ITG is recognized worldwide, has close to millions of followers or people who can recognize it off the bat
DDR yes. PIU maybe. ITG lolno.
Just giving an example Pie ;)

Post #30 · Posted at 2012-01-16 02:46:40am 2.9 years ago

Online Pie-kun Chatting
Pie-kun Avatar Badge Member+
6,019 Posts
United States
Reg. 2007-03-25
969.0pts
Log in to send this user a private messageWindows Live Messenger: piepiepie75[at]hotmail.comAOL Instant Messenger: piepiepie75Skype: piepiepie75FacebookTwitter: pie_kunTumblr
CROSS×BEATS User ID: 61742417
Just didn't want you giving ITG more credit than it deserves. At this point most ITG fans essentially just play custom simfiles exclusively, so I don't know that you could even call them ITG players.

Post #31 · Posted at 2012-01-16 02:48:03am 2.9 years ago

Offline Max
Max Avatar Badge Member+
7,698 Posts
United States
Reg. 2008-02-05
612.2pts
Log in to send this user a private messageWindows Live Messenger: maxxunlimited114[at]hotmail.comSkype: Julian AlayonFacebookTwitter: maxninja09Google+TumblrYouTube
PlayStation Network: maxninja114Wii Friend Code: 3095166183267994Nintendo Network ID: maxninja114Steam: maxninja093DS Friend Code: 392661848995Game Center Nickname: maxninja114GREE Username: Julian
"GARUGAMESH"
Quote: Pie-kun
Just didn't want you giving ITG more credit than it deserves. At this point most ITG fans essentially just play custom simfiles exclusively, so I don't know that you could even call them ITG players.
You're right, plus it's also a Stepmania-based engine hey HEY! Big Grin

Post #32 · Posted at 2012-01-16 02:48:47am 2.9 years ago

Offline Daniel_BMS
Daniel_BMS Avatar Badge Member+
191 Posts
United States
Reg. 2007-09-01
22.6pts
Log in to send this user a private messageYouTube
Xbox Gamer Tag: DanielBMS
Mungyodance 3 has songs you will never see in a commercial dance game. That is why limiting the definition of a video game to a commercial game is regressive.

Post #33 · Posted at 2012-01-16 02:51:58am 2.9 years ago

Offline Max
Max Avatar Badge Member+
7,698 Posts
United States
Reg. 2008-02-05
612.2pts
Log in to send this user a private messageWindows Live Messenger: maxxunlimited114[at]hotmail.comSkype: Julian AlayonFacebookTwitter: maxninja09Google+TumblrYouTube
PlayStation Network: maxninja114Wii Friend Code: 3095166183267994Nintendo Network ID: maxninja114Steam: maxninja093DS Friend Code: 392661848995Game Center Nickname: maxninja114GREE Username: Julian
"GARUGAMESH"
Quote: Daniel_BMS
Mungyodance 3 has songs you will never see in a commercial dance game. That is why limiting the definition of a video game to a commercial game is regressive.
So limiting the song list to have the game not be released anywhere is a credential for Most Songs in a Dance Game since you said they would NEVER BE SEEN anywhere else?

Yeah i think we have a winrar guys.

Post #34 · Posted at 2012-01-16 03:14:47am 2.9 years ago

Offline mageman17
mageman17 Avatar Badge Member
1,979 Posts
Qatar
Reg. 2008-06-15
294.5pts
Log in to send this user a private messageYahoo Instant Messenger: japanese_youngsterSkype: mageman17Facebook
"MAGGLE"

Last updated: 2012-01-16 03:14am
Why do we count ITG in this discussion? Because it was released not only as a PC game, but also as an arcade game and a PS2 game. And these releases run on a modified stepmania engine (adds support for mines, drops support for .mp3 and .dwi files, IIRC). These are the reasons I consider ITG to be included in this discussion. The same also applies for Pump Pro, which used a modified SM4 engine.
I don't consider r21 and hacked songs as part of the songlist.


Why is MGD 3 not counted? It's a theme+simfile pack and you need to get Stepmania separately to run it.

APPEND: For some people's sake, I am not counting MGD's not being a commercial game as a factor.
https://fbcdn-sphotos-h-a.akamaihd.net/hphotos-ak-prn2/v/1062382_10201572769465595_128160513_n.jpg?oh=9754e27f3e3abfc87705f8fbb04171b7&oe=51EF2FCF&__gda__=1374640178_2eb448a145b3702ac93532ea3195d6c3

Post #35 · Posted at 2012-01-16 03:26:53am 2.9 years ago

Online Pie-kun Chatting
Pie-kun Avatar Badge Member+
6,019 Posts
United States
Reg. 2007-03-25
969.0pts
Log in to send this user a private messageWindows Live Messenger: piepiepie75[at]hotmail.comAOL Instant Messenger: piepiepie75Skype: piepiepie75FacebookTwitter: pie_kunTumblr
CROSS×BEATS User ID: 61742417
ITG doesn't need to be included simply for the fact that it doesn't have the most songs in a dance game. Just because they added custom song support doesn't make its songlist infinity.

Post #36 · Posted at 2012-01-16 03:27:58am 2.9 years ago

Offline Tyma
Tyma Avatar Badge Member
2,201 Posts
Not Set
Reg. 2006-05-31
525.4pts
Log in to send this user a private messageWindows Live Messenger: msn[at]tyma.netTwitter: tymastyle
Steam: Tyma3DS Friend Code: 2595-1148-0077

Last updated: 2012-01-16 03:28am
Do we really have to explain why a fan-made re-skin of someone else's game shouldn't be considered as legitimate game?

If I called up the ESRB in the morning and told them that my Connect simfile had 10,000 downloads and should be listed in the weekly sales chart as having more downloads than Call Of Duty, do you think they'd consider it a legitimate game? If I threw it and some other simfiles into a zip file, packaged it with Stepmania and drew some characters from Disneys Robin Hood on the title screen, do you think they'd consider that an indie game?

Post #37 · Posted at 2012-01-16 05:07:59am 2.9 years ago

Offline Daniel_BMS
Daniel_BMS Avatar Badge Member+
191 Posts
United States
Reg. 2007-09-01
22.6pts
Log in to send this user a private messageYouTube
Xbox Gamer Tag: DanielBMS
Quote: mageman17
Why is MGD 3 not counted? It's a theme+simfile pack and you need to get Stepmania separately to run it.

What? Mungyodance 3 uses modified Stepmania, and it's content is encrypted. I have the Mungyodance Stepmania gameplay packages, but I have never seen it's theme separately.
     
Thread Locked | Back To Forums

0 User(s) Viewing This Thread (Past 15 Minutes)

©2006-2014 Zenius -I- vanisher.com -5th style- II
Web Server: 1% · Database: 4%
This page took 0.09 seconds to execute.
Theme: starlight · Language: german
Reset Theme & Language